4 ms·
Really? I don't recall meeting an Uber driver who didn't do it all the time. I think GP's point is valid. To start with, it's beneficial and fair that lots of
by lordnacho 9y ago
Really? I don't recall meeting an Uber driver who didn't do it all the time.
I think GP's point is valid. To start with, it's beneficial and fair that lots of little people can rent out their cars for some extra change. But when it ends up being a loophole to sidestepping existing rules to make essentially the same service with fewer rules, it's worth paying extra attention to. Not saying it needs to be outlawed, just that it's not obvious what to do.
- ForHackernews 9y agoIt'd be very easy to have legislation that regulates small-timers (only owns one or two cars, rents it out less than 30% of the time, etc.) differently from professional operators, even if they advertise on the same platform. Some jurisdictions have started doing this for AirBnb.
- Shivetya 9y agowe already have too much of this type of regulation which does just what you state, keeping small timers out to benefit the established interests. occupational licensing sounds beneficial to the public as a whole and at one time it was but once established businesses found they could use it to block competition its original focus was lost. It really clobbers low income workers and fattens pockets of companies which "train" for licenses and the like. Nearly a third of all jobs are regulated as such and many are prohibited to former convicts which is yet another road block. You can end up spending more money gaining your license to braid hair than serve as an EMT.
- ForHackernews 9y agoI'm proposing the opposite: regulate big operators more heavily than small-time amateurs. If you want to rent out a spare room in your own house a few weekends a year, the government probably doesn't need to be very involved in that. On the other hand, if you're a company that owns 50 condos and lists them all on Airbnb, you should be carrying insurance, you should be subject to inspection for bedbugs, etc.
- wutbrodo 9y agoSure, I'm not disagreeing with the point as you state it. I was just surprised by the claim that casuals are pushed out.
- ams6110 9y agoAfer accounting for their costs, Uber drivers don't make much money. As a casual gig a lot of people with other sources of income have probably found it's not worth their time. If you have no other options, working 80 hours/week as an uber driver might make you enough to eeek out a living.
- wutbrodo 9y agoI'm not speculating from first principles as to what might be happening, I'm saying what I've seen from a fairly large sample over the years. Though again, it's limited to my market (SF).