3 ms·
> This specific issue has nothing to do with Trump. I can certainly agree with that. In these sorts of discussions I work hard to ignore the 'people are compla
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
> This specific issue has nothing to do with Trump.
I can certainly agree with that. In these sorts of discussions I work hard to ignore the 'people are complaining about ...' sorts of inputs because people complain about everything, it is hard to develop understanding from that.
However it is useful to understand economic value is changing. For example, gasoline was a 'waste product' of refining oil for kerosene[1]. When the economic value of gasoline changed, it changed how the companies were viewed. Nuclear power was once the power of the future with high economic value, until it was perceived (or maligned depending on your point of view) into being a threat to civilization.
So where does economic value arise? It is the ratio of the cost of production over the price of a good. So raising tariffs allows the cost of production of a foreign good to rise, and assuming the buyers are all trying to get the same price, the economic value of aluminum production goes up in the local (tariff free) economy.
So the price of aluminum goes up, and now it can be made profitably in Spokane, so an aluminum plant (mill?) opens up and jobs are created and the town becomes more prosperous.
With tariffs it is possible to raise the effective cost of any good to the point where it can be made profitably locally. However it requires that the local economy be able to pick up production. That is generally not a problem for the US economy, not as easily done on places like Brazil for example which can have high tariffs and still not have a local iPhone factory.
The rust belt folks believe that the country will switch to manufacturing things locally and consumers will eat the cost increase (or not eat, pun intended). They may be correct, they may not. Seems like we get the experiment regardless of our point of view.
[1] http://knowledgenuts.com/2014/02/24/gasoline-used-to-be-considered-garbage/ http://knowledgenuts.com/2014/02/24/gasoline-used-to-be-cons...
- dragontamer 9y ago> The rust belt folks believe that the country will switch to manufacturing things locally and consumers will eat the cost increase (or not eat, pun intended). They may be correct, they may not. Seems like we get the experiment regardless of our point of view. They are simply not correct, unfortunately. There's no need to experiment. The issue is not with manufacturing per se. Its with manufacturing JOBS. The USA is far more efficient today with computers / automation managing huge swaths of our manufacturing process. Even if we increase output dramatically, we won't make many jobs. The sad fact is that automation is destroying that way of life. US Manufacturing is severely up over the past few decades. Aside from recessionary periods (2008, 2001, etc. etc.), the US has constantly manufactured more and more things. We've just managed to do it with fewer and fewer people.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoBe careful of confirmation bias, it is easy to just say they are wrong but it is important to them that the experiment is run. Your thesis seems to based on the assertion that 'jobs' are the desired outcome and you will get 'automation' instead. I don't disagree, that is certainly a possible outcome but having recently read an interesting position paper on Tesla where much of their model 3 woes were being pinned on being too automated it suggests that it isn't as simple as ordering up a few robots and you're done. Further many of the steel and aluminum plants in the US have been automated as a means of cutting cost, and yet are still made idle by lower cost foreign steel and aluminum. So perhaps it may be a small number of positions that are brought back just by turning the factory back on. Not to mention material transport, etc. All I'm trying to say is that these things are often more nuanced than they appear on the surface.
- dragontamer 9y ago> Be careful of confirmation bias, it is easy to just say they are wrong but it is important to them that the experiment is run. Sure. And its important to me that the USA remains strong and the best in the world. Unfortunately, their perspectives are weakening the USA and therefore, I'll work against them politically. Various US citizens are entitled to their opinion. And I'm entitled to my opinion of those people.
- Clubber 9y ago10K mile view, automation is part of it but offshoring jobs is also part of it. My vehicle was manufactured in Mexico. The one I owned before that was manufactured in the US. The manufacture is still highly automated, but it's cheaper to do in Mexico for various reasons, one being cheaper labor, another being no tariffs.
- dragontamer 9y ago> one being cheaper labor, another being no tariffs. The most important of which is that specialization is the key to efficiency. The USA plants manufacture Ford F-150. But the Ford Fusion is manufactured in Mexico. Having all of your plants in one city making the F150 and ONLY the F150 means parts for that vehicle are more readily available, more specialists who understand the process are grouped together, and the community grows as a whole. Cars definitely need to be made per-country basis in general. The USA has slightly different regulations than UK (Driver seat for instance). Often times: when a plant moves to Mexico, its more so that Ford can increase production of a particular model in a particular area. Scaling up the F150 to even greater production numbers? Well, its cheaper to move the assembly lines to another country, and then grow the F150 plant.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoSpokane already has an aluminum plant (well, a rolling mill), and it is profitable because of cheap Washington state hydro.