3 ms·
Dns over https would be harder for governments and other middleman to block or intercept, despite it being less efficient. It would look like any other https r
by tyingq 9y ago
Dns over https would be harder for governments and other middleman to block or intercept, despite it being less efficient. It would look like any other https request. Especially if browsers agreed to universally support it.
- IshKebab 9y agoNo it wouldn't. They're both encrypted with the same method so they can't tell whether http is used or not.
- tyingq 9y agoSorry, confused. Https requests are prolific, while encrypted DNS requests aren't. Why isn't the former less hard to detect?
- forapurpose 9y agoPerhaps if the attacker filters traffic first by protocol, it's harder but not at all impossible. I'd guess that DNS-over-HTTPS packets won't be hard to identify by other means.
- patrickmcmanus 9y agoof course dns over https to cloudflare can be mixed on the same h2 connection with other https to the same host. It starts to get interesting. (this is one of the advantages of https vs straight tls)
- ori_b 9y agoHow would you tell that an encrypted chunk of data is HTTPS instead of DNS? The best you'd be able to do is guess based on behavior that it's DNS.
- tyingq 9y agoDestination port might be easy to differentiate dns over tls vs dns over https :)
- kpcyrd 9y agotls isn't magic, you can still observe the encrypted stream and make assumptions based on bytes sent/received on the wire, protocol patterns and timing. See the crime and breach attack.