3 ms·
(I grew up in Boston but now live in Silicon Valley.) The T has great coverage but shitty service. Boston is second only to NYC in terms of the fraction of th
by nostrademons 9y ago
(I grew up in Boston but now live in Silicon Valley.) The T has great coverage but shitty service. Boston is second only to NYC in terms of the fraction of the city that you can get to via public transit. The Red Line covers most of the densely-populated Arlington/Somerville/Cambridge neighborhoods, runs straight into the heart of the city, and then services even the lower-income neighborhoods in Roxbury/Dorchester/Mattapan/Quincy. The Green Line covers the whole Back Bay and Brookline area. Orange Line will get you up to Tufts & Medford, and Blue Line covers North & East Boston. All of these except the outer reaches of the Green Line have reasonable transit times.
By contrast, SF has good public transit if you happen to live in the BART corridor through Mission & Market streets, or around 4th & King or Potrero. But if you're in the Sunset, Presidio, Pac Heights, North Beach, Twin Peaks & highlands, Excelsior, or really anywhere else - you can forget about it. It takes as long to get from the Outer Sunset to Downtown as it does to get from Mountain View, 50 miles away, to SF.
However, BART runs on time, as does Caltrain. To the minute, unless somebody kills themselves on the tracks. You know exactly when the next BART train will arrive, and when it will get to its destination. By contrast, when I took the Red Line to work I would frequently find myself sitting stopped outside Alewife or Harvard Square for about 20 minutes for track maintenance, or because they lost the third rail, or because there was another train in the station whose doors were jammed, or any number of other reasons that a well-maintained public transportation system shouldn't have.
- sokoloff 9y agoOr the “every 10 minutes #1 bus” wouldn’t come for 40 minutes, at which point 4 of them would arrive, nose to tail, as if they were drafting each other on a NASCAR circuit.
- seltzered_ 9y agoThe term you're looking for is bus bunching: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_bunching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_bunching Anecdotally, it seems to happen more on longer routes into a city center, and gets worse if there's traffic / bridge opens / etc. along the route.
- burfog 9y agoThe MBTA's T, Red Line, in Boston around 1995: At the train approaches the station, people in the station hear an announcement and see it on a lighted sign. It is something like "Braintree train approaching", letting you know the direction and final destination. Inside the train, they see and hear something like "Approaching Park Street. Next Stop: Downtown Crossing. This is a Braintree train.". When the train stops, there is a similar announcement, again both voice and lighted display, both inside the train and on the station platform. People inside the train can read the brightly-lighted station sign through the windows, and people on the platform can read a brightly-lighted sign on the train itself. Another announcement is made just before the doors close, and another one right after. The other lines were about as good, with a few oddities like a human announcer on the Green Line. San Francisco's MUNI, around 2015, two decades later: There is no voice announcement or message display when I board the train underground, either in the station or in the train. Gee, I hope I'm going the right direction. The train pops out of the ground and runs down the eastern side of the city. It stops only when there is a person waiting at the stop or when somebody in the train pulls a cord, there are no station announcements in the train, and the signs on the stations are unlighted and/or hidden. There is simply no way to count stops to determine where you are. You have to truly recognize the city (for me: in the dark, as an out-of-town visitor) or stay focused on a GPS-based map display. I obviously couldn't do the former, and my phone battery was dying so the latter was a problem as well. So it looks to me like SF in 2015 can't match Boston in 1995.
- wtvanhest 9y agoI could be wrong, but i lived by mgh for 3 years 2011 to 2014. I think they installed those signs while i lived there.
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago> Orange Line will get you up to Tufts & Medford Huh? The Orange Line has one stop in Medford. I live near it. Before that is an expensive shopping area in Somerville, and after that is Malden Center. >However, BART runs on time, as does Caltrain. To the minute, unless somebody kills themselves on the tracks. You know exactly when the next BART train will arrive, and when it will get to its destination. By contrast, when I took the Red Line to work I would frequently find myself sitting stopped outside Alewife or Harvard Square for about 20 minutes for track maintenance, or because they lost the third rail, or because there was another train in the station whose doors were jammed, or any number of other reasons that a well-maintained public transportation system shouldn't have. Boston also sucks at supplying radial transit between the spoke-shaped lines running out of the hubs of North Station, Park Street, State Street, Downtown Crossing, and South Station.