4 ms·
How are the other makers "years behind" Tesla? The Model S is the best-selling EV but not by an order of magnitude. GM was pretty close last year in sales and I
by danso 9y ago
How are the other makers "years behind" Tesla? The Model S is the best-selling EV but not by an order of magnitude. GM was pretty close last year in sales and I don't think it's a bad bet to bet that GM will beat Tesla in getting self-driving tech (GM Cruise is only second to Waymo in testing self-driving, at least in California).
https://www.fool.com/investing/2017/12/30/the-5-best-selling-electric-cars-of-2017.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/2017/12/30/the-5-best-selling...
https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/31/16956902/california-dmv-self-driving-car-disengagement-2017 https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/31/16956902/california-dmv-s...
Tesla deserves credit for getting other automakers to take the EV market seriously, but they are by no means years behind Tesla in terms of production and sales.
- adventured 9y agoUsing one example to represent the industry is the issue in your premise. This list nicely proves my point: How many EVs is Volkswagen selling per year? How many EVs is Subaru selling per year? How many EVs is Fiat selling per year? How many EVs is Ferrari selling per year? How many EVs is Daimler selling per year? How many EVs is Ford selling per year? How many EVs is PSA selling per year? How many EVs is Hyundai Kia selling per year? How many EVs is Mazda selling per year? How many EVs is Suzuki selling per year? Tesla is in fact still embarrassing the auto industry and selling EVs by an order of magnitude beyond what nearly all of the major auto companies are. The above listed companies are selling millions of fossil-fuel vehicles and should be heckled aggressively for it. The fact that so few major automakers are selling EVs at all, demonstrates that what I've said is correct. But hey, all these fossil-fuel makers have great plans for the future. One day soon. The question is: how come those companies aren't being bankrupted for the horrific products they're producing by the millions? Where's the FUD attack on those corporations (which would actually be useful in dramatically improving the world)? Priorities are entirely screwed up when its the EV maker getting smacked around for not selling enough EVs.
- Fins 9y agoAnd how many EVs would Tesla be selling without heavy subsidies and a Musk effect? Besides, selling a car of Tesla's quality would be embarassing to every company on your list. Well, maybe not Suzuki, but probably to them, too.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoAll automakers receive EV subsidies. Why are non-Tesla automakers so bad at building EVs if they receive the same subsidy Tesla does?
- Fins 9y agoTesla's are the largest, though, since they have largest batteries. Tesla builds EVs, that's the only thing they sort of can do (of course they can't actually build them at profit, but that's a problem for Tesla's shareholders). Others will build EVs when they can be profitably sold, because it isn't their only business.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Others will build EVs when they can be profitably sold, because it isn't their only business. Tesla's margins are the highest in the industry for their vehicles. Legacy automakers don't want to innovate and cannablize their own business, which is why they cannot succeed. If you want to sell like Tesla does, and get the level of subsidies they do, sell vehicles that people want and will pay for. There's a reason people would rather wait years for a Model 3 then buy a Bolt, i3, or other half-attempt at an EV by a legacy automaker.
- Fins 9y agoIf their margins are so high, why are they losing money hand over fist? People want to buy a Tesla for the same reason many want to buy an Apple or Bose product -- great marketing, not any kind of intrinsic value. And besides, "legacy" automakers (you know, those guys who actually were first to make an electric vehicle, hybrid, fuel cell, hydrogen etc., ones who have driver assistance systems that do not try to actively kill their users, etc. etc.)already have cars people want to buy. Unless you're talking about some edge cases (doesn't Norway tax regular cars so much that Tesla is actually a good value?) making EVs for them isn't currently a very profitable strategy. Not that it were profitable for Tesla either, of course. It would also be interesting to learn what is it that Tesla actually innovated, apart from marketing (and even there, Apple or Bose has been selling flash over substance for years and years before Tesla)? Batteries? No, they are completely off the shelf. Do they have some magical mystery motors? No... Some exotic body construction maybe? Nope, aluminum cars have been around for quite a while, too. Some incredible self-driving software? No, better not even go there. It will be interesting to see what happens in a couple of years when VWs electric factory comes online.
- nopriorarrests 9y ago>Tesla is in fact still embarrassing the auto industry and >selling EVs by an order of magnitude beyond what nearly >all of the major auto companies are. Um, no. "November was another good month for GM’s Chevy Bolt EV US sales. The electric vehicle hit a new record with almost 3,000 units sold in one month – bringing the total to over 20,000 units to date". [0] Of course total Tesla sales are higher than 20K units, but if we are talking about EV cars in mass segment, Tesla is being outsold at this moment. [0] https://electrek.co/2017/12/01/chevy-bolt-ev-us-sales-records/ https://electrek.co/2017/12/01/chevy-bolt-ev-us-sales-record...
- jacquesm 9y agoVW: 350 e-Golfs / week Nissan has delivered 300K leafs (why did you leave them out?). Chevvy sells about 20K volts / year. Lots more data here: https://insideevs.com/monthly-plug-in-sales-scorecard/ https://insideevs.com/monthly-plug-in-sales-scorecard/ The companies you list are selling millions of fossil-fuel vehicles because that's their business: selling cars. And as long as they can continue to do so profitably they will do so. And whether or not Ferrari makes fossil fuel cars or not is immaterial, the numbers aren't there. Fiat has an electric car but they are not turning a profit on it (it is priced very low, and they still can't sell them). So does Renault, they too make electric cars, and have been doing so for quite a while.
- maxerickson 9y agoMultiple automakers have good enough electric drivetrains to really shorten the time Tesla has to fix their production volume and fit & finish issues. If they don't execute this year their decade of brand building is not going to amount to a whole lot (maybe they have until midway through next year?). The other automakers aren't pairing the drivetrains with big expensive batteries, so they aren't selling them with big expensive batteries, but there's also only so much consumer demand for $45,000+ electric vehicles.
- Robotbeat 9y agoNah, I think the other EV manufacturers ARE years behind Tesla. They shouldn't be, either. The Leaf could be charging at >100kW with 250 mile range and selling like hot cakes, too, but they marketed it as a long range golf cart and were way too incremental and conservative with the battery (although they did seem to address their early problems that stemmed from not properly cooling the battery like Tesla & GM do). And they never built out their charging network like Tesla has. For self-driving, though, Waymo seems to have the edge right now for near-full-autonomy. Tesla's system is really much more like a really-fancy adaptive cruise control right now. But if Tesla gave them LIDARs (currently expensive, but may become cheap enough for Tesla to just add-on) and made them drive like grandmas (like Waymo) around well-mapped, dry locations, then they likely would be in the same ballpark. Which isn't to demean Waymo's impressive efforts at all.