6 ms·
We've been going around in circles with stories like this for years. In spite of all the horror stories, people are still using PayPal. That would indicate to m
by jdietrich 16y ago
We've been going around in circles with stories like this for years. In spite of all the horror stories, people are still using PayPal. That would indicate to me that either PayPal are exploiting a monopoly position, or there is a massive gap in the market for a fast, easy payment system that doesn't treat serious customers like dirt.
I completely understand the Googley argument that you can't provide much customer service if you have millions of users with a tiny average revenue, but what sense is there in treating a €600,000 account so poorly? Surely they must know that they have lost him forever as a customer.
The only logical answer I have as to why PayPal do this to big customers is that they know that as soon as anyone gets big they leave for a cheaper merchant account, so their account freeze is just a way for them to hold on to a customer long enough to make some real money out of them. I can't believe that they would, but I'm struggling to work out why else they would act like this.
- ergo98 16y agoThere are exceedingly few global payment systems, almost none of which, from a consumer perspective, are as trustworthy and easy to use as PayPal: When it comes to small vendors, I'd much rather pay them through PayPal (where I can even pay from a bank account) than to give my CC numbers to some micro operation. PayPal, like all payment processors, deals with a large amount of fraud, yet they seem to manage to keep it low enough relative to the total cash flow that their rates are fairly reasonable for small vendors. Which is exactly why guys like this use the service in the first place. As you mentioned, these stories seem to cycle around, yet lots of people still rely upon PayPal, and there's something to that. Add in that every Western government is imposing strong anti-money laundering and anti-terrorism financing regiments on organizations like PayPal. Seriously, people don't know how amazingly good they really have it. Having a snag in PayPal (and going through the arduous task of providing documents) is nothing.
- sankara 16y agoI'm in India and Paypal had a tough time dealing with the central bank here. So yes, I would agree a little that these rules are most likely imposed by regulatory authorities but that doesn't mean what Paypal does is acceptable. Have intelligent rules not alarms that blaze through the roof everytime someone transacts above, say, a thousand dollars. Even after that they could very well treat sellers with a bit more dignity?
- jemfinch 16y ago> I'd much rather pay them through PayPal (where I can even pay from a bank account) than to give my CC numbers to some micro operation. Really? I certainly wouldn't. I have recourse with American Express. They have far better fraud detection than Paypal, in large part because they know my spending habits far better than Paypal does. On the single instance I've dealt AMEX's fraud detection, they called me before they even authorized the fraudulent transaction, and overnighted me a new card when I confirmed their suspicions. Paypal, on the other hand, flagged a transaction as potentially fraudulent simply because I had the purchase shipped to my workplace (a well known bay area address) and now they want me to go back to Kansas and wait at my home phone number for them to call and "verify my domicile." Screw that; my account can stay locked for all I care.
- ergo98 16y ago>Really? I certainly wouldn't. I have recourse with American Express. When I pay with Paypal I have recourse with both Paypal AND my credit card. It doesn't remove that right. >Paypal, on the other hand, flagged a transaction as potentially fraudulent simply because I had the purchase shipped to my workplace Why is the fact that it's a well known Bay Area address of any significance at all? Paypal demands that shipped items only go to the address on record for the account. That seems pretty logical and of obvious value.
- mey 16y agoNot if you pay with Paypal through it connecting directly to your bank account.
- jemfinch 16y ago> Why is the fact that it's a well known Bay Area address of any significance at all? Which do you think seems more fraudulent? This address: 1600 Amphitheatre Pkwy, Mountain View, CA 94043 Or this one? Hospital Road, P.M.B. 2155 Kaduna, Nigeria Which address do you think is more likely to be used for fraud? > Paypal demands that shipped items only go to the address on record for the account. That seems pretty logical and of obvious value. An obvious negative value, sure. I've shipped to at least 9 different addresses on Amazon. Sometimes I'm not buying things for myself. Sometimes I'm not at home and want it to get shipped to me at a hotel. Oddly, Amazon has no problem with this (maybe because they're indemnified against fraud losses by the CC company, as I noted elsewhere). But try to ship something anywhere but your recorded home address with Paypal and you have to jump through a ridiculous number of hoops. It's not logical at all.
- btilly 16y agoThat would indicate to me that either PayPal are exploiting a monopoly position, or there is a massive gap in the market for a fast, easy payment system that doesn't treat serious customers like dirt. You're missing the third possibility, which is that efficiently doing what PayPal requires requires "treating serious customers like dirt." PayPal is in the business of efficiently detecting and not paying for fraud. One type of fraud that they need to deal with is fraudsters getting control of an established account, sticking lots of fake payments in, then withdrawing the "money" before PayPal notices that it isn't real. Their strategy for this seems to be to make people jump over a low paperwork barrier, then wait long enough that the payments have all cleared before they pay out. Given this, paying for a dedicated customer service representative for the victim on top of that strategy is an inefficiency. The last part of that decision ignores the effect of pissing people off on their reputation, and so may be shortsighted. But the rest of their strategy makes sense to me.
- tolini 16y agoOne type of fraud that they need to deal with is fraudsters getting control of an established account (...) Their strategy for this seems to be to make people jump over a low paperwork barrier, then wait long enough that the payments have all cleared before they pay out. One day my account (solely used for sending payments) got blocked because of a "potential unauthorized third-party access". After completing the verification they asked (new password, new security question and credit card confirmation), I received another message asking me to send a scanned copy of my ID Card, a proof of domicile and my BBAN. I told them that for confidentiality reasons, it was out of question to send any of these documents. I asked them to give me more specific information about the materials that led to the account suspension and to reactivate it without delay. The next day, I received an email with vague excuses and my account got reactivated immediately. It is true that their antifraud system can lead to number of suspended accounts and frozen funds without any solid basis. But they may also take advantage of frozen money (eg. this 600k case) for further financial activities so as big-box stores are used to: http://books.google.com/?id=UOSk0J8vYugC&pg=PA533 http://books.google.com/?id=UOSk0J8vYugC&pg=PA533 (source: http://preview.tinyurl.com/2vrcddc http://preview.tinyurl.com/2vrcddc)
- houseabsolute 16y ago
- scythe 16y ago> there is a massive gap in the market for a fast, easy payment system that doesn't treat serious customers like dirt. You're thinking of AlertPay.
- lanstein 16y agoThey're not called the PayPal Mafia for nothing ;)
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoThey probably also make a fortune on the interest accrued. I wonder if they defer to freezing accounts so easily is because they realize that it's easy money.
- blasdel 16y agoYou would think so, and that was their original business plan — just make money off the float. Instead they ended up charging fees (30¢ + %3) to get to profitability.
- tedunangst 16y agoI don't think the original business plan included credit card payments. You only ever put "real" money into your account, and in order to use the service you basically had to keep enough in there for them to float it. Adding credit card payments changed that. Notice that paypal still doesn't charge fees for payments that come straight from a bank account.
- blasdel 16y agoIn almost all circumstances, the recipient of a Paypal payment gets the 30¢ + %n cut taken out, even if the money came directly from a bank account. Paypal is also set up to avoid making credit card transactions at all costs — you need one to sign up (as effectively overdraft protection), but payments always debit from the bank account first. If you have a pro account and embed/link it to customers, they can have the option to pay directly with a credit card, but only if they don't have a paypal.com cookie. There is only one way to reliably avoid the fees — you have to explicitly make the payment as an 'eCheck' which only takes out the 30¢, but Paypal will take at least a week to clear the funds.
- ergo98 16y agoFirstly, no. Secondly, most PayPal purchases happen through credit cards. Credit card companies hold onto the payments for up to 60 days, meaning PayPal is holding onto absolutely nothing.