11 ms·
This is a puzzle to me. Uber faces some critical issues ahead. If they can solve them, the bikes will be a rounding error. If they can't, the bike business won'
by wpietri 9y ago
This is a puzzle to me. Uber faces some critical issues ahead. If they can solve them, the bikes will be a rounding error. If they can't, the bike business won't be enough to save them. Why add the complexity when they could buy or build something later?
I especially can't figure out why the Jump CEO would do it. The odds of their work surviving to the 10 year mark seems so small. It reminds me of something like Dodgeball. (For those who don't remember, it was a company basically like Foursquare, but years before. Google bought it and did little with it. Eventually the founders got tired of it, left Google, and started the same company again.)
- ska 9y agoThe odds of their work surviving to the 10 year mark seems so small. Are you sure that the odds are worse than surviving the 10 year mark without an acquisition? Would hardly be the first time someone sold because they simply couldn't make the growth math work, and they were all out of good options for financing.
- wpietri 9y agoI'm not sure, but that's the way I'd bet. They just took $10m in January, which is a fair bit of runway for testing hypotheses. When they start to run low on that, they can go to every single VC firm for more. Inside Uber, they are going to have approximately one executive to get funding from. Currently that executive obviously likes them. But feelings change, and they're just a reorg or an executive departure away from somebody who gives zero fucks.
- robszumski 9y agoIsn't this the same problem with a VC? The funds might like you now, but watch those ride numbers drop a bit and suddenly folks want ridiculous terms and you don't have many options. I would bet that getting $10m a year in the budget for a few years is no sweat at Uber...they had gross revenue of $37B in 2017. I realize they are trying to cut that, but increasing engagement in already profitable cities might have a material impact in the other direction.
- toufka 9y agoI suspect it's really good signal for setting up or optimizing routes. Those bikes show very clear underserved endpoints that might otherwise be hard to discover. Might just be a cheap and interesting peek down-market on their geographic data-layer.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe quality of the signal seems to depend heavily on the quality of the bike service. If they aren't moving bikes to where there is demand, they aren't generating any information about where people want to go (because people aren't using the bikes). It can also miss the forest for the trees if they have a few bikes that they usually put in an okay spot (but not enough bikes to meet the real demand).
- Baeocystin 9y agoOne of my favorite purchases over the past few years has been a RadRover from Rad Power Bikes. ( https://www.radpowerbikes.com/products/radrover-electric-fat-bike?variant=5032654929951 https://www.radpowerbikes.com/products/radrover-electric-fat... for the curious.) It's still going strong a year and a half after I got it, and the motor covers all the sins of heavy tires and rolling resistance that a fatbike would otherwise bring to the table. My initial worries about range and getting stuck having to pedal a long way back home have fallen to the wayside- as long as I start with a fresh battery, it will outlast me. And as someone in their mid-40's, it is so nice to be able to feel free on a bike again, without having to worry about struggling up that one hill that blocks an otherwise lovely ride. I don't mean to sound like an advertisement. I just want to note how transformative owning an ebike has been. A good 50% of my car trips have been replaced, and I enjoy the ride while doing so. And I like my car, too. But ebikes are just that much fun.
- paulie_a 9y agoHopefully Uber starts attempting to optimize routes again, if anything they have gotten worse. and every driver I have chatted with seems to agree, most just use Google maps and ignore the directions from Uber.
- 9y ago
- neves 9y agoIt looks like a marketing play. There are studies proving that Uber is increasing traffic and pollution (not even talking about workspace issues and drivers explotation). Bikes are eco-friendly and everybody like them.
- olivermarks 9y agoI think marketing play too - there has been so much negative press about Uber they badly needed an ecologically sound, 'no victims' vehicle to move people's minds away from the self driving car death of a bicycle pusher, and the Travis Kalanick era'Fight Club film extra' visuals a lot of people see as the Uber brand...
- bfuller 9y ago>everybody like them. not entirely true concerning the bike share companies. when they are fighting for dominance like they are in Dallas, the city gets littered with the bikes and people start vandalizing them. This happened in Paris so much that the dockless bikeshares pulled out.
- baud147258 9y agoThe dockless bikeshares pulled out of most of the city where they tried to deploy in France.
- bfuller 9y agoI can only hope we in Dallas can achieve the same.
- guelo 9y agoThese bikes are definitely going to eat into the number of uber rides. It's happened to me personally where I compare the time an Uber ride would take vs a bike and I end up choosing the bike. Interestingly this weekend I ended up choosing an electric scooter over a bike.These things are going to be used in a continuum depending on the situation, especially for younger people in urban environments.
- imjared 9y agoI did the exact same thing. Those electric scooters are also a lot more fun than sitting in someone's Prius. Especially as the weather here in DC warms up, I can see myself shelling out the $2 fee for a bike/scooter way more often than I'd be willing to spend $8-10 for a Lyft.
- maherbeg 9y agoI think you may underestimate the impact e-bikes are going to have on major (non-car centric) cities. They'll likely reshape cities significantly as infrastructure gets improved for biking. You can get significant traffic density improvements by pushing bikes instead of cars, and e-bikes make this more accessible.
- fataliss 9y agoThat would take a lot of political will to do something like that though and it would take YEARS! I don't think the US is a great market (right now) for city-bikes. Outside of maybe Manhattan & SF I can't think of any major city where a bike would take you places faster/better than another way of transportation would. When you consider all the hassles that biking as a transportation comes with, I doubt this has any large potential (compared to the Uber scale). Could be wrong though. I actually really hope I am!
- electricEmu 9y agoSeattle? Portland? Minneapolis/St. Paul? You might consider bicycling while you travel more. In Seattle alone, OFO, LimeBike, and Spin are all competing. American bicycle infrastructure is behind, but it exists. I don't own a car. I get around those cities on bike without issue. It's as fast or faster than a car in many cases and I'm peddling the old fashioned way (with legs).
- eckmLJE 9y agoWashington, DC is a big bike commuting city. Jump bikes are everywhere here.
- s5fs 9y agoRegarding Seattle and Portland, while it's true there are bike share programs, I don't see them used very often. The few who are using the bikes are either tourists (minority) or the homeless on stolen bikes. Additionally, just about half the limebikes that I see are abandoned under bridges or broken and unusable. Portland itself is a very bikeable city and a lot of time/energy is spent to improve and grow this infrastructure. Traffic is getting to the point where cycling is faster for inner-city trips, but as I live outside of the city it's a non-starter because public transportation from my end of town is severely limited. Seattle doesn't seem nearly as bike friendly, and while it's certainly faster to bike or walk during rush hour, it doesn't seem nearly as safe as Portland. I certainly have no interest in cycling in Seattle, driving is bad enough.
- valj 9y agoI don't have the numbers in front of me, but I imagine the key is in how you build defensibility around the core ride-sharing business. Ride-sharing suffers from the problem of clustered networks - you can be a global player like Uber and still lose the entire city of SF to a competitor like Lyft, or feel a minnow like Juno tear into your margins in NYC. Having bike sharing in your pocket helps you build a wider moat around these clustered networks. If I typically take a bikeshare to the subway every morning, and rarely Uber on the weekend, Uber might win 10 low-margin trips from me during the week (bikeshare to and from the subway every day), and through the use of a loyalty program incentivize me to make my 2 high-margin weekend ridesharing trips Uber trips. So yes, it is an adjacency, and it is lower margin than ridesharing and capital intensive, but this is a difficult market and at this point in the game it might make sense.
- subpixel 9y agoSo Uber will use no-margin bike rides to market loss-leader car rides. As ridiculous as this sounds you may be correct.
- joncrane 9y agoThis is the first economically feasible, rational, and internally consistent response in this thread. While it still takes a leap of faith to buy, the argument is sound. And using some other posters' terminology, we can put it like this: If this works, it will drive significant revenue growth and consolidation of both the rideshare and bikeshare markets. If it fails, meh. It's just "rounding error." Seems like a low-risk, high reward proposition to me, the way you stated it.
- oh_sigh 9y agoI suspect this move is about being the go-to transportation provider in any large city, regardless of the mode. Uber is seemingly good about paring back offerings that don't contribute to that vision, like UberRUSH
- rogerbinns 9y ago> Why add the complexity when they could buy or build something later? The two valuable things Uber has is customer credit cards on file and an app installed on their devices. Deals like this that add to those is valuable, and is a barrier to their current and future competitors.
- notatoad 9y agoThis seems like a defensive play against google maps. The most likely future for Uber is to be a route option in Google maps or some other app, where the user chooses the app first, and the transport method first, and Uber will just be an option with a price tag and time beside it, alongside Lyft and waymo and whatever other services are operating. Bringing other transport methods under the Uber umbrella seems like a play to keep you opening the Uber app when you want to go somewhere, rather than opening somebody else's app and selecting Uber.
- cdelsolar 9y agoHow is this their most likely future... where did this idea even come from?
- foota 9y agoI'll bite, Uber benefits from people dumping cars, maybe they see more available personal transport as helping with this?
- paulie_a 9y agoI am assuming the jump CEO will be too busy sleeping on the pile of money he just made to actually care.
- charlesdm 9y agoWhy wouldn't he sell? He gets rich.
- wpietri 9y agoBecause he values something else more than getting rich. E.g., achievement. Or even getting filthy rich. Note that Mark Zuckerberg could have sold Facebook early on for a variety of "he gets rich" prices: http://www.businessinsider.com/all-the-companies-that-ever-tried-to-buy-facebook-2010-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/all-the-companies-that-ever-t... And I'd add that anybody who gets into doing a startup only because they want to be rich is probably better off buying lottery tickets.
- theptip 9y agoStrongly agree on Uber's side; this seems like both a distraction and a rounding error even if it's successful. As for Jump; https://www.crunchbase.com/search/funding_rounds/field/organizations/funding_total/jump-bikes https://www.crunchbase.com/search/funding_rounds/field/organ... They just announced a $10M series A in January. To cash out at a $100M valuation doesn't seem like a bad outcome; after just doing just a series A, the founders' stake is likely to be in the 25-50% range (I'd guess in the lower end). Obviously the zeitgeist is to shoot for a unicorn, but there are plenty of reasons to chose an earlier exit, only some of which suggest that the underlying business is shaky. (Dodgeball sounds like a great deal BTW; rest & vest for a year or two, and then go start your company again except this time without having to bring in outside funding for your seed).
- jgalt212 9y agoThe extremely cynical view is that Dara is trying to curry favor with Menlo Ventures (backer of both Jump and Uber).
- gordon_freeman 9y agoI know Uber initially formed a business partnership with JUMP a couple of months ago and I think they started analyzing the data and found a compelling reason (like user adoption, freq, stickiness, etc.) and found a business value to just own the platform.
- bogomipz 9y agoI have to believe that some of this about brand awareness. Citibike is similar, its not a cash cow but every single bike is painted up in Citibank livery and logos.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoThe relevant buzzword is multimodal transportation, i. e. the trend towards using a variety of different options either on a single route (bike to train) or depending on circumstances (bike when the weather is good, Uber otherwise). Bike sharing is therefore complementary to "ride sharing" and having the two within one system could potential improve both.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- r00fus 9y agoIf the goal is to jump in and steer the market away from affecting its other line of business then it may make sense... in a protective move that aligns with its car manufacturer partners as well.
- usrusr 9y agoAcqui-ad? Doing something bike-related is the "politician posing with a baby" of car companies. If they combine accounts there will be true synergy though: many people either have zero rideshare accounts or almost all of them, the famous lack of moat. The same is probably true where multiple bikeshares are available. Those who have zero accounts in one "x-share" group and multiple in the other would be 100% locked to Uber when they occasionally do cross over from bikeshare to rideshare or vice versa. You are 100% right with this being just a drop in the bucket though.
- reacweb 9y agoUber has become an expert in handling legal frameworks (in particular grey areas), politicians, and precarious workers. Bikes are exactly in their expertise area. Diversification is (IMHO) a good strategy to increase strength.
- khangtoh 9y agoColleges. I remember my time as a freshman, getting a bike from Walmart became a necessity after the first couple weeks. After every winter, I had to fix or buy a new bike just because parts got rusty, broked or vandalize. So I would totally be happy to just use a shared bike if it was available back then.
- rorykoehler 9y agoUber gets you from A to B. I don't see how they couldn't get in now.
- joshe 9y agoIt's a shame, Uber won't work on this nearly as hard as the founders did. Like you said founders delude themselves that buyers will help make their vision a reality. Even Facebook, seemingly the best, most hands off startup buyer, is now consuming WhatsApp and Instagram and moving out the original founders. But... From Uber's perspective, they have a lot of cash right now. They are worried about a self driving future where Waymo takes all the rides from them. Drivers are expensive (at least half the ride price), and electric assist bikes removes driver wages from the ride expense. And really what is Uber's big monopoly advantage? Just the 2 sided market, but it's local. With a 1000 drivers + advertising you could compete in a local market with them. Right now they are subsidizing a lot of their rides with the world's largest pool of capital, but eventually their capital will run down. If this is a good business they will get competition. The shared bike business is capital intensive (buying bikes, building infrastructure) but that capital actually buys you some monopoly moat power. It's a really tough business for a startup to be in, but a pretty good fit for a big company. Uber could also do some cool things like a long haul Uber carpool to a bunch of Jump bikes just outside of downtown. Ie. shuttle up 101 to SF, Jump bike to get you through traffic. For the Jump founder, they have been working on social bikes since 2010, the Uber deal probably includes a cash payout for some of their stock (often after a year). A reasonable guess is that the first 7 years of that were starvation times with a capital intensive business and low capital. At this point the founders might have 20 to 60 percent of the company, with half their stock paid for in cash they might get 10 to 30 million dollars in a year plus the same amount in Uber stock, which is pretty liquid. Plus whatever new grant in Uber stock they get for staying on (it would not be weird if this was another 5-10 million per executive over 5 years). And fundraising is just a massive pain. From the Jump CEO's perspective: Sell $10-40 million / founder, almost certain payout Never fundraise again Lose company (everyone pretends, but that's what happened) Still get to run company for a few years Slowly watch your good culture be consumed by Uber's bad culture. Compete Compete with - the 3 electric scooter startups that have launched in SF in last 2 weeks - Uber and Lyft - buses - Go bikes - self owned bikes and ebikes - driving personal cars 2-7 years of hard work before cash, but then more money Go before Board of Supervisors meetings to explain your plan for fishing bikes out of the bay Keep company and autonomy Make vision a reality The world loses a lot when great startups like this don't compete, but it's understandable that founders sell.