11 ms·
Great Vowel Shift
- wirrbel 9y agoWell, a vowel shift isn't that unusual, with english however, and 17 vowels, the regularisation of the spelling never happened (and would be difficult now as folks would have to agree on one prestigious pronunciation to be the standard).
- walterbell 9y agoWhich languages have fewer vowels than English?
- lifthrasiir 9y agoFor starters, Japanese has five [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_phonology#Vowels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_phonology#Vowels
- lhorie 9y agoWhat about や (ya), ゆ (yu), よ (yo), わ (wa), ー (dash)?
- eecsninja 9y agoThose are modifications of existing vowels, or diphthongs. E.g. し(shi) + や(ya) = しゃ (sha), still the same 'a' sound. English has only 5 vowel characters but more than 5 vowel sounds.
- lhorie 9y agoI mean the weak `i` in や. きや (ki-ya, as in sukiyaki) sounds different than きゃ (kya, as in "argh"), similar to how "meow" can be pronounced /miˈaʊ̯/ or /mjaʊ̯/
- Nadya 9y agoきゃ is not きや as in "kiya" but きゃ as in "kya" - the i in き becomes silent, きや would be something else. For example, 東京 isn't pronounced「とうきよう」but 「とうきょう」.
- lhorie 9y agoRight, Japanese has both /iˈ/ and /j/ sounds. Another example that happens outside the や column is イェス (yes).
- chadlavi 9y agothis is just because of the shift of historical "ヱ" ("ye") getting pronounced as "エ" ("e") then just not used anymore. They're using "イ" as a semivowel here, /j/, not as the vowel /i/.
- amyjess 9y agoOddly enough, it's been my observation that in きゃ and ぎゃ, the /a/ sound is considerably fronted compared to other syllables. It's usually realized as the central vowel [ä], but in these two, it's often fronted to [a]. This is why these syllables are used to render English words containing /kæ/ into Japanese, such as "cannon" (キャノン kyanon) or "cat" (キャット kyatto). Contrast with "cut" (カット katto) or "car" (カー kā). Japanese has some interesting allophones. I also find the allophones in the Z-row fascinating as well ([z] and [d͡z] are allophones in free variation).
- zodiac 9y agoI think that /j/ sound is classified as a consonant, not a vowel
- gizmo686 9y ago/j/ is a semivowel. Generally, these are classified and behave as consonants, but their vowel-like behavior still creeps in sometimes.
- 9y ago
- mcv 9y ago> English has only 5 vowel characters but more than 5 vowel sounds. So what are we counting here? The sounds or the characters we use to represent the sounds? Because if you go by sounds, I think Dutch has more than 14. (a, aa, o, oo, e, è, ee, u, uu, i, ie, eu, ui, au, ij, oe) I've heard that in Czech, the 'r' can be a vowel. In a name like Brno, for example. Those are apparently two syllables. (I don't speak Czech, so no idea if it's true.)
- bassman9000 9y agoSpanish has five. Period. No exceptions. And crystal clear.
- egwynn 9y ago1. You deserve my downvote for claiming “no exceptions” in a linguistic matter. 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_phonology#Exact_number_of_allophones https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_phonology#Exact_number... There is no agreement among scholars on how many vowel allophones Spanish has.
- spanxx 9y agoFrontera tour link: > According to Eugenio Martínez Celdrán, however, systematic classification of Spanish allophones is impossible due to the fact that their occurrence varies from speaker to speaker and from region to region. According to him, the exact degree of openness of Spanish vowels depends not so much on the phonetic environment, but rather on various external factors accompanying speech. So parent point stands. That's my opinion as well as a Spaniard.
- ithkuil 9y ago"no exceptions" sounds like the focus is on rules, in particular on orthography (correct writing). It's easy to ban exceptions if you make the rules. This is the realm of prescriptive linguistics. The very fact that there are individuals and whole group of people who actually talk differently can, has been, and still often is dismissed as either ignorance, class, personal idiosincrasies, ... There is a different way at looking at the thing: observing it objectively as other things in nature. This descriptive linguistics is endlessly fascinating to me, as it's less infected by human desires that have nothing to do with linguistics and all to do with politics. An example of where those two viewpoints begin to present reality in a quite different way and yet don't require to be a trained linguist to grasp it is the definition of where a dialect ends and a language begins.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoAllophones are not a great thing to cite in a dispute over how many vowels a language has. Unless you know you're in a context where people are talking about allophones specifically, no one will care.
- 1maginary 9y agoOff the top of my head, most romance languages. You could argue some German dialects as well, Japanese, etc. Maybe even Chinese depending on your definition of 'vowel'. Are you talking phonemes or actual phones? English has ~17 vowels, which isn't the most a language has, but that's quite a few
- thedirt0115 9y agoTagalog/Filipino (the national language of the Philippines) has 5, very similar pronunciation to vowels in Spanish.
- nohat00 9y agoPretty much all of them. http://phonetic-blog.blogspot.com/2010/11/vowel-inventories.html http://phonetic-blog.blogspot.com/2010/11/vowel-inventories.... says that the average number of vowels in a language is just below 6, and "large" vowel inventories are of size 7-14.
- jcranmer 9y agoEnglish is on the heavier side of vowels, although much of it is diphthongs. The "standard" vowel system is 5 basic vowels (vaguely an a, e, i, o, u, although not as English tends to pronounce those), although some languages (e.g., most American languages) have only 3 or 4. Many languages have a few more monophthongs. English has an additional mid a/e sound, an additional i sound, and another few more u's. There's also the unstressed vowel (aka schwa), and a couple of diphthongs.
- DJohnBenton 9y agoSomewhat related, there was also a "capitalisation shift" in the late 1600s where everyone (or their editors) started writing more nouns as capitalised (e.g. "The quick brown Fox jumped over the lazy Dog"), and then switched back in the mid-1700s. Interesting to know what might have been. https://github.com/DanielJohnBenton/capitalisation-shift-google-ngrams#the-great-capitalisation-shifts https://github.com/DanielJohnBenton/capitalisation-shift-goo...
- thescriptkiddie 9y agoIn modern German, all nouns (but not pronouns, except for formal pronouns) are capitalized.
- wirrbel 9y agoyes, one of the strangest spelling rules. Not useful at all
- keeganjw 9y agoI remember when I first started learning German, I thought it was useless. But after getting used to it, when I switched back to English, I was like where are all the nouns? Why is everything lowercase? It's all about what you get used to, I guess.
- hyperpallium 9y agoTo maximize information content (entropy), we must try to use all symbols with equal likelihood - which this rule assists, employing capital symbols with closer to equal likelihood than their usual rarity. Furthermore, said symbols must convey previously unknown information - which this rule does not, as the nouns have the same meaning whether capitalized as not, and the "information" conveyed is redundant.
- mishac 9y agoHuman languages aren’t usually concerned with maximal information density though. Multiple layers of redundancy are often present. Features like noun verb agreement, grammatical gender, pleonasms, and even redundant words (last will and testament, vim and vigor etc) are used in various languages despite the redundancy, to increase clarity.
- vidanay 9y agoIf you are a native English speaker trying to lean a Germainic foreign language, then retraining yourself that the vowels are pronounced "ah, ay, e, oh, ooh" instead of "ay, e, eye, oh, you" helps your pronunciation tremendously.
- nohat00 9y agoVirtually every language that uses the Latin alphabet follows some version of this plan for spelling vowels, not just Germanic ones. There is a reason the International Phonetic Alphabet uses the 5 basic vowel symbols /a/, /e/, /i/, /o/, /u/ this way.
- wtdo 9y agoAs a native English speaker, this is also helpful with learning Vietnamese, which also uses the Latin alphabet.
- gus_massa 9y agoSpanish native speaker here, but I know a little of German. In the books of "Dora the Explorer", usually the letter "i" in Spanish is replaced by the sound that makes "ee" instead of the sound of "e". So your first list should be "ah, ay, ee, oh, ooh"
- vidanay 9y agoDownsides of trying to illustrate sounds with writing without using IPA (which I do not know enough of). I'm sure we are saying the same thing.
- lhorie 9y agoe sounds more like `eh` though (at least in latin-derived languages and japanese). Pronouncing it `ay` is generally seen as a strong english accent.
- hannele 9y ago\e\ is a sound that is basically impossible to represent unambiguously to English speakers, without falling back to how it's used in words ('e' as in 'ten', for example). `eh` and `ay` can both easily be read as a dipthong that would be represented as `ei` in any reasonably spelled language (like Finnish).
- Slackwise 9y agoJust heard of "The Great Vowel Shift" on the "Lexicon Valley"[1] linguistics podcast, which covered the idiosyncrasies of English spelling, and how the vowel shift was a large factor in how pronunciations diverged from their spellings. [1]: http://www.slate.com/articles/podcasts/lexicon_valley/2018/04/john_mcwhorter_on_english_spelling.html http://www.slate.com/articles/podcasts/lexicon_valley/2018/0...
- dep_b 9y agoThe pre-shift vowels are written and sound almost exactly the same as modern Dutch.
- macandcheese 9y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplified_Spelling_Board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplified_Spelling_Board
- richardfontana 9y agoSee also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Cities_Vowel_Shift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Cities_Vowel_Shift , a significant chain vowel shift that has been developing in some dialects of American English. It's detectable for example (though in a relatively mild form) in the speech of Hillary Clinton.
- onlyrealcuzzo 9y agoWait, wait, wait. Does this article mean to tell me that cot and caught DON'T sound the same? Also stalk and stock? Oh no, I've got it ]=
- yorwba 9y agoAs a non-native speaker, I spent some time obsessing over the "correct" pronunciation of words, until I found this chart: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Phonetic_Alphabet_chart_for_English_dialects https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Phonetic_Alpha... Then I decided to just give up and adapt my pronunciation to that of whomever I'm speaking to.
- sverige 9y agoAs a native speaker, I grew up in an area where the boundaries of three American dialects were within about 25 miles, so I did the same. For example, it doesn't bother me at all to pronounce 'creek' as 'creek' or 'crick,' or 'wash' as 'wash' or 'warsh.' We all figured out where people in our little town came from by the way they pronounced a few different words. ('Roof' is another that tells something about you, for example.)
- stephen_g 9y agoMost languages have regional differences in pronunciation, so being able to pick up on how the people you’re speaking to pronounce things is a really valuable skill for language in general. As a native English speaker, I’ve always been quite good at learning to imitate accents (I can probably do about 10 or so different English-language accents), and I think it’s really helped when I’ve started learning other languages. I’ve been complimented for my pronunciation even early on (mainly using audio courses to start).
- fredch 9y ago>vowel shift In the name of the Internet, MOVEMENT. Vowel MOVEMENT. They have one job, and they blow it. Shameful. Still good information though.
- glup 9y agoFor anyone interested, there is some neat but not terribly well-known modeling work in cognitive science / phonology on chain shifts: http://linguistics.berkeley.edu/phonlab/documents/2007/op463-ettlinger1.pdf http://linguistics.berkeley.edu/phonlab/documents/2007/op463...
- marze 9y agoSo how do researchers determine how words were pronounced historically without audio recordings?
- edanm 9y agoI'm totally guessing, but maybe they use text that shows how something is pronounced? Eg for one example, if you know how one word is pronounced, and you have a poem that includes that word, you can follow rhymes.
- tvmalsv 9y agoOne of the ways can be through poetry. Since many poems tend to include rhymes, the pronunciation of a word can sometimes be gleaned by comparing it to its rhyme pair (there's probably an actual word for that). Of course, that presupposes you know the pronunciation of the other word. Edit: Pretty much what edanm said. I really should do a page refresh before replying when the tab has been open for a while :)
- lainga 9y agoAs Shakespeare wrote in As You Like It: And then, from hour to hour, we rot and rot / And thereby hangs a tale Which is wittier when you realise that hour was pronounced like whore in his day.
- JacobAldridge 9y agoThe quote I learned about the Great Vowel Shift from was Henry IV, Part I. If reasons were as plentiful as blackberries, where the prof explained it was a pun because "reasons" was pronounced more like "raisins" in 1597.
- petercooper 9y agoA video on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPlpphT7n9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPlpphT7n9s (with examples)
- kmm 9y ago
- peter303 9y ago'Pirate dialect' was during the vowel shift according to linguist McWhorter. Longer vowels were replacing the earlier shorter German ones.
- jrobn 9y agoI wish English kept some of its runic hold overs like the letter thorn “þ” (th sound). “þe fox ran þurh þe field.” I could imagine the confusion for non native English speakers when they encountered: through thought brought bought daughter All hold overs from old English when the “gh” came from the throat and was spelled with a “ȝ”
- js2 9y agoIf you've never seen Gallagher's routine on English you'll enjoy it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mfz3kFNVopk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mfz3kFNVopk
- jrobn 9y agoThank you! I recalled seeing this this as a young kid. Great re-watch.
- bhrgunatha 9y agoNo discussion about inconsistent spelling and pronunciation is complete without The Chaos by Gerard Nolst Trenité, a non-native speaker! http://www.businessinsider.com/english-spelling-pronunciation-poem-the-chaos-2017-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/english-spelling-pronunciatio...
- henrikschroder 9y agoDaughter. Tochter. Oh!
- rootbear 9y agoHaving dabbled in text-to-speech algorithms, I wish English had kept both eth and thorn, or had SOME way to distinguish voiced vs unvoiced th. There are few clues.
- bagacrap 9y agoWhy are those words confusing in the context of one another? They seem pretty consistent to me as long as you aren't confused about the order of the adjacent t and h pairs.
- ineedasername 9y agoNearly as interesting is "why" there was a great vowel shift: Plague. While difficult to prove, it's commonly believed by linguists to have been caused, or very greatly helped along, by the bubonic plague and the extreme amount of social upheaval and migration it caused over its extended rampage through that area of the world. I was rather surprised the wikipedia entry didn't mention that factor, it was spoken of as an established fact when I was in grad school. (https://esoterx.com/2016/04/20/language-is-a-bacterium-the-disease-theory-of-the-great-vowel-shift/ https://esoterx.com/2016/04/20/language-is-a-bacterium-the-d...)
- markdog12 9y agoIt's in there > Some scholars[who?] have argued that the rapid migration of peoples from northern England to the southeast following the Black Death
- ghayes 9y agoI also tend to believe the French influence as a likely cause, also mentioned in the article.
- ineedasername 9y agoOh i missed that, was looking for "plague", thanks
- lillesvin 9y ago> it's commonly believed by linguists to have been caused, or very greatly helped along, by the bubonic plague I have a master's degree in linguistics and I've never heard about that theory before. I don't want to argue about the validity of it (obviously, because I'm not familiar with it) but I will say that I don't agree that it's commonly believed by linguists.
- postcynical 9y agoSmall anecdote from history: Back in the days, the conservative Swiss looked down on those vowel shift hipsters in Germany and thought that the simple vowels where good enough as they were. So the Swiss-German spoken today is basically a pre-vowel-shift German, "Haus" [pron: house] vs "Huus" [pron: Hoose]. Mid/northern Germans find it super hard to understand Swiss-German (or mistake it with German spoken with a Swiss accent). Perhaps we start to see a similar shift happening in France where yougsters start to mix up vowels in everyday words.
- sixstringtheory 9y agoI’ve been reading a modern english translation of the Canterbury Tales, and once upon a time had to memorize the first part of the prologue in middle english. It’s nice to see some of the linguistic theory describing how the latter became the former. PS give a ME translation of Canterbury Tales a try, it is super impressive.
- fouc 9y ago> Great Vowel Shift is responsible for the fact that English spellings now often strongly deviate in their representation of English pronunciations. Can someone explain this in simpler terms? I'm too tired to interpret this.
- qalmakka 9y agoIn layman's terms: people in England around ~1400/1500 started to change how vowels sounded in almost every word (i.e., /a/ shifted to /ei/, /i/ to /ai/, ..). Given that written languages often evolve much more slowly than their spoken form, people simply kept writing everything with its middle English spelling (which now had lots of wrongly placed vowels and mute consonants, such as [gh] and the [k] in "knight"), giving birth to the messy English spelling we all use and love. This is also the reason why English speaking kids find spelling so difficult, and spelling bees exist - people are actually writing in an older version of the language they speak.
- peteretep 9y agoSo "out" went from "oot" to "owt", "about" went from "aboot" to "abowt", eh? Thank God for traditionalist Canadians and Northumbrians.