6 ms·
Backpage helped keep me safe during one of the scariest times of my life
- fahayekwasright 9y ago“Backpage helped me prolong a bad situation and keep my abusive addict piece of shit ex alive” yay backpage
- sky_rw 9y agoSo the argument here is that without backpage she would not have been able to efficiently prostitute herself to support her abusive heroin junkie pimp? I'm fairly certain that the argument "backpage is super effective" is the exact argument used to take it down.
- samschooler 9y agoNo, the key point is: She was in a situation where whether Backpage existed or not, she would still be doing sex work. With Backpage, she could screen her clients instead of approaching strangers at a gas station not knowing if she would live to see the next morning.
- yters 9y agoWhy does anyone have to do 'sex work'? The argument "I'm going to do it anyways, so you might as well make it safe and convenient for me" doesn't sound very persuasive to me, especially if we generalize this principle.
- darawk 9y agoSome people choose to do sex work. Making that more dangerous for them when their choice of work isn't harming anyone else seems fairly petty.
- relics443 9y agoI wouldn't be so quick to say it doesn't harm anyone else. It's not so far fetched to imagine a married family man acting on an impulse to hire a prostitute. It's a situation where if one wasn't so easily available, he wouldn't have done it. Not such a stretch of the imagination to imagine this person getting found out by family. Bam! Instant harm to multiple innocent people.
- darawk 9y agoYou're right, the availability of sex and sexuality is too much for men to handle. We should criminalize prostitution - and while we're at it, why not criminalize yoga pants? I know those are pretty tempting to me.
- relics443 9y agoI think the question you mean to ask is why criminalize anything, and IMO that's out of the scope of this forum. But once you receive the answer to your real question, the reason why prostitution is criminal, while yoga pants are not should be self evident.
- darawk 9y agoUm, no. Things like murder are criminalized because they involve the infringement upon the rights of others against their will. Prostitution does not infringe upon anyone's rights against their will.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Why does anyone have to do 'sex work'? The same reason people need to do any kind of work; because we are living in a society where he economic system requires most people to sell labor of whatever kind they can that is valued by others in the marketplace in order to survive. EDIT: And for some people, given that requirement, sex work is the option where the undesirability of doing the work combined with the pay for doing it leaves it the rational choice. In some cases, it's also the least socially objectionable option practically open.
- sky_rw 9y agoYour definition of survival includes supporting an abusive pimp's $3,000/month heroin addiction?
- dragonwriter 9y agoYes, that's the reality of survival for people who don't have better things to sell, in part due to the illegality of prostitution.
- manicdee 9y agoDo you have a better option for the people in this situation?
- derangedHorse 9y agoYes, to be smart enough not to work for Barn Cat and to only work for herself if sex work is the only type of work she wanted to do. Besides that, I'm sure she could've found a variety of other jobs if she really wanted (although potentially a lot less profitable).
- sky_rw 9y agoYes, I appreciate that it enables more effective sex work and likely makes her specific case slightly safer. This argument could be used for a multitude of illegal acts, e.g. steroids, heroin, digital piracy, etc. It doesn't change the reality that society has agreed that this act is illegal and should not be enabled.
- relics443 9y agoWhile this is a very sad story, it doesn't change the fact that prostitution is illegal. Even if it helped save her life, it's still illegal. Until it is made legal (not happening in the US), there is no argument that should work in favor of making it easier. There are reasons prostitution is illegal. There are reasons to make it as difficult as possible for someone to find a prostitute. There are enough stories of people who tear apart their lives and families because it was too easy to find a prostitute (implication is that they wouldn't have used a prostitute if they couldn't find one easily and quickly). It's sad that she suffers from bi-polar, but this is not a utilitarian society. Backpage helping her doesn't justify the fact that it directly led to a proliferation of illegal activity.
- thecrash 9y agoDeferring to the law is a thought-stopper. It's entirely possible that something is illegal but should be tolerated or accommodated in some circumstances. Equating the law with a perfect moral code - i.e. it is always wrong to break the law and always good to obey it - is a flawed way of understanding human society.
- relics443 9y agoI'm deferring to the reasons why it's a law.