4 ms·
Good on them for finding something people want. However, you're not supposed to be able to protect that knowledge with a patent. If I start making cheeseburger
by lordnacho 9y ago
Good on them for finding something people want.
However, you're not supposed to be able to protect that knowledge with a patent. If I start making cheeseburgers where the buns are replaced by croissants, and it turns out to be so compelling that a billion people are hooked on it, should that be something that can be protected?
No, of course not. We want many entrepreneurs to be able to make these burgers so that everyone can have them at a sensible price, in whatever varieties are popular, and where and whenever they are in demand. Allowing one entity to have control over this "discovery" (cheeseburger + croissant = heaven) will mean that consumers cannot have any of those things until the discoverer has built up the business empire required.
- djrogers 9y ago> If I start making cheeseburgers where the buns are replaced by croissants, Dang, that sounds good - if I wasn’t trying to lose another 7lbs...
- Spare_account 9y agoI may be misunderstanding you, or missing a piece of your argument, but you appear to be arguing that patents should not exist? Is there any area that you feel would be acceptable to allow patents?
- lordnacho 9y agoWell I'm no expert on it, but it would seem that patents are not justified in a great number of industries. There's a bunch of businesses where capital and knowledge exists, and can be turned to making more or less anything. For instance, if you come up with some new shape of plastic coathanger, you can find some guy in China to make it for you, in millions. The key isn't that you're smart and can make a clever shaped coathanger, the key is that you are able to convince people it's useful and worth buying for more than what it costs you to open a webshop and pay the factory. You shouldn't be able to patent that. Some other person may be able to make it without your help, cheaper, and for more consumers. Or you could make software. Pretty much any old UI innovation can be made by anyone in the field for peanuts. If it turns out everyone wants a circular knob to scroll up and down, it would not take long before every browser, application, and mobile app could implement that. You shouldn't be able to patent that; it's an obvious thing that takes no input from the original "inventor" to make. I already had an example from the food industry. You can mash together any number of foods, pretty much anyone can. Pharma is one area where it is perhaps legitimate, due to the cost of research. If you don't have someone doing tests to show some molecule works, nobody will know what works. And if you don't have someone showing you how to make a particular molecule, it may take a long time before consumers have that drug. I'm still reserved about it in this area though. The potential for abuse is considerable.
- gaius 9y agoHowever, you're not supposed to be able to protect that knowledge with a patent. In general, IP laws are a recognition of the phenomenon that making something for the first time is difficult and/or expensive, but once it exists it is cheap to reproduce. This differs from tangible goods in that much of the value has gone into the sourcing and manipulation of physical materials. Once again I find it bemusing that a startup-oriented community doesn't get this. The system is far from perfect in execution, I'll admit, but it's all that means that a small company can innovate without immediately being crushed by an entrenched firm with superior manufacturing and distribution capabilities. Ultimately most anti-IP arguments boil down to "I want to be paid for what I create but I want what everyone else creates for free". That's not sustainable. Also speaking of croissants and IP law you might find this amusing http://blogs.findlaw.com/free_enterprise/2014/03/bakery-hit-with-cronuts-cease-and-desist-order.html http://blogs.findlaw.com/free_enterprise/2014/03/bakery-hit-...
- lordnacho 9y ago> In general, IP laws are a recognition of the phenomenon that making something for the first time is difficult and/or expensive, but once it exists it is cheap to reproduce. You are mixing up a number of things into "IP Laws". Some things make sense, others do not. - For instance, it's perfectly reasonable that people who make some product can do so under their own brand without other people pretending to be the same brand. We can't have some new entrant calling themselves McDonalds and selling Big Macs. - Patents are indeed meant to address the issue you are on about. But the "invention" of cheeseburger + croissant is not hard to produce for the first time. In this case the patent is pretending to be doing something difficult, but what it's actually protecting is the first person who happens to test some random market (what about chicken wings + marmite?). And that is the distinction you need to be thinking about. Another example of this was the lawsuit about the "rubber band" effect on UIs. In no way is it hard to produce the item in question, you just need to know that someone wants it. And the fact that there is a market for something should not be patentable. > Once again I find it bemusing that a startup-oriented community doesn't get this. I doubt that anyone doesn't understand this. What's happened is a nuanced view has developed over the years. - People can see that IP is in the first place not easily attributable. Ideas are like nature: they mix together, things are added and removed by different people, new ideas are formed on top of old ones. You don't need to actually make a product to get a patent but if you're first at the PTO you can ride on everyone who does make a product. Doesn't seem right. - What was thought to be protecting the little guy is doing the opposite. If you're a little guy, most likely you are the employee of some firm that makes you put all your patents in their name. If you want to go on your own, good luck with the lawyers. If you look at your average success story here on HN, try to categorize them: The firm created some item that was patented and turned it into a major success on the back of that patent, or the firm found some market that was probably already not virgin, and managed to address it without particular importance of some patent. - Patent seem to be abused easily. I did a patent a few years ago and the day it got issued the guys I was working with started talking about finding a good patent troll lawyer. It seems the system has created an unhealthy culture. > Ultimately most anti-IP arguments boil down to "I want to be paid for what I create but I want what everyone else creates for free". That's not sustainable. No, they don't. If what is created is easily duplicated (eg general knowledge like the area of a circle) then why should it be paid for? I want to be paid if I'm going to paint someone's circular table, because I can only paint so many in my working life. But if I invented A = pi * r * r, which all the painters need, should I be paid? > Also speaking of croissants Yes, that was my inspiration. Ultimately, where you stand on this depends this: Is it a question of recognizing what effort people have put in, "costs, investment", of invention, or is the important thing what consumers get out, "value"? And that is why the HN crowd leans the way it does.
- chrischen 9y agoGenerally such discoveries require a lot of trial and error, aka R&D. It’s certainly possible to accidentally stumble upon the croissant idea, but it’s also possible that you tried countless iterations and spent boatloads of money to test buns. If you don’t protect that it simply disincentivizes intentional R&D.
- lordnacho 9y agoThe point of the croissant "invention" was that it wasn't really a big R&D spend. It's a marketing spend, pretending to be R&D.