3 ms·
Their critics are very loudly proclaiming Tesla is an immense failure, that the Model 3 is a failure, and that they're going bankrupt in a matter of months. The
by adventured 9y ago
Their critics are very loudly proclaiming Tesla is an immense failure, that the Model 3 is a failure, and that they're going bankrupt in a matter of months. The FUD being broadly directed at Tesla is astounding and reeks of bias of one sort or another.
The other major automakers are running years behind where Tesla is at today. That's where the embarrassment should be today: those automakers are still gleefully selling tens of millions of fossil-fuel-only vehicles.
Producing 20,000 Model 3 vehicles per quarter this year will be an accomplishment (even in spite of Musk's absurd prior goal). It implies they can push well over 100,000 units in 2019. These days they're being given little credit for what they are accomplishing. When they hit that 20,000 quarterly marker, the Model 3 becomes one of the best selling mid-priced luxury vehicles on the planet in its first year.
- elvirs 9y agothey are given a ton of credit. their stock value was a good proof of how much credit they were given but you can't keep being late and not delivering on promises to hundreds of thousands of customers who made deposits while the CEO is busy building flamethrowers amd hats to sell them on twitter
- danso 9y agoHow are the other makers "years behind" Tesla? The Model S is the best-selling EV but not by an order of magnitude. GM was pretty close last year in sales and I don't think it's a bad bet to bet that GM will beat Tesla in getting self-driving tech (GM Cruise is only second to Waymo in testing self-driving, at least in California). https://www.fool.com/investing/2017/12/30/the-5-best-selling-electric-cars-of-2017.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/2017/12/30/the-5-best-selling... https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/31/16956902/california-dmv-self-driving-car-disengagement-2017 https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/31/16956902/california-dmv-s... Tesla deserves credit for getting other automakers to take the EV market seriously, but they are by no means years behind Tesla in terms of production and sales.
- adventured 9y agoUsing one example to represent the industry is the issue in your premise. This list nicely proves my point: How many EVs is Volkswagen selling per year? How many EVs is Subaru selling per year? How many EVs is Fiat selling per year? How many EVs is Ferrari selling per year? How many EVs is Daimler selling per year? How many EVs is Ford selling per year? How many EVs is PSA selling per year? How many EVs is Hyundai Kia selling per year? How many EVs is Mazda selling per year? How many EVs is Suzuki selling per year? Tesla is in fact still embarrassing the auto industry and selling EVs by an order of magnitude beyond what nearly all of the major auto companies are. The above listed companies are selling millions of fossil-fuel vehicles and should be heckled aggressively for it. The fact that so few major automakers are selling EVs at all, demonstrates that what I've said is correct. But hey, all these fossil-fuel makers have great plans for the future. One day soon. The question is: how come those companies aren't being bankrupted for the horrific products they're producing by the millions? Where's the FUD attack on those corporations (which would actually be useful in dramatically improving the world)? Priorities are entirely screwed up when its the EV maker getting smacked around for not selling enough EVs.
- Fins 9y agoAnd how many EVs would Tesla be selling without heavy subsidies and a Musk effect? Besides, selling a car of Tesla's quality would be embarassing to every company on your list. Well, maybe not Suzuki, but probably to them, too.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoAll automakers receive EV subsidies. Why are non-Tesla automakers so bad at building EVs if they receive the same subsidy Tesla does?
- Fins 9y agoTesla's are the largest, though, since they have largest batteries. Tesla builds EVs, that's the only thing they sort of can do (of course they can't actually build them at profit, but that's a problem for Tesla's shareholders). Others will build EVs when they can be profitably sold, because it isn't their only business.
- Someone1234 9y ago> Their critics are very loudly proclaiming Tesla is an immense failure, that the Model 3 is a failure, and that they're going bankrupt in a matter of months. This is a classic straw man. You've created a fictional persona which you then describe as: > The FUD being broadly directed at Tesla is astounding and reeks of bias of one sort or another. How about we stick to what other posters you're replying to are actually saying rather than creating fictional personas in order to then attack them.
- adventured 9y agoI wasn't attacking the parent or implying that was their bias. I intentionally structured the response as a point about the extremely wide-spread criticism being directed at Tesla. This: "The FUD being broadly directed at Tesla" I inserted "broadly" for exactly that reason. I also intentionally avoided using "you" or similar (re-read what i actually wrote, you should instantly notice my reply is clearly not targeting the parent just based on what words I use), so as to hopefully avoid leading anyone to think I was claiming the parent was the source of that FUD.
- nopriorarrests 9y agoI don't know what you are talking about re:FUD. I'm neutral on Tesla both emotionally and financially and have no skin in this game, but I can say that TSLA bears have a very compelling case on their hands, with numbers, future projections, industry comparisons, etc. It's not often bear position is so well reasoned. In fact, TSLA bulls are much more often "selling the dream".
- MadcapJake 9y agoI would agree with the parent, as a laymen casually observing HN and the major news outlets this is really what it feels like, a complete shift in news/commentator opinions of Tesla.
- dahdum 9y agoI tend to think Tesla benefits far more from hype and Elon charisma than is being hurt by FUD. There are still many real risks to their success, from outright failure to middling future sales. It wouldn't be shocking to see them eventually exit sales and license their tech / batteries to major automakers down the road as the major revenue stream. All that said, their fanciful production plans can't hold much weight with institutional investors after so many misses, so it should be priced into the market.
- Fins 9y agoCalling Model 3 a luxury vehicle is rather a stretch. Even Model S lacks things Hyundai one third the price has. While no other company can come close to Tesla in selling half-baked (or altogether nonexistent) stuff to the gullible, packaging Panasonic batteries in an overpriced golf cart isn't something that any company that knows how to actually build cars would be particularly concerned about.
- dmode 9y agoLol, I have a Hyundai and a Model S. What you wrote makes zero sense
- Fins 9y agoSo... your model S has cooled seats? Tesla doesn't offer them now (and apparently they didn't work when they did). My wife's Sonata has them, and they work. Not even talking about stuff that is to be expected in a $70K+ car, Tesla doesn't quite compete with a $30K econobrand when it comes to creature comforts.
- dmode 9y agoLet's see. My Hyundai doesn't offer any kind of Autopilot features or advanced safety features. My Hyundai doesn't get monthly software updates that improves the car every month. My Hyundai doesn't have a world wide supercharger network to take long trips for free. My Hyundai doesn't have advanced voice features that are constantly improving. Doesn't have natively integrated streaming and podcasts app that can be controlled with voice. Doesn't have integrated Google search with voice command. Doesn't have an AI driven climate preconditioning. Doesn't have a simple UI to maintain separate driver profiles. Doesnt have an interface to customize a myriad of settings. This is just a start. I can keep going
- Fins 9y agoLet me guess... it is a 10 years old Elantra? Let's see... my wife's Hyundai does have adaptive cruise control that actually works and does not try to kill her, it has line assist that works as well, it does not get some buggy and unexpected changes in behavior that make it work worse than before. It can actually drive from San Jose to Vegas non-stop without sitting for a couple of hours in the exciting world of Kettleman City's Supercharger station. It integrates with whatever podcast/streaming app she has on the phone, got integrated Google search with voice control, has a perfectly working AC system (and what the hell is an AI driven climate control anyway? Does that come with little Elon's waving fans around your head or something?). Oh, did I mention that it does not try to kill her? And cools our butts when it is hot outside? And that the body panels actually fit? All of that in a cheap brand for $40K less than a Tesla. For the kind of money you paid, I expect massaging seats, rear seat recliners, maybe even safety better than that of an old Kia. Sorry. Not being very impressed here.