3 ms·
How is "strictly" defined? I'm going to guess it's define as "the magistrate knows it when it sees it", so take to be both "don't use the most egregious interpr
by gowld 9y ago
How is "strictly" defined? I'm going to guess it's define as "the magistrate knows it when it sees it", so take to be both "don't use the most egregious interpretation", and "don't be a populist punching bad that governments can make hay out of attacking".
- mehrdadn 9y agoI assume it's "you cannot provide said service without having said data".
- molf 9y agoAny data you collect that you do not unambiguously need to provide the service would be an appeal for "legitimate interest" as a legal basis for collecting it. There are a number of things GDPR writes about it and of course you cannot be sure how this will play out in practice, but the main points are: * it must be reasonable from the user's perspective * there must be alternative; you cannot achieve the goal (your "legitimate interest") without it * it must be balanced with the rights of the user, and not infringe on their freedom or fundamental rights * if your "legitimate interest" is direct marketing, the user can always object, and you are required to actively inform the user of this right See also [1] [1] https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-47/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-47/
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI think you meant "no alternative" under the second bullet point.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoStrictly has a pretty clear definition. If you can provide a service strictly devoid of the PII it means there is no logical necessity for PII. You can't provide a call-waiting service without a phone number, but you can provide a mail-redirection service without one even though it makes it easier to administer when you have a customer phone number, you can strictly provide (and bill/administer) the service when that information is absent.
- drewmol 9y agofrom molf's comment: >The alternative is to only collect data that is strictly necessary to provide the service. While I agree with your comment, I suspect that for any given law firm, paramTotalHours_Billable(SubjectID = necessary) will be a much larger value.