7 ms·
I've wondered about this. I've worn a 34"-34" pant for the last 20 years, and I know my waist has expanded over that time. It just didn't add up. On fixing t
by btilly 16y ago
I've wondered about this. I've worn a 34"-34" pant for the last 20 years, and I know my waist has expanded over that time. It just didn't add up.
On fixing the meaning of the sizing, I'm reminded of someone I knew who took a sewing class in highschool. They started with patterns from the 1950s, and despite the teacher warning the students how different the sizings would be, virtually nobody managed to make clothing that they could squeeze into.
Personally I think the best solution is to make it a matter of law that the sizing be accurate. Everyone would hear that the sizing changed dramatically, there would be a brief transition, and we'd soon get used to accurate sizes. Drawing it out gradually would force people to keep on relearning their size, and overall would be more disruptive.
- city41 16y agoNot to mention it might be a bit of motivation to lose some weight.
- AndrewHampton 16y agoI really hope something this trivial doesn't merit the time of Congress. Unfortunately, I wouldn't be surprised if it did.
- tomjen3 16y agoTrivial? It might seem so, but it does actually fall well within the area the founders gave congress (surely this is both weights and measurements and interstate commerce). "Fixing" the standard size would be fraud, as they don't sell the actual product that they claim to sell.
- dantheman 16y agoWould you mandate your system or sizing? What if they just changed their form of measurement? Or they said recommended size? Is this a problem you are constantly facing? I don't have any difficulty buying pants - why do we need a law?
- tomjen3 16y agoAll I would mandate would be that pants labeled 10 inches would be ten inches. You want to sell Venti pants - go ahead.
- jodrellblank 16y agoWhy don't we revoke all other laws which do not affect you while we're at it?
- joshuacc 16y agoState legislatures would also be an option.
- mkramlich 16y agothe more state-specific/state-varying laws that exist the more of a pain-in-the-ass it becomes for businesses to operate across multiple states and especially across the entire nation
- jellicle 16y agoGood thing someone invented the Uniform Commercial Code to solve this problem, then. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Commercial_Code http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Commercial_Code
- Splines 16y agoSeems to me that "fixing" sizes would put pressure on people to lose weight, in the similar way that publishing calories on menus does.
- pierrefar 16y agoHardly trivial when waist circumference is a predictor of heart disease. http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/public/heart/obesity/lose_wt/risk.htm http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/public/heart/obesity/lose_wt... http://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/news/20050414/waist-size-predicts-heart-disease-danger http://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/news/20050414/waist-size-...
- gojomo 16y agoHow about this: there's no legal requirement you label your products in any given unit, but if you choose 'inches', they have to be real 'inches'. You can use your own made-up unit, say 'oldnavies', instead -- just don't call them 'inches'. (Even minarchists usually find laws -- common-law or legislative -- against commercial fraud acceptable.)
- joshfinnie 16y agoI thought there were bodies of government[1] out there that specialize is certifying companies who use 'inches' and want to mean inches. If you are not certified, I don't think there is a guarantee that what they say is 100% accurate. [1] http://www.iso.org http://www.iso.org
- georgecmu 16y agoIronically, for me the problem is the opposite. I've worn the same size since college, and in the past few years noticed that I have a hard time keeping pants on.
- araneae 16y agoA major problem with this is that the "size" generally refers to the size of the person it goes on, not the actual measurements of the clothing. For instance, a size small "boyfriend" sweater probably has similar dimensions to an XL form fitting sweater, because it's intended to be worn large. And what if you're buying something with elastic, like leggings? Anyone can get a ruler and see they the waistband is 15 inches, but that information is completely useless if you're trying to decide which one to buy. Sure, size inflation happens, but legislating that the dimensions of clothing be declared actually defeats the purpose of sizing, which is to tell you generally who should be wearing it. This is not like the nutrition labels on food. You can't tell how many calories are in a food by looking at it. You CAN tell how large a waistband is with a ruler. Legislating on this would make things very difficult on both clothing manufacturers and clothing purchasers. And it's only misleading to people who don't own a ruler, which I think is a fair burden to place on the consumer.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>>Personally I think the best solution is to make it a matter of law that the sizing be accurate. >legislating that the dimensions of clothing be declared actually defeats the purpose of sizing He said what you said he didn't but should have AFAICS. He didn't say that you had to measure the circumference of the waistband in a pair of trousers just the size of a persons waist that the trousers were made for. >And it's only misleading to people who don't own a ruler, which I think is a fair burden to place on the consumer. You seem to be suggesting that when purchasing clothing online one should buy all the clothes, measure them yourself and then try on the ones that are the right size. Or that in a store one should measure the clothes on the rack to find the right size and then try that on. As the manufacturer produces the clothing to a specific size and has already designed the article to fit a particularly body size would it not be easier if they honestly labelled the size the clothing had been made for instead. Do you really think that fraudulent retail should be allowed because people are able to test things for themselves. Tins of tuna with dolphin meat in that was labelled "dolphin friendly" - are they OK? People can simply do a DNA test and determine the species of animal the flesh comes from, no?
- 16y ago
- dantheman 16y agoThere is absolutely no reason for a law like this to ever come into effect.