4 ms·
other sites are forced out of business completely, then the argument doesn't stand This is only plausible if such a crack down could change things so much that
by joe_the_user 16y ago
other sites are forced out of business completely, then the argument doesn't stand
This is only plausible if such a crack down could change things so much that adult ads weren't just harder to make but near to impossible. And that seems highly implausible given that prostitution flourished quite well in a pre-Internet world.
Merely increasing the barriers to entry actually enhances the power of the "mafia-based sex slave traffickers" - when an individual can place a simple ad, they don't have to depend on a dicey character, otherwise they might.
And prostitution has had a variety of "customer acquisition mechanisms" stretching into antiquity. Full page ads you can find in many free weekly would qualify as authentic temptations for engage an prostitute (show lots of skin, etc). An ambiguously worded ad on craigslist is more like a means for a consumer to find the product they are already looking for.
- tptacek 16y agoWhat's your point? Whatever means they use to acquire customers can be targeted by law enforcement. It is simply not the case that craigslist was their one exploitable weak spot. I don't like arguments that insult my intelligence.
- joe_the_user 16y agoThe point is that merely decreasing but not eliminating the ability of prostitutes to find customers will increase the power of the most larger, more exploitative operators but not eliminate the phenomena. We can see a similar pattern in the drug trade. Illegality creates large, monstrous cartels when it doesn't eliminate demand. For example, the semi-legal pot growers in California aren't great but they are much better than the Mexican cocaine cartels (murdering 100's of people at a time last I heard...).
- tptacek 16y agoIs your argument that the dynamics of the sex trade are the same as that of the drug trade? Because I don't believe you. I don't even believe that most prostitution is driven by organized crime. I don't think you can point to any prohibition of any item and say "that's going to work just like the drug trade", unless you're prepared to argue that we should all be allowed to buy Stinger missiles.
- joe_the_user 16y agoProstitution resembles the drug trade in that it is unlikely the demand as such is going to be eliminated - indeed, this is even more true for prostitution than drugs. Certainly, prostitution is not driven by organized crime currently. The point is that when it is more difficult for a prostitute to operate independently, she is more likely to turn to a pimp and/or a mafia controlled operation (not to deny that some pimps and mafiosi entice some people into prostitution now - but as you say, this isn't the majority currently). We're more or less arguing over demand curves. Your argument boils down to claiming that more enforcement would change the supply-and-demand situation sufficiently to improve things for people. That is where both drugs and music downloading are good analogies because they both show the failure of enforcement to impact supply and demand sufficiently to change the situation (except for the worse).
- tptacek 16y agoThis sounds like a reasonable argument for legalizing prostitution. I won't vote for you, but I'll respect the effort. It does not sound like a reasonable argument for saying that craigslist should be running ads to help the illegal sex trade. This is not just Internet scare-mongering. Craigslist has genuinely transformed and streamlined the sex trade. It did so knowingly and, given the amount of topic-based curation it already does, deliberately. It is a valid public policy target.
- joe_the_user 16y agoIt does not sound like a reasonable argument for saying that craigslist should be running ads to help the illegal sex trade. The last time I looked, Craig wasn't soliciting donations for the Russian mafia. Craiglist doesn't run ads. Craigslist's users run ads. Some of those ads might (or might not) be for prostitutes. The question under debate is what obligation should be imposed on craigslist to decide that something is an ad for prostitution and stop it. And I'm not particular arguing for or against legalizing drugs or prostitution - legal or illegal, both have their problems. I would argue for more of a harm reduction perspective on both of these. And "Craigslist has genuinely transformed and streamlined the sex trade": To claim Craigslist by itself did this is preposterous. The Internet as a whole certainly did but you're going to put that genie back in the bottle - well, not without a dictatorship harsher than China or Iran.