7 ms·
“Did We Create This Monster?” How Twitter Turned Toxic
- furicane 9y agoThat's why I refer to it as Twatter. I am pleased certain twats found what I wrote offensive. Please, mash that flag button, that's your life's purpose ;)
- overcast 9y agoIt's just human nature, people are awful in general, and the internet allows them to bring it to the masses easily, with very few repercussions.
- camillomiller 9y agoPeople are generally good, they just tend not to be very vocal about that. Twitter and Facebook, on the other hand, tend to give a megaphone to bad people, allowing them to spread their message wider and louder. That is inherently bad, because thanks to network effect more people would behave in a way they would never allow in real life. My take away is that, after ten years, we can say that Facebook and Twitter have a negative impact on contemporary society.
- justicezyx 9y agoI think anyone read decent amount of history book can agree that "people are bad in general". What are the evidences for "People are generally good"?
- SirFatty 9y ago"some people are bad in general". FTFY
- TallGuyShort 9y agoMost of the stuff that isn't selected for inclusion in a history book.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wongarsu 9y agoHistory books only talk about the extreme actions of the most extreme people of any time period. Beyond "most people follow anyone who is charismatic" history books don't tell you much about humanity at large
- namelost 9y agoPeople are naive and easy to manipulate. Often (in history) they are manipulated into killing other people against their own interests. Few people are wilfully "good" or "bad".
- nemild 9y agoI hear this argument a lot, and let me just make one point: Human nature is really shapeable — and we (as a former product manager in this space) designed algorithms and product experiences to maximize certain outcomes that benefit social network bottom lines. Regardless of how good or bad human nature is, the algorithms prize engagement however they can get it — I personally believe it surfaces a certain side of humanity, and pushes people in a certain direction. If you're a news editor, you actually have a choice to sensationalize all day because it maximizes short-term profits. After bad things happened (see yellow journalism, the newspaper circulation wars) — newspapers did cut back a fair bit. (We can debate whether that was the risk of regulation, or their own respect for the role they had) This clearly isn't the social networks' fault alone, but their product choices do partially influence on how we all behave. On HN, you hear a lot of anger at journalists for being so click-baity, and the sad part is that every incentive many journalists face encourages this (from user behavior to profit) There are tons of examples how bad incentives can warp how people behave, far beyond "humanity is good" or "humanity is bad". For example, see Hannah Arendt's Banality of Evil or the Stanford Prison Experiment. More regularly, see architecture, urban planning, or product management in the Valley, as disciplines that think deeply about the outcomes they want to encourage. A more accurate statement I would say is: humanity has certain predilections, and design choices can influence these dramatically. (And now I will shill my media literacy for engineers guide — contributions welcome: https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer )
- rdiddly 9y agoTrue in general, but the only thing I see about how Twitter is designed, that has any significant effect of shaping behavior in a negative direction, is the anonymity, which it inherits from the internet itself. It's no Stanford Prison Experiment though. Maaaayyybe it's the guards' mirrored sunglasses if you want to make the analogy. But since the same feature is available to everyone, including as a protective feature for any would-be "prisoner" or victim, even that analogy breaks down. I'm just not seeing any power-unbalancing features that are inherent. As with most things, its best features are its worst.
- domevent 9y agoIt’s probably fairer to say that when there are no consequences for their actions, a statistically significant portion of people are awful, and those people are loud and obsessive.
- Kequc 9y agoSo Twitter doesn't censor enough, dunno how much more time or money Twitter could have spent trying to control the narrative. So the lesson here is that it's never enough. If you had Twitter completely sanitized there'd be people who don't understand 'changing the channel' complaining about too many meat-eaters on the platform.
- jlebrech 9y agocensorship basically allowed for trolls, memelords, bots, eggs and shitposters to thrive because of how they censored wrong-thinkers willing to have a rational discussion. only those who have nothing to lose are left in the conversation.
- neolefty 9y agoThe article argues that it wasn't so much censorship as poorly-implemented censorship. For example: > Internally, Costolo complained that the “abuse economics” were “backward.” It took just seconds to create an account to harass someone, but reporting that abuse required filling out a time-consuming form. And of course the larger story of a vigilante censor being blocked. Twitter doesn't want outside forces policing it, but that means it has to police itself, which it has failed to do at critical moments.
- jlebrech 9y agocensorship happened and the platform taking sides with one side made the other side even more nasty and cryptic in their actions.
- tajen 9y agoProbably the best explanation. Besides, our youth is getting used to censorship workarounds. Most people have two accounts per network. It really reminds me of a friend from Iran telling me about the underground bar culture in his country. It’s worrying that we have so much a problem with the opinions of others that our teenagers routinely rely on Iran-level techniques to navigate their world.
- wsinks 9y agoCan we learn more about the Iran underground bar culture? Or does putting that here violate that culture? Just curious.
- thinkingemote 9y agoIm trying to pinpoint when it started going wrong. I think it was when they changed the third party API usages etc which lead to solutions by others being cut off - they had to do everything themselves. But I also think it was the move towards threads and conversations. For a few years Twitter was mostly one directional . You would post your status, similar to how you would update your instant messaging away status. Twitter became a way to follow everyone's posts. Threads didn't exist and replying was not built in. After these two changes the company became blind drunk with growth and celebrity. Oprah moment.
- komali2 9y agoI like your second theory. I'm thinking about how you can easily avoid absurd alt-right conspiracy drivel by, for example, never reading Breitbart. But because NBC articles have a comment section, all the bullshit finds its way through anyway. Somebody could make an echo chamber argument at me I guess, but I should be allowed to filter out absolute falsehoods without being called "unfair and unbalanced."
- pmlnr 9y agoIn essence, it's simple: the moment they started adding more social features. Seeing how every network eventually spreads to the same directions (comments, reactions, stories, media elements, etc. ) the problem is they don't stick to core motives. Twitter: sharing 140 char (the 280 change was based on data, but still, it's a significant change) TEXT. It should never have grown into threads, images, videos, etc. Somewhere when it was still text only, but @mentions and #hastags already existed it should have stopped. Unfortunately this system wouldn't have the exponential growth in it, only to be a good system, an infrastructure.
- xefer 9y agoTwitter could start at home by doing something about the sewer that is "Moments". It ignores words in the "muted" list; it's full of celebrity crap and the sort of click-bait stuff I loathe. The whole thing seems to set the tone for the sort of garbage that they talk about wanting to eliminate.
- L-four 9y agoIf you allow the unwashed masses to communicate with you, you'll be communicating with the unwashed masses.
- cirgue 9y agoThe iron law of the internet is that, in the absence of constant high-quality moderation, all discourse eventually becomes toxic. This has been true since the days of usenet.
- gurkendoktor 9y agoThe tendency is there, but that doesn't mean that all social platforms become equally toxic over time.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ocschwar 9y agoI think it's more complicated than that. Github isn't toxic. Dreamwidth isn't toxic. The orientation towards microblogging has a lot to do with the toxicity.
- philwelch 9y agoGitHub has its moments.
- danharaj 9y ago> Github isn't toxic There's defo some toxicity on github.
- cctt23 9y agoIt’s mostly not though, and easy to avoid. On Twitter it seems to be the raison detre.
- cirgue 9y agoGitHub has high-quality moderation in the form of repo owners who have a vested interest in punishing bad actors.
- ocschwar 9y ago
- username223 9y agoWhy did this person expect anything else? That's what happens when you connect everyone in the world and let them shout at each other. It's the reason that Usenet readers had kill-files since the 1980s. He had the solution right in his hands: > “For the most part I found them rather laughable and easily ignored,” he says.
- nukeop 9y agoLet this be a lesson to others, the more censorship and the more draconic your allowed speech rules are, the worse you're off. The quality of overall discussion is negatively correlated with the amount of censorship.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danso 9y agoHN is the most moderated platform I currently use, but despite its rules and frequent mod intervention, it seems to have a higher overall quality of discussion compared to what I can find on Reddit or Twitter.
- exelius 9y agoThere is definitely a hive mind that is reinforced by the mods here. Reddit is far worse, but realize that Ycombinator has certain goals as an organization and if your comments stray into direct opposition, they will delete things. I don’t think this is an indictment of HN, just highlighting that there is an implicit bias in every discussion forum. Discussion is of high quality as long as it remains aligned, which is true 99% of the time.
- slantyyz 9y ago> Reddit is far worse, I would re-characterize it as "some Reddit subreddits are far worse" - because your experience can vary widely. All the subreddits I subscribe to (hobby and interest related, not news/politics) are actually self-policed very well. I tend to think the toxic subreddits are actually in the minority even though they get all the attention.
- nukeop 9y agoReddit is far worse in reinforcing subconscious self-moderation to adhere to the majority opinion. It's present on Hacker News too, since most people use the downvote as a "I disagree" button.
- alexashka 9y agoFor me, twitter is the least toxic and 'monstrous' of all social platforms that I've been on. I'd say the trend of articles on news sites using hyperbole and inflammatory language in every other headline to bait people into clicking is a far more serious issue. People on twitter do as they please - journalists need a hard look in the mirror before throwing stones at entire platforms.
- LargeWu 9y agoFor me it's the most toxic. I quit before they expanded the character limit, but the limited format almost completely annihilates the ability to express nuance. Combine that with everybody else assuming bad faith, it just devolves into people screaming at each other, often even when they agree.
- coldacid 9y agoHaving the ability to build a whole thread of tweets now would go a long way towards providing the nuance that has so far been missing, but almost nobody even knows it's there, never mind uses it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- komali2 9y ago>Contentiousness grew common: Bhatnagar’s team would want to suspend users it found abusive, only to be overruled by Gadde and Harvey. “That drove Tina crazy,” says a source familiar with the dynamic. “She’d go looking for Jack, but Jack would be at Square, so the next day he’d listen and take notes on his phone and say, ‘Let me think about it.’ Is it feasible for one person to be an effective CEO of two companies at the same time? Particular ones that are at the stages Twitter and Square are at?
- exelius 9y agoNot when decisions like this are funneled through the CEO. You can be effective if both startups are in fundraising mode: you’ll be having a lot of the same conversations with the same people. That’s a relationship game.
- amelius 9y agoMusk
- WhompingWindows 9y agoI'd say this is an example of poor workflow. If you have millions of users of your product, the CEO must be abstracted far above such mundane decisions. With someone like Elon Musk, you have a nitty-gritty focused CEO who wants to get onto the engineering/production floor and tackle the toughest bottlenecks. If you don't have a dual CEO at his level of expertise, though, I think you're setting yourself up for problems, especially with aforementioned crappy workflow.
- hluska 9y agoI don't agree. This was about censorship, an issue absolutely vital to the core Twitter experience. Choosing how/what to censor is absolutely not mundane.
- JaimeThompson 9y agoThis is true. I know of someone who has had their real name and email address posted on Twitter by someone to harass them and Twitter finds nothing wrong with it and says it doesn't violate their rules. However don't say a curse word or you might get a 24 hour / 7 day time out.
- upofadown 9y agoI don't get the "Imposter Buster" thing. Does Twitter verify the user images somehow? If not, then what extra responsibility do they have to police pictures over equally misleading text? Spam is spam. If they were actually spamming then Twitter had every right and obligation to shut their operation down. Spamming for a good cause does not make it right. In general, Joe jobbing against race only works against racists. Who cares about racists anyway?
- garethsprice 9y agoThey change the conversation, driving division and influencing opinion. Propaganda is very powerful, especially when a message appears to be coming from dozens/thousands of voices. Look at any controversial tweet these days and the reply thread is full of inflammatory comments from users with numeric usernames (@Joe154354), blurry photos (that can't be reverse image searched) and that seem to ONLY post about political topics and retweet similar voices. Heuristically they are highly likely to be bots or provocateurs but it's hard to prove as Twitter doesn't expose much information. Twitter has a serious bot/troll problem that they are choosing to ignore, and it is making the discourse on there toxic and untrustworthy. I find myself avoiding the platform these days as it just leaves me feeling stressed and sad.
- upofadown 9y ago>Propaganda is very powerful, especially when a message appears to be coming from dozens/thousands of voices. Well it shouldn't be on an anonymous forum. The only things that count in such a environment are ideas. Only the first one counts. The same ideas over and over again just count as a poor signal to noise ratio (which would be the root problem). I suspect that we are in some sort of eternal september[1] phase here where people are being exposed to such environments for the first time. If this sort of thing is going to be a social problem perhaps we need to teach anonymous forums in school. I personally have no interest in Twitter because I have passed the phase in my life where such a thing would be interesting. That doesn't mean that I think it is worthless but it seems that there are people who are taking it more seriously than it deserves. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- philwelch 9y agoTwitter was designed to be toxic and all of the incentives driving product development led them inexorably to that goal. (Hint: what do flamewars and harassment look like to your engagement metrics?)
- michaelfeathers 9y agoI think the architecture of social media spaces affects their culture. I wrote up some observations here: 'Twitter, Reddit, and Conway's Law' https://michaelfeathers.silvrback.com/social-media-architecture-and-conway-s-law https://michaelfeathers.silvrback.com/social-media-architect...
- mizay7 9y agoNo, its toxic by design. All the big social networks exist to serve advertisers. They sell users attention to marketers. This means that their profit is directly dependent on how much attention they can harvest. So the systems that emerge (consciously or not) propagate attention grabbing content. This means that trolling and toxicity which exist to get a reaction get systematically supported. It also means that the novel and affirming fake news get magnified. It also means that the lowest common denominator cruelty does best (hey Logan Paul and your 'prankster' cadre). None of this changes if you want tech and services paid for by your attention and mind-share. If users actually become customers then the question becomes what might they spend money on, not just what can we get them to pay attention to. And that can lead to much more sophisticated behavior. Behavior that actually reflects our conscious choices as opposed to subconscious impulses. Check out oalrus.com for my proposal to implement something like that.
- drefanzor 9y agoWith free speech, come idiots that abuse it and say hateful things. These are sacrifices necessary in order to live in a free society. You can't just take freedom of speech from the people you don't like to listen to; you would be taking it away from everyone.
- zajd 9y ago> You can't just take freedom of speech from the people you don't like to listen to; you would be taking it away from everyone. Good
- bbctol 9y agoSure, but you don't have to design your platform to incentivize making people angrier.
- coldacid 9y agoI really wish more people would recognize this. Freedom of speech only exists if it protects speech that people disagree with.
- rdtsc 9y agoWhen wasn't Twitter toxic? It is designed and implemented to breed toxicity. It is optimized for engagement, but people don't just engage when they are happy and want to share the joy they also engage when they are angry, upset, want to argue and debate. So they end up arguing in 140 character short quips and sarcastic remarks. Which gets other people angry and they respond with more short sarcastic remarks. How often has anyone said in such an exchange "Oh your witty remark and calling me an fucking idiot gave me pause, I went back, reevaluated my position and now I agree with you". But engagement goes up, and why bother removing bots, they just add more activity and users. "Oh look we have 330M active monthly users" they can say to the shareholders. Buy more shares! There is no mention how they went to RT, a Russian state propaganda outlet and offered them deals and access to US voters ahead of the 2016 election. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/26/twitter-bans-ads-from-russia-today-and-sputnik-over-election-interference https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/26/twitter-b... . Forgot what Twitter's response was, something like "we do not comment on private pitch decks". Which pretty much acknowledges it. So they breed and encourage toxicity then turn around and blast PR how they want more civility and are protecting democracy.
- mc32 9y agoOne problem is for people to be noticed they have to offer something compelling, maybe novel, but most of all something which will cause nods or outrage, Since most people have nothing significant to say (notable discovery) they signal which ever way they can. So they dig up nonsense molehills and let their friends build it into a mountain. Oh, look, this restaurant is sourcing from this place that my friend just told me secretly underpays their workers-- most foul. Don't patronize the restaurant, boycott! (No, I didn't confirm, I don't know if it's true, but boycott , for justice NAU!!! (Oh I feel a righteous human now))