26 ms·
Evidence suggests - and my experience agrees - that correctly teaching process creates the ground-work for moving to understanding. Considering you are talking
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Evidence suggests - and my experience agrees - that correctly teaching process creates the ground-work for moving to understanding.
Considering you are talking about evidence, where is yours?
I agree that a lot of people make unsupported generalizations about "what works" and "what doesn't work". I'm simply doubtful you can really propose a practical alternative, not even hypothetically practical alternative.
I would assert that part of this how extremely difficult it to really determine better teaching methods scientifically, controlling for expectation, controlling for multiple socio-economic factors, controlling for each child's background, etc, etc.
The rather rough experiments that anyone can point to show at best that "X works reasonably with teacher of X ability with student of X socio-economic position".
Inherently, just about every teaching method is "insufficiently researched". Just about every way that we deal with human beings is "ready, fire, aim" because we simply don't have the resources to fully, scientifically tease out what's the best dealing with the many, many dimensions of human behavior.
I'm not against social science because it's better to try to be a systematically as possible. I am against deluding oneself into thinking social science will work like natural, that it will come up with generalized laws that one can follow without constant adjustment.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoYou ask the very reasonable question: > Considering you are talking about evidence, > where is yours? As I say in http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1679203 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1679203 > No, sorry, I can't cite the research off-hand, > it's been shown to me by others and I don't > have the references We're not really arguing different points here - we're both saying it's bloody difficult to do "proper" research in this area, and even harder to come up with anything that's guaranteed to work. I've seen a lot of papers written and witnessed a lot of different techniques. I've seen first hand several fads, and most things work for some children with the right teachers. But I am concerned with the way the whole thing is approached, in part because I have a PhD in math and I know that "research" when in an area that involves people is really, really hard. Especially with children. I know that things have to be done differently in education research, and people who do the work are doing their best. I observe that the situation is still appalling - there's more that needs to be done. I have my personal opinions about what might work, but they are unsupported by anything like scientific evidence, and I'm working closely with both teachers and education researchers to see if my ideas can be tested, and if so, whether they can be made to work. But I won't air them here. ADDED IN EDIT: Wow - a down-vote. Wonder what I said that made someone feel that this comment is of negative value. Interesting.
- mikeklaas 16y ago> ADDED IN EDIT: Wow - a down-vote. Wonder what I said that made someone feel that this comment is of negative value. Interesting. It's really not worth making an issue of a single action of an random person on the internet.