5 ms·
I can’t say much about the accident rate but the loss can be attributed to the fact that anything more than a scratch on a Tesla is often counted as a total los
by dogma1138 9y ago
I can’t say much about the accident rate but the loss can be attributed to the fact that anything more than a scratch on a Tesla is often counted as a total loss just look at the various Tesla salvage channels on YouTube and you’ll see how silly it is.
This is what happens when no one can fix your car but Tesla and Tesla doesn’t repair what most body shops would fix in a day.
- lsc 9y agobut the non-tesla electric cars also had more severe (though fewer) claims. Part of that is probably that an electric car is just plain more expensive than it's ICE counterpart right now, and my experience is that repair cost of a vehicle scales with the capital cost of a vehicle.
- greglindahl 9y agoYou also need to compare Tesla aluminum-bodied cars with aluminum-bodied cars. Which are more expensive to repair. The IIHS article doesn't say what cars they compared Model S to, and aluminum-bodied cars are rare enough that it's likely not very comparable. Mind you, that doesn't affect the claims-per-mile statistic.
- MrFoof 9y agoThe IIHS considers the Tesla Model S a "Large Luxury Car" in its classification system. Other "Large Luxury Cars" as classified by IIHS include... * Acura RLX * Audi A6 * Audi A7 (not rated) * Audi A8 (not rated) (aluminum body) * Bentley Continental GT (not rated) (aluminum body) * BMW 5 Series * BMW 6 series (not rated) * BMW 7 series (not rated) * Cadillac CTS * Cadillac XTS * Genesis G80 * Genesis G90 * Infiniti Q70 * Jaguar XJ (not rated) (aluminum body) * Lexus GS * Lexus LS (aluminum body) * Lincoln Continental * Maserati Ghibli * Maserati Quattroporte (not rated) (aluminum body) * Mercedes-Benz CLS-Class (not rated) * Mercedes-Benz E-Class (partial aluminum body) * Mercedes-Benz S-Class (not rated) (partial aluminum body) * Porsche Panamera (not rated) (aluminum body) * Volvo S80 * Volvo S90 ----- The main issue is the IIHS doesn't test many vehicles that can exceed a $100,000 MSRP, as they're a small portion of the overall market.
- jd20 9y agoAnd the Tesla is furthermore an outlier, because for a long time it was the only luxury EV in widespread use. In a couple more years, the data on "luxury electric vehicles" should have a lot more data points.
- Spooky23 9y agoTesla refuses to allow third party repair or parts and has difficulty making things. So costs are crazy. A colleague had to have his towed 300 miles and wait forever, for a rear end fender bender which necessitates a claim as the cost was a few thousand bucks. With a normal car, he’d probably just lay out of pocket to avoid the insurance bullshittery.
- greglindahl 9y agoThis is not correct. Tesla does not do body work.
- nnf 9y agoNot to correct you but to add context: I recently had body work done through the Tesla service center. I dropped my car off, got a loaner, and they took mine to a nearby body shop. (They told me up front they would be doing it this way.) Picked it up a couple days later where I dropped it off.
- dogma1138 9y agoTesla does cosmetic body work they don’t do it in house but they do handle it for you anything more than that they will refuse to touch it and it will likely get totaled by your insurer. You can ry to repair it on your own and recertify it with Tesla but it takes quite a bit of time and it ain’t free.
- greglindahl 9y agoI've had 1 body repair to my Tesla. My insurance didn't total the car, and there were several local certified body shops to choose from. It was the same process as with other cars, I've never had a dealer do body work.
- nradov 9y agoIt seems silly to avoid filing an insurance claim when the other driver is insured and at fault. Even a minor bumper repair on a cheap vehicle is >$800 now. I've been rear ended 3 times in California and the amount of insurance bullshittery was pretty low.
- mikeash 9y agoTesla doesn’t do collision repair. They have a program to certify third party body shops for that.
- dogma1138 9y agoTesla handles that for you afaik and even then it’s limited as those body shops can’t get replacement parts form Tesla other than windshields and lights so if you need to replace a body part you’re out of luck.
- mikeash 9y agoTesla doesn’t handle it for you at all, and a full range of replacement parts is available, although sometimes they can take a long time to arrive.
- hliyan 9y agoI'm starting to feel like this whole thing is a case of competitors in the auto/energy industry smelling blood in the water after the Model 3 production issues. I'm seeing a spike in "Why Tesla is doomed" type articles recently...
- jd20 9y agoI don't know for other areas, but here in bay area Tesla only does service, not collision repairs. I took both my Model S, and my wife's Porsche to the same repair facility, and I can tell you that both were eye wateringly expensive, and so well over my deductible that I really just didn't care. So, I'm not sure whether to feel bad that the Tesla's claims are higher on average, or take pride that I'm getting more for my dollar from the insurer when I get it fixed?
- dogma1138 9y agoAs far as I know Tesla handles minor cosmetic damage for you they will hand it off to a local body shop but the problem is that anything that won’t buff out can’t be repaired as you for example as a body shop even a certified one can’t get say a buy a new door from Tesla. The only way to fix a Tesla is essentially via salvage and there are plenty of people who buy scrapped Tesla’s and make a frankencar some might opt to recertify it with Tesla so they can’t get updates and service but you don’t have to do so for the car to drive and even charge from the network.
- jd20 9y agoSo in your example, sounds like Tesla is still not doing any body work, they're just referring the customer to a local body shop, which sets their own prices. Repair centers can certainly buy brand new official parts from Tesla. When my nose cone was fixed, the entire front bumper assembly (including new Autopilot sensors) was ordered from Tesla. This is pretty much the rule, not the exception, and Tesla seems to operate no differently than other car manufacturers when it comes to the repair process, from what I've seen. I don't see much about the Tesla that would make it more likely to salvage other than the battery pack though. Structural repair to a Tesla seems about the same as any other aluminum bodied car, and while there are shops that will do it (and get all the certified parts from Tesla), it just often doesn't make sense to spend $20-30k to fix a car whose used market value with a salvage title will be maybe double that?