10 ms·
The unsolved mystery of who owns 221b Baker Street
- gumby 9y agoIt seems pretty clear that the massive gains in high end real estate in Manhattan and central London have been driven by offshore money, some (perhaps most?) of which is money laundering (buy something liquid for X -- even if you overpay and end up selling at a "loss", what you get out has been laundered). But this is all at the very high end -- you see in manhattan that houses people actually live in sell at half the $/f2 that unused "investment" properties do. So are they really driving up prices and pushing people out? I don't know. In Palo Alto, Chinese money is flooding in and pushing up prices, but the houses are actually inhabited, so yes, it's driving up prices but it would be harder to complain that something nefarious is going on (and indeed I haven't seen any such complaints).
- djrogers 9y ago> money laundering (buy something liquid for X -- even if you overpay and end up selling at a "loss", what you get out has been laundered). You're missing a step in the money laundering here - you can't use completely unlaundered cash to anonymously buy investment property, you have to launder somehow first.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- currymj 9y agoyou’d be surprised. in the past at least there’s been far less oversight of real estate transactions than other types.
- pjc50 9y agoUsually this involves a set of corporate shells with opaque ownership; there may not even be a registered transfer of the property, just in shares of Mystery Holdings Corp #237 (British Virgin Islands).
- lossolo 9y agoBut this has nothing to do with money laundering. If money gets into international banking system it's probably laundered already. Money laundering dosen't work like you think it is - "shady offshore companies" is not enough to launder money because every one of this jurisdictions will work with law enforcement in case of money laundering. Then just follow the money and you will get busted. Shell companies will just make whole process longer for law enforcement agencies. Real estates in rich jurisdictions are used for stashing/anonymously investing money, not laundering money.
- jonknee 9y agoOr just find a shady real estate developer. Maybe one who has a famous name and had a reality TV show. A real greedy and corrupt type who doesn't ask a lot of questions or do much (or any) due diligence.
- munk-a 9y agoI don't think it's money laundering as much as money stashing. A lot of this money is flowing in from areas where the banks are unreliable, personally owning real estate is not certain (there are a preponderance of eminent domain seizures) and your control of your in-country assets is subject to the government's opinion of you. I don't think this is laundering as much as finding a mattress to hide it under that pays back a bit on your investment. So that if you lose everything you can liquidate your hidden little pockets of real estate and maybe make a bit of cash while fleeing to where ever.
- charlesdm 9y agoPretty much this. It's also the reason why I believe cryptocurrencies will continue to do well in the coming years -- there's a need for a state independent store of wealth.
- dazc 9y agoThe advantage of property being it will always be worth something.
- roywiggins 9y ago> it will always be worth something Assuming a sufficiently friendly state apparatus that enforces the ordinary claims of ownership. If that goes away, or is turned against you, it's not yours anymore. With stuff like real estate, you can't exactly smuggle it out of the country. (This is what the Global Magnitsky Act and international equivalents are meant to do- having your personal assets frozen by the US or UK government suddenly makes your frozen assets somewhat less valuable to you...)
- charlesdm 9y agoSure, if it doesn't end up being confiscated.
- jonknee 9y agoIt's much easier for a state to seize your cryptocurrency key than foreign real estate. There's a whole system of law protecting your NYC penthouse, but a couple of goons and a hammer can take all your BTC (without any way to reverse it!).
- ishi 9y agoHere's an very clear article talking about this problem in general as well as specifically in Israel, where housing prices have more than doubled in the past decade: https://www.timesofisrael.com/do-israels-ghost-apartments-explain-why-the-home-you-want-is-out-of-reach/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/do-israels-ghost-apartments-ex...
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoBut this is all at the very high end -- you see in manhattan that houses people actually live in sell at half the $/f2 that unused "investment" properties do. I suspect that the discrepancy in the $/sqft ranges is more about the property quality and scarcity at that range; you pay a premium for an 8,000 sq. foot duplex with a terrace that overlooks central park and has world-class finishes and amenities because there are far fewer of them than ultra-wealthy people who want them.
- elipsey 9y agoIt seems kind of strange to me that govt actors complain about money laundering while using their monopoly of force to protect the property rights of people (at least human people, not corporate “people”) who won’t even admit ownership. It seems like if representatives were earnest about addressing this sort of money laundering they might propose some way to stop doing that for owners of massive property holdings who won’t show themselves. In my home state, the real names and contact info for owners of small houses and residential lots are available from the tax assessors database online. That we have reporting requirements for $10,000 in cash deposits, but apparently not for office buildings and yachts seems to suggest that the wealthy are practically subject to a different system of law then the rest of us. Has it been proposed that owners of this sort of property publicly report real ownership? There are cases where we have managed to create all sorts of de-anonomizing reporting requirements for the non-billionaires (e.g. for cash deposits). There are limitations on property rights for absentee owners (even non-anonymous ones) as with squatter’s rights. Is it so illiberal to decline to enforce property rights for anonymous shell corporations that countries that don’t do it will be ostracized? Is it so hard to require that the real name of owners be published on a title, or just politically impossible?
- lopmotr 9y agoYou mean seizure of land? That's quite a risky thing to do. Plenty of now 3rd world countries destroyed themselves doing that. If people can't trust the government to enforce property rights, then how can they invest in property safely? That could then limit investing in business that owns property. Maybe it would be safe for the economy if it's done according to a law which is not retroactively applied to existing owners. Something like requiring new owners to be personally identified before they can even be granted ownership. Then there's no seizing required.
- pjc50 9y agoMore like "bona vacantia". Or, if the UK had a meaningful property tax, a requirement to file said tax non-anonymously. (The UK could also do with cadastral mapping to solve a different set of problems; available only in Scotland)
- auntienomen 9y agoMrs Hudson. Duh.
- baybal2 9y ago>Now, court documents seen by Quartz and files leaked in the Panama Papers suggest the properties have belonged at least in part to one or more family members of Kazakhstan’s president, Nursultan Nazarbayev. And to be precisely, his niece. When the guy was studying in Geneva, he was bragging about that left and right. My highschool classmate Olga Fedotova studied with him. I see it a big surprise that something known even to schoolchildren out there, is such a "revelation" to the British public and law enforcement. The hearsay was around for at least 8 or 7 years. More likely, they simply have no willpower for that
- shitgoose 9y agowatch out for the door handles - wipe them clean before entering. the great and fearsome Putin is sending you some Novitchok now! and, what the hell, Olga Fedotova too!
- baybal2 9y agoWell, this is a thing about which local newspapers write, whom present Nurali as "an esteemed 20-years-old property magnate super duper smart wunder kinder", heck, even his own Instagram him posing in front and in that building. There is no use for me in anonymity here. Dozens of people here and in YC known me in person. Even if I were to say that under a different acc, who I am would be instantly clear. You see, their believe in Western politicians and bureaucrats being their playthings is so strong, that they don't even mind bragging of their London estates in the public. Heck, one of the biggest London and NYC property owner Avramovich literally said on live TV "yes, I killed that guy, what will you do?", and his London mansion still stand inviolable to UK law enforcement; UK police have not lifted a finger to do anything about him even after that.
- baybal2 9y agoI'll tell you a bit of to what extend does the determination of current Western political establishment is in fighting mafia: May, and. co, and many of her predecessors gloss over terminology of rule of law, and that they can't do anything with mafia mansions unless the guilt of an owner is legally proved - this is a lie. In both UK, and the US the executive branch has a carte blanch laws to do anything with whose ever property these days, as well as to warrantlessly wiretap them, and put them in indefinite detention. For example, a no fly list, an OFAC SDN non-person list, EU red list. An executive branch has an unlimited power to put anybody on such list. Being put on that list effectively gives a designated person an effect of Orwell's non-personhood. A right way to deal with those mafiosos, yet have you ever seen anybody, anymuch major being put there?
- TallGuyShort 9y ago>> a new law ... allowing authorities to require a person to explain their stake in a property and how they came to own it It seems to me that anybody who has the resources to have a network of off-shore shell corporations laundering money for them while owning 24% or less of all of them would have no problem providing a plausible explanation for how they came to own a particular piece of property.
- spodek 9y agoIf they eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoSolution seems elementary. Require all property owners (the corporate head if not private) to register properties by direct application (in a set time). If said property remains unregistered, it may -immediately- be auctioned, forfeit.
- adamcharnock 9y agoI believe Portugal is about to do something similar, albeit for different reasons. In their case the rural population has been urbanising. Those that remain are old and are inevitably dying. Combine this with unhelpful inheritance laws, and the result is a lot of abandoned land. This land becomes unmaintained and is a big fire risk (as per the forest fires last summer) I understand that Portugal is going to require the registration of ownership of all rural land, and any land that is not registered will be reclaimed by (presumably) the state.
- kazinator 9y agoIt's elementary: just eliminate the improbables, and whosoever remains must be the owner/landlord.
- bartkappenburg 9y agoTo prevent these kind of 'situations', the Netherlands have a (soon to be implemented so it seems) law that states that it should be clear who is the "Ultimate Beneficial Owner" (UBO) [0]. The UBO is registered and viewable for everyone. No more hiding through obfuscation :-) [0] https://www.nautadutilh.com/en/our-expertise/special-topics2/UBO/ https://www.nautadutilh.com/en/our-expertise/special-topics2...
- chrischen 9y agoSeems like the solution if too many unwanted foreign parties are holding your assets is to depreciate your assets. For whatever reasons houses are considered appreciating assets, even super old ones.
- kspaans 9y agoIt's the land underneath that appreciates, not the structure of the house on top of the land.
- chrischen 9y agoRight, so there needs to be incentive structure to force property owners to make the most of the land. If the house is old and crappy, then taxes should force them replace the building with something more useful/more dense in order to offset taxes.
- kspaans 9y agoOne way to do this is to modify property tax into a Land Value Tax that's only accessed against land values, rather than land + buildings. This means property owners aren't "punished" for improving their buildings or building larger ones. But this can also be achieved in current property tax regimes by upzoning to allow more density. This will raise the value of the land (because it's now possible to build more density on it), which once reassessed, will also raise the property taxes.
- microtherion 9y agoAn unsolved mystery? Someone should get Sherlock Holmes on the case!