9 ms·
Any ideas? Banning handguns and jilted lovers or angry people is a whole different ballgame than banning automatic weapons or the sort.
by oh_sigh 9y ago
Any ideas? Banning handguns and jilted lovers or angry people is a whole different ballgame than banning automatic weapons or the sort.
- DanBC 9y agoAny person who has a conviction for domestic assualt isn't allowed to own any type of gun Any person with TBI isn't allowed to own any type of gun Any person with drug or alcohol addiction isn't allowed to own any type of gun Those three things would cut down the numbers of these types of murders, which tend to be impulsive.
- Cuuugi 9y agoI don't have a issue with the logic of your statements, however the implementation of them could be rather scary. Who is to say what a alcohol addiction entails? etc. etc.
- oh_sigh 9y agoWhat percentage of gun murders are committed by people with TBI, domestic assault, or state-known drug or alcohol problems?
- kevincrane 9y agoMass shooters have a super high correlation with domestic abuse.
- DanBC 9y agoEach of these things is a much better predictor of violent behaviour than mental illness, which is the thing normally blamed.
- Cuuugi 9y agoNot to mention automatic weapons are essentially already banned. There's no rational debate to be had, since they only really seem to happen with bodies fresh in our minds. I don't have the right answer, or claim to, but i do know that making these types of decisions in a crisis, rarely works out.
- celticninja 9y agoThe decisions are not made in a crisis. The crisis is the impetus needed to get people to change their mind, its not like this will result in a law change. It may result in a new proposed law, which will be debated and voted on in due course. It wont be a knee jerk reaction but hopefully someday soon enough people will see one of these events as the start of the end of future mass slayings.
- Cuuugi 9y agoI disagree. The media spotlight around the Stoneman Douglas high school students should be all you need to know. The fact that they have been elevated to a place they don't really belong (in the national spotlight) is to simply push a narrative. This is child abuse, and wrong. They want to push legislation to restrict the right to own firearms, when it really hasn't been considered that guns themselves might not be the problem. What makes a "mass shooter"? The gun just makes them a shooter. To fire indiscriminately clearly shows mental issues.
- BenSahar 9y agoI think it's funny that people are so upset about some high school students voicing their opinions after experiencing a school shooting. I do agree with the idea that the US needs to fix its mental (and general) healthcare system. It's odd that the majority of the time that argument is used by the same group that wants and has tried to gut any attempts at improving the system.
- musage 9y ago> some high school students voicing their opinions They said "media spotlight", not "the fact that some students voiced their opinion". > It's odd that the majority of the time that argument is used by the same group that wants and has tried to gut any attempts at improving the system. It's odd in the same way the above is funny, namely in that you're just saying it.
- celticninja 9y agoBanning firearms in general worked for the UK and Australia, 2 places that have experienced this type of massacre while having a significant number of legally held firearms. Since the firearm bans there has been a huge reduction in these types of incidents. It is entirely possible to do the same in the USA, however it may take longer to remove all weapons simply because you have been so slow to respond to this problem. Basically when things like this happen and people think that the government are going to take their guns, a certain type of person will buy more guns, just in case. If there is a gun amnesty or ban then these people will not turn in their guns, it will be these guns that are then sold illegally or stolen and will perpetuate the problem for longer.
- thatswrong0 9y agoBanning firearms in general won't work in America. There are already more guns than people in circulation, the right to own them is codified into the Constitution and requires an amendment to fix (and amendments are ridiculously hard to pass), and of course there's the huge section of the population that would probably rather die than let their right to own guns be infringed. Not to mention that we do have a giant border with Mexico to our south that would probably make any attempt to remove all guns from America pointless.
- jazoom 9y ago>Banning firearms in general won't work in America. Obligatory "not with that attitude".
- celticninja 9y ago>Banning firearms in general won't work in America. This is the go to reason that people give, but it just means they haven't tried. No one said it would be cheap or easy but it could be done. As for gun smuggling, the USA used to be the source of 80% of guns used in crimes in Canada and in Mexico it is 70%. https://www.quora.com/How-are-guns-smuggled-into-the-United-States https://www.quora.com/How-are-guns-smuggled-into-the-United-... https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/01/12/462781469/in-mexico-tens-of-thousands-of-illegal-guns-come-from-the-u-s https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/01/12/462781469... https://www.vox.com/2016/1/14/10771628/gun-violence-america-mexico https://www.vox.com/2016/1/14/10771628/gun-violence-america-... So actually a gun ban in the USA would help both Canada and Mexico with their gun problems. In Mexico many of these guns end up in the hands of the cartels who are much more willing to use them than your usual criminals, and whilst they would still probably be able to obtain weapons they would not be able to do so in the same sort of volume and they would also have trouble locating ammunition.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]