4 ms·
Interestingly the complaints would disappear if they just got rid of homework. No, I'm not being facetious. If you read The Homework Myth you'll find out that
by btilly 16y ago
Interestingly the complaints would disappear if they just got rid of homework.
No, I'm not being facetious. If you read The Homework Myth you'll find out that homework in grade school is a net neutral from a learning perspective. The benefit is that you get more practice. The downfall is that without supervision it is as easy to practice the wrong thing as the right thing, and practicing the wrong thing sets you back.
Studies have shown that, in practice, the net effect is that homework causes academic performance to become more strongly correlated with the parent's socioeconomic status, but overall across the whole population there is no net change in learning outcomes. Plus assigning homework is a source of stress for families that causes students to dislike school. The strength of these effects is roughly linear in the amount of homework assigned, all of the way down to no homework at all. (Instead students have to do in class exercises, under the supervision of teachers. Which they have to do anyways.)
The reason for that is that homework causes enforcing correct practice to be the job of the parents, and so how well the parents understand the material determines whether homework benefits or hurts. While my family educationally benefits from the trend (me and my wife can assist correct practice), reduced stress and inequality makes no homework seem fair to me.
And hence the problem underscored by this article. With homework, when we teach students different techniques, we need to think both about how easily the students will learn them, and how well the parents will understand them. Without homework the parents lose that responsibility, and we're free to just focus on what works for the kids.
- confuzatron 16y agothe net effect So homework does help some kids. But it's unfair to do anything that helps some kids but not others, so it should be got rid of. The ideal is perhaps for parents to be able to choose whether to send their kids to a school that has their kids best interests at heart, rather than 'fighting inequality' by deliberately teaching them less well.
- btilly 16y agoSo homework does help some kids. Homework helps some kids and hurts some other kids. And causes stress all around. The kids that it helps are exactly the ones whose families are most able to send them to private schools. The kids that it hurts are the ones whose families are least able to send them to private schools. The ideal is perhaps for parents to be able to choose whether to send their kids to a school that has their kids best interests at heart, rather than 'fighting inequality' by deliberately teaching them less well. You're using loaded language that shortcuts thinking. If we TRULY have the kid's best interests at heart then it seems to me we should not assign homework in public schools (avoid hurting the kids who get no other choices), and allow private schools to assign as much as they want (so kids who would be helped can be allowed that experience). This maximizes the chance of having kids encounter the homework strategy that will be most effective for them. That seems better to me than the current situation where half the kids encounter a homework policy that actively harms them. And have no alternatives.
- elai 16y agoI know as a kid, and now probably too, that I would of preferred to of stayed in school for an extra hour or two and do home work so that when I go home I didn't have any homework. For god sakes, the typical school schedule almost has a built in slot for it already. 9-5 is the typical adult work day, 9-3 is the typical school day. If we could synchronize the two and make it 9-5 for both of them, it would probably work better for both groups of people's schedules! Adults today don't like doing their equivalent homework either. Most adults dislike bringing extra work home with them, taking phone calls outside of work hours and talk on and on about work/life balance and so on. Also for kids who don't have environments conductive to studying at home would do better too. If they don't have a computer at home, they don't have stable, quiet environment to study in, or they're parents are clueless, they would all benefit staying at school to do their 'home work'. Often schools cannot let the kids stay for an extra amount of time, since computer labs would close down, staff often lock the school and do not have the time to supervise the kids.
- kellishaver 16y agoMy daughter is 8 and has to take the late bus home, due to our work schedules, giving her about 45 minutes of waiting around after school for the bus. At the suggestion of her teacher, she's gotten into the habit of going to the library and doing her homework there, before she even leaves. There are a few computers in the library to use and there's a teacher around to help answer questions. She does the work there, then brings it home and we check over it. It's a good balance of self-discipline and supervision, I think. In fact, giving her the freedom to initiate the "doing homework" on her own rather than having me tell her to do it when she gets home has been good for her. It's nice to see her taking responsibility of her own accord.
- blahedo 16y ago> But it's unfair to do anything that helps some kids but not others, so it should be got rid of. This is a disingenuous straw man of a summary. If it were the case that it "helps some kids" but the others felt no effect, and they kiboshed the program for that reason, you'd have a point. But the problem here is that it "helps some kids", AND HURTS OTHERS. That's a big problem. The fact that it correlates with SES makes it even worse, because it means that the ones it's hurting most are the ones least capable of defending themselves, but the basic logic would be sensible even if the help/hurt spectrum were uncorrelated.
- philwelch 16y agoThis indicates that students from different SES should be taught differently, not that all students should be given an education that might help some statistical average, but doesn't necessarily help them personally.
- hristov 16y agoIf you think your kid will benefit from homework, you can still do it with him/her, without being assigned it. I am sure every text book has additional exercises you can try. "Eliminating homework" does not mean outlawing homework and sending the police after anyone that attempts to do any homework.
- MattGrommes 16y agoI just had this discussion with my 3rd grader's teacher and have talked about it with all her previous teachers after reading that book. Her point is that the homework is just practice and only takes a few minutes which makes me dislike it just on the principle of wasting "just a few minutes" of my family's time for no benefit. I try to give teachers the benefit of the doubt on this and not argue too much but in the past I've sent a note to school saying she just won't be doing the homework and it's not her fault, it's my decision.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoI told my kids to do exactly as much homework as needed to get the idea; then stop. Worse than weeknight homework: weekend homework. I absolutely reject this idea; I plan my family time, NOT the lazy teacher.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>I plan my family time, NOT the lazy teacher. I don't understand your slight against teachers. Preparing homework takes time and effort if it's to be a proper part of the curriculum of learning to be set. Even if it's an afterthought it still has to be marked and assessed and recorded (in the UK it does). Surely the lazy teacher would just say "for homework tonight watch TV" or some-such.
- jessriedel 16y agoThis is an honest question from a childless person: how much time does your 3rd grader spend doing math homework per night? Naively, it seems reasonable to me that there is going to be a fraction of the necessary practice which must be done under the supervision of the teacher, and a fraction which can be done alone. Now, as people move up the academic ladder and, presumably, become better at teaching themselves, the amount of class time decreases and the amount of self-directed time increases. At the 3rd grade level, where they spent 6-8 hours in class each day, it seems plausible that the correct amount of homework is roughly 30-60 minutes per night. It also seem plausible that the homework teaches a student not only the material, but also how to learn on their own.
- russell 16y agoI think it would relieve a lot of stress if meaningless homework were eliminated in elementary school. I can see the value of math and writing homework, but social studies drills are worthless but take as much time as English. It seems that every teacher feels the need to assign an hour a day.
- jleader 16y ago> It seems that every teacher feels the need to assign an hour a day. Some school districts (including Arcadia, California, where I live) set standards specifying how much time different grades should spend on homework "on average". For 5th grade, the standard here is 50 minutes. So the teacher "feels the need" because that's what his/her bosses say to do. From what I've heard, those standards are driven at least in part by the expectations of the parents.
- vilya 16y agoWithout homework, how does one develop good study habits? As someone who went to an independent school which didn't assign homework, I believe I was disadvantaged by NOT having to acquire those skills and had to expend disproportionately more effort than my contemporaries to learn them later.
- eru 16y agoI (almost) never did any homework at school. It's easy to wiggle out of it, if you set your mind to it. For example, you can often just fake it in class. But my parents where not involved at all. However, while studying math in university I did lots of homework and it actually helps with understanding. Also in mathematics you know when you are cheating yourself.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>However, while studying math in university I did lots of homework and it actually helps with understanding. I find that comment interesting and befuddling all at the same time. Which bit of your course was homework. I did a modular course in the UK including modules of Maths at honours level - we had lectures and tutorials on subject fields, did library study, computer based exercises and "labs", example problems, proofs and the like. Which bits are what you consider "homework"? Did people really get degrees without studying outside of lectures? When your entire life is self-motivated study I'm not sure how you draw a line and say "this bit is homework"?
- eru 16y agoI just classified everything outside of a lecture or tutorial as homework. I studied in Germany, and we usually got a sheet of exercises to work through (mostly finding proofs) each week for each subject. We presented our solutions in the tutorials (Übungen). At the end of the term there were oral exams. Germany has a history of very self-directed university study. Of course you were free to do library study and the like. It was often a good idea to work on the homework in teams. I found it quite easy to get through the exams with just attending lectures, tutorial and doing the assigned homework. But most people studied a lot more. (I got decent but not perfect grades.)