8 ms·
Where I started might not be useful to you
- FearNotDaniel 9y agoHonest question: can anyone explain who this writer is, and why her posts keep hitting the front page so frequently these days? There's no bio on the site so I'm guessing there's some kind of Valley insider knowledge going on as to why her opinions are considered significant. Sorry if that's a dumb question, I just don't see the appeal of these musings and I'm wondering if I'm missing out on some crucial context, other than the fact that she's old enough to remember the 8-bit days.
- sudhirj 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13401293 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13401293
- Rainymood 9y agoI was ~literally~ about to create a post (when there were no comments) describing exactly this. But when I refreshed I saw your comment. I am wondering the same.
- compiler-guy 9y agoShe was an engineer at Google, then a freelancer for a bit, then an engineer at facebook. Her debugging skills are otherworldly, and she is a decent writer, which helps her make Hacker News a lot. She also has dealt with a lot of the social issues inside Silicon Valley, and has some pretty good insights there as well. Perhaps 1/3 of her stories are cool "How the hell did she figure that out?" debugging stories. 1/3 are social commentary, and the remaining third are about odd bits of technology, like this post.
- justherefortart 9y agoSo good content gets upvoted. I read them and upvote the ones I find interesting.
- BrissyCoder 9y agoCame here to ask the same thing. Thanks to to others in thread for providing some context. Personally I haven't found any of the posts from this site to be interesting/entertaining... but please link the ones people think are.
- icebraining 9y agoThe HN search is the easiest way to find the most popular submissions of a certain site: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=rachelbythebay.com&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=rachelbythebay.com&sort=byPopu...
- JacobAldridge 9y agoOr you can click on the domain url from the frontpage (easier, though it doesn't sort by popularity so is less helpful in that regard for larger sites) - https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=rachelbythebay.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=rachelbythebay.com
- kragen 9y agoIt's okay for you not to be interested in the kinds of things she writes about. Different hackers are interested in different things. But it turns out that a lot of hackers are interested in the things Rachel writes about, and we enjoy her plainspoken way of writing about them — confident without ever approaching being arrogant or condescending to the reader. (Sometimes they are pretty harsh on her previous coworkers.)
- mercer 9y agoI think part of this is the 'frontpage echo effect'. Quite regularly there'll be a few days/weeks of articles about either a particular topic (that is not time-sensitive), a particular theme, or from a particular source. Sometimes it's submissions of interesting links from the discussion of a previous article (I've done that more than once), sometimes it's from people who decide to read past entries from the same source (or add said source to their reading habits). And I'm sure there's other reasons why this happens.
- ryandrake 9y agoThat’s part of the charm of HN: scrolling through the top articles you’ll see brand new experimental software tool, a NYTimes piece about some world changing technology, then some rando engineer’s personal blog—right next to each other. Much more variety than the “top” search results elsewhere.
- caseymarquis 9y agoI like her posts and read/upvote them whenever I see them. It always seemed natural that they'd be on the front page of HN. It's the sort of content I'm here for.
- JoeAcchino 9y agoSame for me. I like her writing stile and the content.
- chris_wot 9y agoShe is a very insightful and technical writer. She's also seen a lot of current big business, and so she is the insider's outsider really. I thoroughly enjoy her writing and every time it is posted to HN I read it.
- FeepingCreature 9y agoI think that maybe webdev, maligned as it is, fills that role. You can make something useful quickly. "Boot times" (page reload) are short. State can be saved but is ephemeral by default.
- RobertRoberts 9y agoI agree, webdev is the modern equivalent of a fresh new playground. I started with computers in 3rd grade, logo. It was enthralling. I was enamoured with computers right away. I learned you could stop some Apple games and view the code. I learned you could even print it, (I had reams of printed code I didn't know what 99% of it did, what is a gosub? lol) most of this learning was by accident, as I didn't have a single book to teach me anything, and only 1 other real nerd friend who showed me how to program lowres graphics. (One friend got bootleg copies of games from his older brother though, lol. Anyone remember punching holes on the side of a floppy disk to make it store more data?) I tried over and over to create games, and made dozens of odd text adventures and stupid space invaders games that crashed after a couple minutes of play. In highschool I found (by watching the older kids) about hacking system resources on Macs, and we'd mess with the menus, lol. Pascal was interesting, but I never learned to make anything cool with it. Finally when I got into college, I got some real coding experience, and found out you can mix art (I was a flip-book animating nut as a kid, made hundreds of them) with programming. Eventually the web took over, and I found out you didn't have to "install" anything on someone else's machine ever again, I was hooked. As bad as the web is in so many ways, I never want to go back to supporting other peoples computers ever, ever, ever again. I will take JS hell over that garbage. (Imagine helping a client debug an install issue on a computer over the phone, and he's 2,000 miles away on a Carribean island living it up and blaming your for him clicking the wrong button because he simply refuses to follow your instructions "explicitly" and can't ever be wrong... ugh)
- icebraining 9y agoImagine helping a client debug an install issue on a computer over the phone (...) Instead, that client is using IE6, doesn't know how to tell you that, and IT restrictions prevent them from upgrading or using another browser. Or they have Chrome and a shitty addon that breaks your site in a way that you can't even imagine. Or they are behind a workplace firewall that blocks some specific domain used by the site. I've done support for a webapp, and I've had to use remote desktop sharing quite a few times.
- tonyarkles 9y agoI frequently run into the same problem. I work with clients, and inevitably one of their employees asks something like "how did you get to be so good at Linux? You figured out a problem we've been chasing for weeks!" And I hate my answer, especially when the employee is around my age or older: I first installed Slackware from floppy disks when I was about 12 years old. I installed it because I heard that Linux had a great C compiler, and I was getting tired of the Power-C compiler that I'd been using for 2 years. Like Rachel, I started on a Vic-20, around age 8. The computer was at my dad's house though, and I lived with my mom most of the week, so I would take out books from the library, write all of my code on loose leaf, and then fast & furiously type it in when I got over to dad's house to see if it worked. POKE 36879 indeed.
- taneq 9y agoI sometimes wonder if growing up before the internet and Wikipedia and Stack Overflow was actually a boon for my problem solving skills. I spent so many hours with nothing to go on but some books and my own persistent trial-and-error. If I'd done the same stuff these days I don't think I'd have learned half as much (although would I have done more, different things? Probably...)
- qznc 9y agoI believe the most important trait for debugging is stubbornness. When Stack Overflow and Google do not help, you start doing it yourself. You use tools like a debugger. If the tools do not help, you can look for other tools. If you cannot find them, you can develop your own. You can look at your code, the code of your operating system, and every library you use. You can trace and observe every instruction a CPU performs.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoYeah, but it's also really bad for sleeping patterns. Countless times I've started to address a bug in the evening only to find it spirals down into some obscure feature I didn't even know existed. After hours of thinking and learning more about the language/tools/computer than you thought there was you feel great, but it's 3am. In my experience there are only two ways to really learn about programming: teaching and debugging.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoNice, my dad was quite prescient as well and bought me and my sister Vic-20s with little black and white matching TVs. I have great memories of hacking the random sentence generator in BASIC and loading/saving programs to cassette tape over many minutes. A teacher so far ahead of his time at school had a TRS-80 that we would have lessons on. It would be at least 5 years later that I would touch another computer, a PC XT running DOS.
- taneq 9y ago> I suppose you could come up with some simple machine which plugged into your TV and let you experiment with a handful of primitives to get a feel for starting out. A modern equivalent might be the Micro Bit (http://microbit.org/ http://microbit.org/) - it doesn't plug into a TV but it does have a rudimentary display built in, it's programmable and it has various sensors and I/O on it. Also the entire Arduino ecosystem fills a similar niche, of a bare-metal-ish platform which lets you jump right in and start coding things.
- Angostura 9y agoThey really don’t fit the same niche as the little machines that you could plug into your tv and either load up some simple arcade games or produce your own using Basic.
- taneq 9y agoThat's not really a niche, though, any more. It's almost cheaper to just put an LCD on something than to interface with modern TVs. If you want something more in that spirit regardless of hardware, maybe PICO-8? It's basically a (virtual) minimalist 8-bit computer / gaming console for the modern era. https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php
- jgrahamc 9y agoReminds me of something I wrote a while back: http://blog.jgc.org/2009/08/just-give-me-simple-cpu-and-few-io.html http://blog.jgc.org/2009/08/just-give-me-simple-cpu-and-few-... Those of us who started programming in that era had simple, relatively cheap, fully comprehendable computers in front of us.
- telesilla 9y agoInstalling mklinux in the late 90s on an old 6100 by transferring disks copied over the internet that took a few days each, while everyone was sleeping, and sometimes the disks failed, then getting the damn thing installed.. but then it worked! Gave me a reward for my perseverance, and I've been getting that reward since as I continue to stubbornly chase bugs and fix genuinely interesting problems. I learned by trial and error, before you could just google a problem and have it pop up in StackOverflow. It taught me one major lesson: debugging is how you learn about everything in the environment. A bug is an opportunity to explore the programming environment, framework etc and you'll get a grasp of the platform through searching for solutions. StackOverflow is nice for quick fixes but it doesn't give you the deep knowledge that debugging does. I recommend to my team, if they find a bug spend half a day figuring stuff out from the ground up (where we have that time luxury) and it makes everyone more knowledgable in the long term.
- smoyer 9y agoI've actually been pondering this problem for a couple of years - when everything is based on FLASH, what do you do when something corrupts your "base install"? The VIC-20, C64, Timex-Sinclair and other computers of their day had the OS in ROM that couldn't be changed. So you couldn't break these computers via the keyboard (or other peripherals) but if there was a bug somewhere in the firmware (which included the OS and BASIC) you had to live with it for the life of the device. You can get back to those days via emulation - https://vic-20.appspot.com/emus.htm https://vic-20.appspot.com/emus.htm, but there's nothing (that I know of) that's a physical device with these characteristics.
- sratner 9y agoYou can protect pages on most flash devices (e.g. internal microcontroller storage). Lock the bootloader and factory reset image, so you can still update the running firmware, but also have a way to recover from any scenario with a hardware button or sufficiently clever watchdog.
- seanwilson 9y agoThis is why I hate the quote "It is practically impossible to teach good programming to students that have had a prior exposure to BASIC: as potential programmers they are mentally mutilated beyond hope of regeneration." and "The teaching of BASIC should be rated as a criminal offence: it mutilates the mind beyond recovery." I started coding by reading the huge instruction manual that came with the Amstrad CPC and didn't have an issue moving on to other languages later. As long as you're willing to keep up with what's new and are passionate about improving your skills it doesn't matter what you started with.
- rimliu 9y agoI wonder: technically Basic (MSX Basic to be precise) was the language I wrote my first working program in, but I've learnt to program on paper. I am serious: we had no computers in school, but we had a programming course and a teacher who took that seriously. So I've learnt about variables, loops, control flow etc. by writing pseudocode on paper. When I got access to the computer all I needed was a syntax. So is my brain mutilated or not? :|
- smarks 9y agoThat sounds like Dijkstra, from EWD498 (1975): http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD04xx/EWD498.html http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD04xx/EW... At least, the "mentally mutilated" phrase is about BASIC. The "criminal offence" phrase was actually about COBOL. You'll note that Dijkstra also had choice words about FORTRAN, APL, and PL/I, which were popular programming languages of the day. It's tempting to say that Dijkstra was being tongue-in-cheek when he wrote this. I never met him, but based the attitude I picked up from his other writings, I'd guess that if you had asked him he'd have said he was completely serious. And he has a point. I first learned programming in BASIC, and look how I turned out. (Well maybe I confirm Dijkstra's point. Others will have to judge.) But I do recall a bunch of characteristics of early BASIC systems that potentially led to terrible programming habits: GOTO and line numbers leading to spaghetti code; all global variables; no scope; no functions; self-modifying code (overlays); etc. All of these had to be unlearned at some point.
- 9y ago
- mrlyc 9y agoI started with a Vic-20. I wrote a BBS for it with multiple rooms (message areas), private mail and an online game. Users could start their own rooms and make them public or private. It was very popular with each user spending an average of 70 minutes on it. That's how I got into programming professionally. One of my users said "Anyone who can write a BBS for a Vic can program!" and hired me as a programmer. Thirty-two years later, that same guy now wants me to work with him at Google.
- cbm-vic-20 9y agoThis one speaks the truth.
- yownie 9y agoHey rachel, the bbc microbit definitely fits the parameters you listed at the end of this post. Only $12, so definitely worth picking one up to fool with. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_Bit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_Bit
- Narishma 9y agoYou can't do anything with that without first connecting it to a bigger computer.
- jannotti 9y agoJavascript and reloading a web page are the obvious parallel. There are one liners for changing colors, fonts, etc. A tiny bit of canvas setup and you can draw freely. I think sound is slightly more complicated, but not much. It might make sense to make a little js library (maybe call it basic.js, though I'm not actually recommending copying the BASIC language) and then write some blog post that start with loading it, and then fooling around in the JS console.
- neogodless 9y agoIn a way, this is a big part of how I transitioned from someone who knew how to program a Commodore 64 to someone that could help people build web pages (and eventually be able to do other things good, too.) I had a Geocities web site, and I loaded it down with JavaScript widgets that I wrote. Things to flip images around. Things to annoy you with alerts. Then I spent countless hours in MS Paint making images out of bitmaps which I then wired up using JavaScript to emulate an Iron-man watch (complete with glowing and a very bad battery!) There was "no risk." It was fun and exploratory. It didn't achieve anything useful for anyone else, but I learned and got confident in learning (and experimenting.) When someone actually hired me and threw ColdFusion at me, it was wildly different... from QBasic and from JavaScript... but I just experimented and figured out how to do CRUDDY things.
- mannykannot 9y agoThe author asks whether her principles are relevant today, and I think they are, at least for someone like me. Firstly, starting by poking around a small issue that interests me generates motivation: as soon as I have made some progress, I find lots of things that I want to look into more deeply. Secondly, it gives me confidence that I can master the topic, an antidote to the sinking feeling I get from looking at a multi-page table of contents.
- forrestbaer 9y agoDoes anyone make a c64-ish SOC with SID style sound limitations, HDMI out, 1/8" audio out, 8-16 GPIO pins, good documentation and development environment (C/ASM)? I wish a simple (restrictive) mid-range system like this existed to develop on as a hobbyist. The Pi is too much, arduino doesn't have the "fun" (interesting sound chip, built in outputs, marketing/documentation).. Does anything like this exist?
- kalleboo 9y agoI think it's because everyone who wants something like that just buys a C64 (or NES, or whatever)
- forrestbaer 9y agoYes that makes sense, I wish there was a market for these kinds of systems at the arduino form factor / cost point with more of a hobbyist bent.
- proppy 9y agohttps://ichigojam.net/index-en.html https://ichigojam.net/index-en.html ?
- forrestbaer 9y agoInteresting!
- golem14 9y agoI can highly recommend MIST: https://lotharek.pl/productdetail.php?id=97 https://lotharek.pl/productdetail.php?id=97 Works like a charm and can run C64, VIC, Atari ST, various older computers like PET or TI99/4a or zx81/spectrum.
- noonespecial 9y agoArduino is the spiritual successor she's looking for to the C64 era experience. It worked fantastically for my kids and brought back waves of nostalgia watching them grok the basics like I did.
- parsoj 9y agoWhy aren't cloud, or even local, VM's being brought up? You irrevocably blow up your linux VM... just spin up a new one - or revert to your snapshot from earlier in the day. I'd actually make the argument that virtualization would make it easier than ever to safely experiment with things. Complexity has definitely gone up, and the time and ability to peacefully munch on problems under a tree has definitely gone down. But, I would argue that if a learner given the right sort of virtual sandbox, instructions on how to reset their state to working order, and an internet connection with google, the linux docs, and stack overflow bookmarked, there is a lot of learning to be had!
- itomato 9y agoIt's a Chicken and Egg Problem. Bootstrapping an 8-bit Microcomputer is so much simpler than the first order of operations in the hosted VM model.
- gfo 9y agoI agree with most of the sentiments, except for one key statement: > "Just about any computer you can buy today is going to have some kind of non-trivial boot time. It probably will require a whole ecosystem of crazy things to make it work. It will be fragile. You can break it easily." I vehemently disagree with the italicized portion, at least in the way it's presented. Those on here probably aren't affected, but many of the non-technical users I know are afraid of learning how to go beyond simple tasks on their computer (word processing, internet browsing, etc.) because they're afraid they'll break their expensive box and have to pay someone to fix it. Most UIs today seem to help users avoid breaking things and typically have some sort of notification if they'll change something that would break their machine (e.g. UAC in Windows, padlock in OS X). Even beyond this, general application development wouldn't pose these risks. Hardware hacking certainly could, but any time you're dealing with the physical workings of something that's an assumed risk.
- diggan 9y agoI think "break it easily" does not refer to actually breaking the hardware but ending up in a situation where you cannot come back to where you were before. My mother frequently called for my help when she made an application fullscreen and could not go away from it, and she considered the computer broken at that point. There is also numerous ways you can make computers unbootable by removing files, installing the wrong thing that runs on boot and so on. I maybe wouldn't say it's fragile and can break easily, but it can, and if you just go around clicking on things, it's probably gonna break after a while.
- gfo 9y agoThat's a great take, didn't think of that. Thanks for your response.