4 ms·
This specific issue has nothing to do with Trump. For at LEAST the last 20 years, I've heard of people complain about "Trade Deficits" and the perils of "Globa
by dragontamer 9y ago
This specific issue has nothing to do with Trump.
For at LEAST the last 20 years, I've heard of people complain about "Trade Deficits" and the perils of "Globalization". Sure, Trump is an anti-globalist. But so are a TON of other people. My statements are aimed at anti-globalists in general.
> And if you don't believe that's the case, I'll go spend a day in rural West Virginia with you and show you first hand.
Indeed. And I've spent a week in rural Washington (Spokane). The town was decimated after a lumber mill closing, and tons of people were on welfare. Trust me dude, I've seen it myself. HUGE stretches of areas where the ONLY revenue source are Native American casinos and/or military bases, with closed down factories overlooking hills. There were some successful farmland, but that's not enough to sustain the economy of the population.
Now explain to me how raising Aluminum / Steel prices is going to improve the position of towns like this? Explain to me why a trade war with China / Europe / Other countries helps at all?
China just increased tariffs on Pork, Wine, dried fruits and nuts: https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2018/04/02/598870076/what-chinese-tariffs-targeting-american-crops-will-mean-for-farmers https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2018/04/02/598870076/wh...
Good luck rust-belt / heartland. The trade war is coming. A good chunk of the rural folks have been wanting this for years. If Trump wasn't going to be elected last year, it'd only be a matter of time before some other "anti-globalist" came into power.
Unfortunately for the rural folks: they're the ones who depend most heavily on exports AND imports. Increase costs of steel and aluminum makes manufacturing more difficult. Sure, it helps the US Steel industry, but there are FAR more rural towns out there who rely upon cheap steel prices for the meager manufacturing that they already have. And obviously, if China stops buying Pork / Fruits / Wine / etc. etc. from American farmers, then those farmers are going to get hurt.
Its obviously lose/lose if you give it some thought. Alas, too many people are focused on the "Trade Deficit" to even care.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pishpash 9y agoTrade deficit is also a red herring. It's accompanied by an equal and opposite capital account surplus. In this case China invests in US Treasuries. Now this is money you could be spending wisely -- funding obligations and social services, investing in education, investing in infrastructure, investing in new technology. The rhetorical question is what has the US been spending it on? It's crystal clear what the problem is. It's not the trade deficit, which is simply a result of the market's way of allocating where capital and labor should be. The market is giving US laborers an extraordinary break -- let others be slaves, you take the capital. The problem is what the US has been doing with this capital.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago> This specific issue has nothing to do with Trump. I can certainly agree with that. In these sorts of discussions I work hard to ignore the 'people are complaining about ...' sorts of inputs because people complain about everything, it is hard to develop understanding from that. However it is useful to understand economic value is changing. For example, gasoline was a 'waste product' of refining oil for kerosene[1]. When the economic value of gasoline changed, it changed how the companies were viewed. Nuclear power was once the power of the future with high economic value, until it was perceived (or maligned depending on your point of view) into being a threat to civilization. So where does economic value arise? It is the ratio of the cost of production over the price of a good. So raising tariffs allows the cost of production of a foreign good to rise, and assuming the buyers are all trying to get the same price, the economic value of aluminum production goes up in the local (tariff free) economy. So the price of aluminum goes up, and now it can be made profitably in Spokane, so an aluminum plant (mill?) opens up and jobs are created and the town becomes more prosperous. With tariffs it is possible to raise the effective cost of any good to the point where it can be made profitably locally. However it requires that the local economy be able to pick up production. That is generally not a problem for the US economy, not as easily done on places like Brazil for example which can have high tariffs and still not have a local iPhone factory. The rust belt folks believe that the country will switch to manufacturing things locally and consumers will eat the cost increase (or not eat, pun intended). They may be correct, they may not. Seems like we get the experiment regardless of our point of view. [1] http://knowledgenuts.com/2014/02/24/gasoline-used-to-be-considered-garbage/ http://knowledgenuts.com/2014/02/24/gasoline-used-to-be-cons...
- dragontamer 9y ago> The rust belt folks believe that the country will switch to manufacturing things locally and consumers will eat the cost increase (or not eat, pun intended). They may be correct, they may not. Seems like we get the experiment regardless of our point of view. They are simply not correct, unfortunately. There's no need to experiment. The issue is not with manufacturing per se. Its with manufacturing JOBS. The USA is far more efficient today with computers / automation managing huge swaths of our manufacturing process. Even if we increase output dramatically, we won't make many jobs. The sad fact is that automation is destroying that way of life. US Manufacturing is severely up over the past few decades. Aside from recessionary periods (2008, 2001, etc. etc.), the US has constantly manufactured more and more things. We've just managed to do it with fewer and fewer people.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoSpokane is not rural. Newport is rural, Yakima is kind of rural, but Spokane has 500,000 people and a grimy downtown. Spokane’s current decline, vs. when I was a kid in the 80s, is due to a decline in...manufacturing. Also, Kaiser as a major aluminum processing center there , fed by cheap hydro power from columbia river dams, so the steel/aluminum should be of some benefit (though that feeds a Boeing operation that could be hurt by retaliation tariffs). (note: I don’t support the tariffs, just pointing out the facts).
- dragontamer 9y agoThanks for the perspective. Looking back at the map, I landed in Spokane airport and then traveled westward for 2 hours. We passed the Grand Coulee Dam and I stayed in and around that area for roughly a week and got to interact with the locals. Omak was the actual town I stayed in. Apologies for getting the geography wrong. I had to look up the map and actually remember the names to get this stuff right... I'll check a map next time I start listing off Geography I'm not familiar with... Specifically for the area I was in: the locals were mostly concerned with a Lumber Mill that shut down relatively recently. Certainly not a town that is affected by the Aluminum or Steel tariffs, and certainly one that will be affected by China's counter-tariffs in Nuts and Dried Fruit. Lots of farms in that area. You're right though: they have lots of cheap power due to the huge Grand Coulee Dam, so the area should be theoretically a good area for manufacturing.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoAh...that makes much more sense. There is nothing from Spokane to Wenatchee along that route. Spokane is Washington State's second largest airport, but like many airports is located outside of the city. Washington has been in the metal refining business because of cheap hydro since WW2, Boeing's primary operations are in Washington (Seattle, some in Spokane) because of it.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoAlso, most of the farms in that part of Washington focus on apples, berries and, oddly enough, grass feed for Kobei beef, nuts are more of a California thing.
- Clubber 9y ago>Good luck rust-belt / heartland. The trade war is coming. You can't scare people with nothing left to lose.
- dragontamer 9y agoPlenty to lose still. We export food around the world. Vietnam uses our cotton to make shirts. Etc. etc. The US Heartland relies upon beef, cotton, nut, pork, etc. etc. exports. The US's primary "manufactured" export is food from the heartland.
- Clubber 9y agoThose are largely mega-farms run similar to mega-corporations, and they utilize a lot of immigrant labor. There are a few independent farmers around eeking out a living, but not many.
- dragontamer 9y agoCapitalism generally favors mega-farms though, due to the efficiencies of scale. Larger corporations can more reliably offer wages, better plan for trends, better analyze market conditions, afford the latest technologies, etc. etc. Traditionally, when companies got too big in the USA, the regulators would split them up to allow competitors to flourish. This sort of splitting doesn't happen these days however.
- Clubber 9y ago>This sort of splitting doesn't happen these days however. They sure haven't. Last real breakup was AT&T in the early 1980s? I think that's my biggest gripe with politics today. Neither party is willing to break up these big companies and often gives the green-light for mega mergers without much fuss.