17 ms·
Comcast, AT&T and Verizon pose a greater surveillance risk than Facebook
- pascalxus 9y agoI've always wondered why people are so hard on Facebook, but give At&t and the other ISPs a free pass to do whatever they want. If you ask me, the ISP cartels are orders of magnitude more evil than FB. At least FB is making changes to address the issues, unlike At&t who keeps screwing people over more and more every year.
- spiderfarmer 9y ago...mostly in the US.
- saudioger 9y agoFacebook is mildly transparent about it so it's easy to criticize, the ISPs are black boxes.
- nielsbot 9y agoGood question... Maybe: 1. I don't think people have thought about it enough. I know I haven't. I think part of the reason is AT&T et. al. seem "inevitable" whereas Facebook is conveniently "quittable". 2. FB's lack of privacy has been discussed in the open and in the news recently, making it stand out. 3. (One of) FB's goals is to sell you to advertisers...
- sykh 9y agoDon't ISPs like Comcast have access to orders of magnitude fewer users? I think it has to do with scale and the fact the Cambridge Analytica used Facebook data and not, it seems, Comcast data. Overall Facebook is just the focal point of the ire. The ire though is really not Facebook as such but rather unregulated data collection by private companies.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoYes. Google and Facebook both have global reach and billions of users, but they also spend millions of dollars on PR to convince you the ISPs are the real privacy threat. The author's LinkedIn includes recently working for a law firm, Fenwick & West, which proudly brags about Google being one of their clients on their career page. If an article is doing "whataboutism" that minimizes the danger of big tech, check their resume, it's probably their job.
- zjaffee 9y agoYes, they have far less users, but they also have a much longer history when it comes to user tracking and measurement in the name of ad targeting. Although I think the big difference is they can't do network analysis. This said, Comcast (which owns NBC universal), has been able to use cable boxes to improve ad targeting for decades, trace that back to internet usage, and apply it to models already built for NBC usage. A n even more powerful one though is Verizon, where with their now acquisition of yahoo can use that data as well, which is combined with both all of the home data collection comcast has, but with 80+ million mobile users as well.
- reaperducer 9y ago> Don't ISPs like Comcast have access to orders of magnitude fewer users? Yes, but because it's your ISP and your data it's snooping, it suddenly becomes important. As they say, one death is a tragedy. A thousand deaths is a statistic.
- fightorflight 9y agoPeople should also include credit card companies as they've been tracking purchases and inferring data long before Facebook has existed.
- dylz 9y agoyou forgot selling all of the purchase data.
- redbeard0x0a 9y agoof which I'm sure facebook buys...
- justadudeama 9y agoDo you have a source for this?
- dylz 9y agohttp://partners.exelate.com/media/1/_orig/1426866843-8791.pdf http://partners.exelate.com/media/1/_orig/1426866843-8791.pd... http://adage.com/article/digital/facebook-partner-acxiom-epsilon-match-store-purchases-user-profiles/239967/ http://adage.com/article/digital/facebook-partner-acxiom-eps... https://adexchanger.com/ecommerce-2/purchase-data-playbook-marketers/ https://adexchanger.com/ecommerce-2/purchase-data-playbook-m...
- mtgx 9y agoWhenever you think "why don't users care about this privacy issue" stop and ask yourself "wait, do people actually know about this privacy issue and do they understand the implications, though?" Do you think most people have actually thought about how their ISPs must track their every interaction with the web and read all of their unencrypted chats and traffic? I think that what's needed is more awareness about what the ISPs are doing, but I really don't like headlines and articles like this one that try to minimize what Facebook and Google are doing. The ISPs tracking may be more all-encompassing, but a large portion of the web, especially popular websites are becoming "dark" to them, as major sites adopt HTTPS encryption. Their next most valuable tracking tool besides HTTP is probably the DNS server. And to get people to change that you'll need raise a lot of awareness about it. I guess Microsoft, Google, and Apple enabling their own DNS resolvers by default on their operating system would be a small improvement, but you're kind of moving the problem instead of solving it. And Google already does that with recent versions of Android, I believe.
- ThomPete 9y agoBecause most people haven't actually thought about this very deeply and if they did they would realize Facebook doesn't "know" a fraction of the things people claim they do[1] which makes the whole CA hysteria even more absurd. [1] https://www.ft.com/content/d7c955ac-3213-11e8-ac48-10c6fdc22f03 https://www.ft.com/content/d7c955ac-3213-11e8-ac48-10c6fdc22...
- reaperducer 9y ago> I've always wondered why people are so hard on Facebook, but give At&t and the other ISPs a free pass to do whatever they want. Because we choose to use AT&T and other ISPs. Facebook has enough beacons spread across millions of websites that even if you choose not to have a Facebook account, it's still monitoring you.
- welder 9y agoMajority of people in the USA don't choose their ISP, their city zones IPSs per neighborhood.
- jstanley 9y agoBecause Facebook is in the business of monetising data about people and ISPs aren't. It's not obvious to me that ISPs would bother (except where required to do so by law). They could just route traffic and not inspect anything.
- crowbahr 9y ago"It's not obvious to me that ISPs would bother" The issue is mainly that ISPs are also, by and large, the Cable Companies. Cable is dying. It's dying quickly. Cable companies are seeing dwindling revenue streams from their cable packages and are going to be looking for ways to bolster their shareholder's profits despite the inevitable death of traditional cable programming schemes. How do they do that? They do it by selling anything and everything they can to advertisers, exactly like what they've been doing with cable. Coincidentally that's also exactly the reason that cable is dying.
- welder 9y agoISPs also are in the business of selling your data.
- rayiner 9y agoLargely because FB is mining your data today and has built a half-trillion dollar business doing it. For ISPs it's mostly theoretical and attempts here and there. (That's why this article uses the phrase "pose a greater surveillance risk").
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- welder 9y agoSpoiler Alert: ISPs also already sell your data to advertisers and data middle-men. They also have built a business selling your data.
- timgilbert 9y agoI agree, though I'd say that this is because of general ISP incompetence, not because the ISPs don't want to do this.
- wybiral 9y agoFB (and other data collection businesses) pose a greater threat because they have direct access to your content rather than passive streams of increasingly encrypted data. And web trackers get access to your browsing behavior even if you aren't a user in a way that gives them more oversight on TLS connections since they're embedded (somewhat unwittingly) by webpages throughout the internet. TLS limits what your ISP can see. So until they block encrypted traffic it doesn't scare me too much.
- docdeek 9y ago> Many – though by no means all – of us are privileged enough to #DeleteFacebook, or at least reduce the time we spend there. What privilege is being referenced here?
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoThere are countries where Facebook is a primary means of communication.
- docdeek 9y agoI wasn't aware of that. I know of places where it is popular and a reflex for quick communication but I didn't think it would be a/the primary tool.
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoThe article doesn't address strategies for avoiding such surveillance. How well does it work? Does it prevent you from doing anything you might need to do? How hard is it? How much slower? Can it be done on a mobile device?
- gscott 9y agoFurther expanding on the article, ATT sells a spy service to police departments and many police departments are paying 100k and more yearly to ATT for this. https://mashable.com/2016/10/25/att-selling-data-police/#DuI6_vekkqqx https://mashable.com/2016/10/25/att-selling-data-police/#DuI...
- enedil 9y agoWhining about Comcast might be actually valid, but for most people of this world it's largely irrelevant. People from every place have Facebook access. Comcast customers are minority - Americans are minority. That's why Facebook has a lot harder time (also, ditching Facebook is more achievable).
- Install_Gentoo 9y agoWhy would this be a surprise?
- citilife 9y agoI recently received a "terms of service" update from Comcast, with the notification that they can now "monitor and record anything going through the network. Including, but not limited to: audio recording, video recording, ..." I don't even have an alternative in my area.
- exabrial 9y agoYikes. I'd be sure to lodge a complaint here, note about the local monopoly: https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us I'm curious where you are located [if you don't mind sharing]?
- Analemma_ 9y agoLodge a complaint with Pai’s FCC! Thanks, I needed a good laugh this morning.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 9y agoSo many comments to the FCC ignored. Complaints won't go anywhere, either.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoComments were collected. No obligation existed to treat them as a vote. Very few contained new information to the FCC, so they weren't valuable. The entire "millions of comments" nonsense is wholesale irrelevant, because the process doesn't exist for the purpose of voting or conveying public opinion. Comments are collected in case there are scenarios the regulatory agency didn't consider. They considered them, and decided a way you didn't like.
- SkyMarshal 9y agoYou have to get this stuff on record in real-time so the adminstration after Pai's will have timestamped evidence to act on. Stop being so short-sighted and defeatist about this stuff, think strategically.
- inspecotrrr 9y agoThey can't read the contents of conversations masked by TLS, but Facebook can. This is incredibly relevant to modern services and technology. Telephone is an audio stream, so speech-to-text is a bit more wobbly. SMS, on the other hand... well, at least their price gouging was cost prohibitive for a few decades.
- jacquesm 9y agoComcast, AT&T and Verizon don't have a single bit of data on me, I'm not a customer. As opposed to Facebook and Google being present on just about every webpage and gobbling up data about all the people on the planet that have internet access. The article has this bit in it: "Your internet provider doesn’t just know what you do on Facebook – it sees all the sites you visit and how much time you spend there. Your provider can see where you shop, what you watch on TV, where you choose to eat dinner, what medical symptoms you search, where you apply for work, school, a mortgage. Everything that is unencrypted is fair game. " The last part is the important part: hardly anything is unencrypted these days (and if it isn't it really should get with the times). So if that part of the article would have been adjusted to the present day situation that only thing that remains is that if these parties are your provider then they can indeed see which IP addresses you connect to (if you don't use a VPN). They can't see what you watch on TV unless you configure your TV to tell them (or use a set-top box to choose your channels for you), they do not know where you choose to eat your dinner unless your smartphone leaks GPS coordinates to them (regular triangulation is too coarse for this) and they do not know where you apply for work and school or a mortgage. In general this is a whole bunch of alarmist hoopla, yes, providers see too much data, no it's nothing compared to Facebook and Google. What should worry you is AT&T and other cellular services providers access to your call records (which they are required by law to keep for a long time in most places) and SMS data as well as the possibility of them recording all your voice calls without your consent.
- rconti 9y agoFor the vast majority of customers, Comcast, AT&T, and Verizon know what sites you visit, what types of data you pass to them, every single DNS lookup you make, etc. Sorry, but this is FAR more intrusive than Facebook, which you CLAIM has lots of data on you even if you don't use their service. It's harder to avoid Google than it is to avoid Facebook, but again, it's doable.
- jacquesm 9y ago> For the vast majority of customers, Comcast, AT&T, and Verizon know what sites you visit They know which IP addresses you connect to. Many of those host large numbers of websites. > what types of data you pass to them What do you mean with 'what types of data'? They can't access the headers of encrypted traffic. > every single DNS lookup you make Yes, that's true. And you can cache those locally. > etc. Sorry, but this is FAR more intrusive than Facebook, which you CLAIM has lots of data on you even if you don't use their service. Shadow profiles are a thing. > It's harder to avoid Google than it is to avoid Facebook, but again, it's doable. It's just about impossible. Every other email you send ends up in a gmail inbox. So even if you don't use their services at all your data still ends up with them. Even if you don't have a smartphone enough people around you will have them that your social graph will end up with Google anyway. And so on.
- gdulli 9y agoI'm not as concerned about CA having data I've given to FB as I am about their admission of using it to spread false information. If cable and phone companies were politically weaponizing my data the same way I'd be just as concerned. On the one hand, maybe worrying sooner prevents issues. On the other hand, I don't want to assume a slippery slope out of principle.
- losvedir 9y ago> admission of using it to spread false information . . . weaponizing my data Can you link me to what Cambridge Analytica actually did with the data? I've been really curious about it but I can't find anything concrete.
- gdulli 9y agoWell the founder was recorded admitting to creating fake news for political purposes in an untraceable manner. The FB data would have let them target and personalize it. And the 2016 election was flooded with targetted fake news from obscured foreign sources. I don't personally have access to CA's operations and communications. It's for investigators to prove if A and B are connected. It's up to us to deploy Occam's razor.
- reaperducer 9y ago>If cable and phone companies were politically weaponizing my data the same way I'd be just as concerned. What makes you think they aren't? They have influencers in Washington, just like any political group does. The only difference between what the ISPs did and CA did is that the ISPs sell the data, whereas CA stole it. Your data still gets transferred.
- gdulli 9y agoOf course they lobby, and for self-serving purposes. And that could use reform. But it's not related to the FB/CA story. They use our data to participate in the ad-tech ecosystem but that's separate from lobbying, which doesn't benefit from having my likes or social graph in any way I'm aware of.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoWe should implement browser extensions that randomly go to sites in the background, and create so much noise that the ISPs can't get any signal from us.
- gcb0 9y agobe more useful and run a tor node
- pfarnsworth 9y agoMost tor nodes are government run anyway what’s the point.
- eric_lu 9y agowtliteralf
- mistrial9 9y agoa key difference here is the data structures behind the scenes, dont you think? FB built a state-of-the-art pipeline designed for graph analytics, and sold that as a revenue source. Meanwhile, the ISPs spent money on attorneys to secure favorable legal terms, and the "moron count" inside the company is likely quite high.. A zillion streams of sequential records are more like the 90s data warehouse situation, not FB graph search.
- dna_polymerase 9y agoOh cool, now it is the big ISPs. What is the Guardian coming up with next? "The ISPs surveillance is nothing compared with the NSA"?? How are people waking up only now? Snowden happened in 2013!
- jwilk 9y ago> Your provider can see [...] what medical symptoms you search [...]. Everything that is unencrypted is fair game. Which search engines are unencrypted these days?
- xexers 9y agoWhen the article says "what medical symptoms you search"... Comcast can't see what you search if you're connected to a page using https, right? All of the major search engines and medical sites all use https... so, what are they talking about?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIndeed. They can know you're at WebMD, not that you looked up erectile dysfunction symptoms at WebMD. Only the ad companies get that kind of detail. And beyond that, we're so centralized these days that most websites people spend time on are generic. For example, you have no idea what someone's interests are because they connect to Reddit, Google, Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube, nor who they might be communicating with over those domains.
- alvil 9y agoYou are right but they were not mentioned by Soros in Davos 2018 :)
- iClaudiusX 9y agoThe text of Joint Resolution 34 when it passed in the Senate last year https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-joint-resolution/34 https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-joint-re... The role call vote breakdown https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?congress=115&session=1&vote=00094 https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_... Ars Technica's coverage of the bill (now law) with context https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/senate-votes-to-let-isps-sell-your-web-browsing-history-to-advertisers/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/senate-votes-to-...
- alexnewman 9y agoand amex is even scarrier
- feelin_googley 9y agoNaive questions: What has been the US legal/regulatory framework governing "privacy" that telecomunications operators have had to work within for the past thirty years? Has Facebook had to operate within that same framework? As FB grew, has it been subject to the same restrictions? Has Facebook, with the billions they have made through collecting and monetising user data, and with the competition they have given to the telecommunications providers, played any role in any "shrinking" of past privacy protections afforded telecom subscribers? I have not lived very long but the big difference I see from past decades is that collecting user data and monetising it is viewed as a "core business". While I was not yet born at the time, I am confident that the telegraph was not funded by reading peoples telegrams and trying to sell that information to merchants. As far as I know telephone service was not funded by recording peoples conversations and marketing the value of the collected information to advertisers. Even consumer internet service, first appearing in the 1990s, was not funded by collecting user data and trying to "monetise" it. "Free" communication thanks to the internet has brought us a new type of company. It operates in a legal grey area, free from many of the restrictions that applied to its predecessors. Until proven otherwise, it appears that without collecting data on users and marketing it to third parties, this type of company cannot survive. Yet, whether these new companies exist or not, as far as I can see communication over the internet is still "free". (The cost being the internet subscription fees.) Of course when a user chooses to utilise the "services" of these companies to "simplify" their internet use (or even their first introduction to the internet), that notion of "free" becomes rather complicated.
- gcb0 9y agosites and isp were excempt of all common carrier laws. then fcc tried to add privacy considerations on isp similar to telcos, but that was shot down recently by republicans. granted, if the proposals also included sites/advertising, democrats would join in shutting it down.
- mattsfrey 9y agoYet another reason Musk's new satellite internet will be awesome. I'd personally sacrifice some bandwidth for privacy.
- ironjunkie 9y agowhat makes you feel that one will be "private"? Please don't tell me that you believe into the Musk PR. Google used to be the same way "Don't be evil...". It is the great circle of life. The incumbents love to be privacy-centric, but as soon as they become big enough, they realize that they can make a shitload of money with data//metadata now that they got a captive set of customers
- mattsfrey 9y agoTrue, I have more faith in that guy though. Maybe he is just another money grubbing hackjob that will eventually morph his companies into evil enterprises but it just doesn't seem like thats his schtick atm.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoNo he just releases software that kills a customer, and then publicly releases the data from the car sensors to paint the now dead customer as an incompetent driver. Sounds like exactly the person to trust with my privacy.
- akvadrako 9y agoThat guy is a scam artist. Tesla accounting is very abnormal; it's probably why the CFO quit.
- loourr 9y agoYeah, sure, agreed, but why call the article that? Don't we want them all to stop sucking?
- confounded 9y agoIf you have a local independent ISP, use them! Two great ones in SF, MonkeyBrains and Sonic. Both support net neutrality, and don't do any of this evil shit. https://www.monkeybrains.net/ https://www.monkeybrains.net/ https://www.sonic.com/ https://www.sonic.com/
- mikeyanderson 9y agoIf you talk to a sales person from any third party ad service and ask questions about what you can do with data—you'll find there is an entire market of buying and selling data from every cell company, credit card company, banks, corporate rewards cards, voting records and donations, etc.
- friendlydude12 9y agoHow about they all pose a serious threat to privacy?
- _bxg1 9y agoThe good news is, HTTPS is pretty common these days and Cloudflare just launched encrypted DNS (1.1.1.1). Those two things cover a large portion of exposed data. If you're on Android, this is an excellent app that allows you to set a custom DNS server across all apps and connections, without root: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.jak_linux.dns66/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.jak_linux.dns66/. As a bonus it also lets you blacklist domains, though of course that's not relevant to concerns about your ISP. Be wary of third-party VPNs, though (bottom section titled "VPNs could put you at risk"): https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/06/aiming-for-anonymity-ars-assesses-the-state-of-vpns-in-2016/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/06/aimin...
- khana 9y agoYES.
- joelrunyon 9y agoHow about both are bad?
- 908087 9y agoMy ISP can't sniff what I'm doing on a properly encrypted website. Google Analytics and Facebook "like" buttons, however, certainly can and do.
- ereyes01 9y agoYes, ISPs can snoop on you to a degree, but I don't see how it's worse than Facebook or Google. ISPs have to work around widespread (and growing) encryption, while Google/Facebook have your _actual_ data... plus, they know way more about you in minute detail via their mobile apps and devices. My home internet is VPN'ed and unless my ISP is expending undue effort on monitoring me, it can't see much detail about what I do on the Internet. However, Google/Facebook break all the security layers because we explicitly _trust_ them with all our data. Unless something fundamentally changes (maybe via net neutrality somehow allowing ISPs to penalize encrypted traffic or something), I don't see how Facebook/Google don't run away with all the power here.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> ISPs have to work around widespread (and growing) encryption, while Google/Facebook have your _actual_ data. Today. But in terms of risk moving forward, I think ISPs are way worse. Two reasons: 1) I really can choose not to use Google/Facebook. There exist very solid, privacy-respecting alternatives for every service these two companies offer. It's a matter of consumer choice. This is not the case for ISPs. If my (one) local "high-speed" ISP demands that I install a new root cert so they can MITM all my traffic, my choices are to a) capitulate, or b) find a way to live with very low-speed DSL/dial-up. Monopoly power backed up by a vast network of cables has way more staying power than monopoly power backed up by social network effects (FB) or superior software offerings (Gmail). 2) You might argue that history demonstrates we don't have to worry about ISPs demanding to MITM customer traffic. But Historically, ISPs weren't incentivized to snoop because of regulatory barriers that prevented collection/use of data for advertising purposes. In the case of US ISPs, changes in regulator landscape suggest that past behavior doesn't guarantee future behavior.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> If my (one) local "high-speed" ISP demands that I install a new root cert so they can MITM all my traffic I don't see what sense it makes to worry about that before it actually happens. Especially when there's no reason to believe it is going to happen.
- chvid 9y agoThis is a somewhat misguided article. Your ISP does not have access to most of your communication, social media usage and searches as that runs thru https. That is why Facebook and others is completely blocked in China. Had the national carriers been able to surveil and block select communication they would have been asked to do so by the government. Secondly an ISP charges you a subscription and that is their revenue model. They are not incentivised to build an elaborate profile on your in order to deliver advertisement. Thirdly ISPs in most countries are required by law to support the police with surveillance information. That is done in transparent way (you can read the laws and ask your politicians). This police support has always existed sinces the days of the tele monopolies. However now that more communication runs via internet, https and social media, it creates this strange inbalance where the police cannnot get the same access to Facebook (or similar) communication as they can to SMS or voice communication. Also Facebook provides different level of access to the NSA, the police in Denmark and the police in Myanmar. And do that in a non-transparent manner.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Secondly an ISP charges you a subscription and that is their revenue model. They are not incentivised to build an elaborate profile on your in order to deliver advertisement. That's exactly the opposite of how corporations work. Especially corporations in monopoly/duopoly markets. In fact, US ISPs lobbied heavily for the right to do exactly that, without user permission, and got their way. > Thirdly ISPs in most countries are required by law to support the police with surveillance information. That is done in transparent way (you can read the laws and ask your politicians). But that's not what this is about.
- kraig 9y agocame here to say this, surprised i had to dig so far to find this view
- fiatpandas 9y ago>Secondly an ISP charges you a subscription and that is their revenue model. They are not incentivised to build an elaborate profile on your in order to deliver advertisement. Please, everyone, stop saying things like this. Just because you pay a company money for a service does not mean you magically have a perfectly balanced relationship with them. They are in a position of extreme power and will not stop caring about aggregating what you do in a machine readable format in fine detail, all the while doing so behind a veil of legalese opt-out style tactics. Beyond the lobbying for more relaxed data collection / monetization laws, ISPs have been fined in the past for injecting tracking cookies to keep better record of your browsing habits. They’ve been caught selling IP identification api’s. No, they don’t care about delivering advertising to you, they just want to broker your data to companies who will.
- drawkbox 9y agoYour ISP tracking your every move is scarier than anything after the ISP privacy bill passed [1][2]. At least Facebook and Google give you something for it and you can route around them if you desire. No routing around ISPs unless you use a VPN but even then they will start blocking those again. Broadband/cable/telcos capture everything you do and can now sell that information and do [1][2]. That bill was the pre-cursor to removing net neutrality by taking privacy and policy from the FCC to the FTC. Part of Jeff Flake's argument for getting rid of the privacy protections were so that ISPs can compete with Facebook and Google and sell your data/offer ads to you. Yet Facebook and Google at least built products you wanted that you willingly gave up privacy to use and at least got something for it [3][4]. ISPs you have to pay to use and they still take your data as if you are the product. ISPs could have built products people wanted to get that data but they instead bribed 'representatives' to get it via legislation with their local monopolies. Noone wanted this bill but ISPs [2]. I expect tracking from free services I am not paying for that my data is the product. I expect tracking from companies that make their money from ad/marketing to do that. I do not expect tracking and privacy invasions from my ISP, my front door to the internet. I can't route around my ISP, there is no local competition and what competition there is amounts to false competition. From the FCCs own data, most people only have 1 or maybe 2 real competitive ISPs in their area and virtually no competition at 100Mbps, zero options for gigabit [5][6]. > FCC report finds almost no broadband competition at 100Mbps speeds [5][6]. > Even at 25Mbps, 43 percent of the US had zero ISPs or just one [5][6]. ISPs like Comcast, Verizon, AT&T etc are your base gateway to the network and entry point. Facebook is just built on top of the network. ISPs lobbied hard to remove your privacy protections for a reason [1][2] as stated in Jeff Flake's op-ed as the bill sponsor. [3][4] > The FCC rules subject all web browsing and app usage data to the same restrictive requirements as sensitive personal information. That means that information generated from looking up the latest Cardinals score or checking the weather in Scottsdale is treated the same as personal health and financial data. > The new rules also restrict an ISP’s ability to inform customers about innovative and cost-saving product offerings. So much for consumer choice. So privacy protections were removed for 'consumer choice' according to the bill. ISPs lobbied hard to remove network neutrality so your ISP can not only bias connections but track your every move, reducing consumer choice. ISPs you cannot route around or not use and there is false competition in most areas and really only one provider so they have local monopolies [5][6], reducing consumer choice. Instead of building products on top of the web they bribed and lobbied to get their way, reducing consumer choice. When you only have a handful of large ISPs where AT&T has been known to split your data to share with the NSA and authorities, that is dangerous [7]. > Room 641A is a telecommunication interception facility operated by AT&T for the U.S. National Security Agency that commenced operations in 2003 and was exposed in 2006 [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/senate-votes-to-let-isps-sell-your-web-browsing-history-to-advertisers/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/senate-votes-to-... [2] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/03/five-creepy-things-your-isp-could-do-if-congress-repeals-fccs-privacy-protections https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/03/five-creepy-things-you... [3] https://www.flake.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/3/op-ed-for-the-wall-street-journal https://www.flake.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/3/op-ed-f... [4] https://www.flake.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/3/flake-introduces-resolution-to-protect-consumers-from-overreaching-internet-regulation https://www.flake.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/3/flake-i... [5] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/02/fcc-report-finds-almost-no-broadband-competition-at-100mbps-speeds/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/02/fcc-r... [6] https://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2018/db0207/DOC-349074A1.pdf https://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/201... [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- markhahn 9y agohow about banks and cc companies? commercial behavior is inherently less noisy than social - though finding disparities between them would be interesting.
- droopybuns 9y agoI think this is fear mongering in the extreme. Facebook, Twitter and Google have persuaded all of the major internet sites to add code to their pages in the hope that it will drive more page views. At this point they have implemented enough code to reap the same level of benefit that you might get from passively MITM’ing all internet traffic. What’s “worse”, is that Facebook and Google are campaigning heavily to move all web traffic to encrypted. The end result: a “more secure” internet that just happens to fend off a competitive threat. The author should be ashamed of themselves. I think this falls under the “relative privation” fallacy. Google and FB are peerless when it comes to surveillance.
- gcb0 9y agoplus google amp, where google serves your site from their servers. and 4.4.4.4 and 8.8.8.8 dns servers, where they can see which ssl site you visit that still haven't added their spy code
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- electriclove 9y agoThis is typical Facebook manipulation of media to take the eye off them.
- zmitri 9y agoYou were down voted, but this is actually an internal talking point that FB uses to rally their current employees behind the company with. Some of the points an FB employee said about the situation around a week ago: "Well the ISPs are worse" "Imagine if it was them instead of us, we do a better job" "Net Neutrality is the real problem". They think of everything as a PR problem unfortunately, and would rather go this route than dealing with the problems they have.
- jason_slack 9y agoCan anyone talk about hardware and software one can run at home to help protect themselves more? I have a pfsense box for firewalling the whole connection. I should look and see if I can integrate VPN with this as well. Right now I use a personal router with Astrill VPN for when I am out and about at coffee places. This: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01K6MHRJI/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01K6MHRJI/ref=oh_aui_sear... Plus I also have this Ubiquite Edge Router I carry around too for wired connections. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00YFJT29C/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00YFJT29C/ref=oh_aui_sear...
- mithoon 9y agoISP data is "Our" data, whereas FB/ Google data is "MY" data. So they can generally be extremely accurate.
- vladsanchez 9y agoI was saying this while the Cambridge Analytica scandal unfolded. All my UVerse traffic goes thru AT&T proxy servers and that dwarves what FB and Google get from me on a regular basis.
- LeoPanthera 9y agoI've been forwarding all outgoing connections on port 80 (and a selection of other commonly-unencrypted ports) through a VPN (in the router) for a while now - but leaving all other ports (including most importantly 443) connecting directly. It feels like a good compromise between privacy and speed.
- CodinM 9y ago* possibly, if you live in the U.S.
- neo4sure 9y agoThe biggest difference here that we don't pay to use facebook or google. We pay to use Comcast and most of the time we don't have an alternative.
- wemdyjreichert 9y agoThough it's a problem, theres a solution: VPN. Openvpn and outline are 2 good options you can use to roll-you-own gigabit on a vps for $5/mo.
- peterwwillis 9y agoIf you use Chrome or Firefox, almost all of your data is hidden from the ISP - increadingly more sites use HTTPS, and use a CDN, and browsers are implementing DNS over HTTPS and have their own DNS resolvers. In addition, providers like Google are literally proxying your mobile requests to unrelated sites to capture even more data. Google and CloudFlare can see probably more than 90% of your traffic without even trying. Google's business model is dependent on selling advertisement based on your data. Your ISP can see maybe 50%, and it's shrinking fast. All of these companies exist because you agreed to them. You're paying them to continue this behavior, or using their free services. Stop agreeing to free services and stop using monopolies. Lobby your local government to overturn laws preventing municipal internet providers. That won't happen though, because people don't really care that much about surveillance to go to those lengths just to stop it. Hell, the NSA is still illegally wiretapping US citizens.
- GordonS 9y ago> If you use Chrome or Firefox, almost all of your data is hidden from the ISP Can you elaborate on how Chrome and Firefox hide your traffic from your ISP, and what privacy advantages they have over IE, Safari or Opera?
- peterwwillis 9y agoSure. Chrome and Firefox both implement (or are implementing) DNS over HTTPS, which hides what domains you're visiting by passing the request encrypted through a provider such as Google. Chrome also has a "data saver" on mobile that passes your traffic through Google's servers. Opera has had similar functionality for some time. Safari and IE will implement DNS over HTTPS once it's a standard, which should be soon. Don't know if they have plans to support tunneling too.
- iggg 9y agoWhat is stopping yourisp from doing reverse dns and looking up what domain is pointing to the IP you are connecting to?
- dabockster 9y agoGood luck, I'm behind seven proxies.
- kerng 9y agoDoesn't Comcast even require a special router, where they install custom certs and packet analysis software. Remember a friend of mine was on the phone long with their support, because he just wanted to use his own router, but Comcast wouldn't wanna patch him through. Anyone had similar experience? I can ask him again for details.
- thrillgore 9y agoIt would be nice if the US had GDPR policies like the EU has. Shit, it would be nice if we had a functioning democracy.
- innagadadavida 9y agoI’m disappointed that a respectable website like the guardian is trying to take the heat away from Facebook and google in this recent privacy fiasco. Please don’t click on that article and give them your cookies/clicks/profile/$$$
- hacknat 9y agoMost web traffic is encrypted these days so ISPs can only see what sites you’re visiting via DNS and SNI. While that is worrisome, I fail to see how that is greater data than my search history.
- 75dvtwin 9y agoThis article reads to me like a propaganda piece, employing USSR-style 'what-aboutism' argument [1]. ISPs 'could be worse' than Facebook already is, the article argues. >"Your internet provider doesn’t just know what you do on Facebook – it sees all the sites you visit and how much time you spend there. Your provider can see where you shop, what you watch on TV, <" But, really, a consumer has a choice of VPN to protect his/her traffic, and demarry it from their identity. This is not an option when a user has to login to use features within Facebook or Google+, or Youtube. What I think is happening, is that Ad-revenue based service providers (eg most CA-based 'thought-leaders') are deathly afraid of consumers choosing VPN. I think, actually, ISPs should encourage consumers to use VPN, this way ISPs will still get paid their 'utility' value, but the 'digital footprint collection, and then Ad-selling business companies, would have to rethink their business models... Which is why, the content-providers propaganda machine was so intensive against repeal of 'net-neutrality' (which was, essentially, a form of business-net-privilege for Ad-selling content providers). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- throw2016 9y agoEither you are concerned about surveillance or you are not. If you are then you would have to be concerned about both. And more about Google and Facebook because of their global reach, access to location and content across all devices, an insatiable greed for user data including collation from all available sources to build detailed long term profiles of individuals, not unlike files by the stasi. Here is Facebook trying to get user data from hospitals. [1]. This is truly sinister. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/05/facebook-building-8-explored-data-sharing-agreement-with-hospitals.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/05/facebook-building-8-explored...
- whatupmd 9y agoDoesn't the guardian mean Sky, BT, and Virgin Media?
- eveningcoffee 9y agoWhy greater or smaller? The effect of this comparison will only diminish Facebook risk in people minds. The right answer is that Comcast, AT&T and Verizon pose a the same surveillance risk as Facebook.
- cronix 9y agoIn addition to the ISP you use, the DNS you use sees all as well, doesn't it?
- jh72de 9y agoThe NSA already has access to all that data that internet access provides can gather themselves.