3 ms·
Is the underlying concern nonsensical? Well there are a number of ways that can be interpreted. Is there exploitation and misery within the sex industry? Yes
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Is the underlying concern nonsensical?
Well there are a number of ways that can be interpreted.
Is there exploitation and misery within the sex industry? Yes but far from every sex worker is a fifteen year old Russian nanny tricked into prostitution. Many go into the field with their eyes open, make more money than they make in a mainstream field and leave. Others go in that way but get addicted to drugs or otherwise harmed. It's dangerous but so are a lot of things.
Is making it harder for prostitutes to find johns going to decrease exploitative aspects of prostitution? It seems highly doubtful to me. While I know of friends of friends who used the adult section to turn tricks, I'm far from an expert. Still, the most plausible argument is that craigslist makes it possible for prostitutes to operate in the safest possible fashion doing what they'd do anyway. If you disagree, I'd like to hear the argument.
So, is the entire campaign a political stunt that hasn't prevented a single act of child exploitation? I think the article makes a good case for this. As far as "outrage", that's also a rather nebulous thing.
- tptacek 16y agoI'm not going to get pigeonholed into sticking up for some career pol in Connecticut. The motivation behind the attack on craigslist is obvious. But neither am I going to allow my recognition of that fact to reshape my views on the sex trade. Blumenthal being opportunistic and unfair doesn't make craigslist right. What I see here is yet another case of technology complicating law enforcement, and the peanut gallery expecting the laws to change to accomodate it. That shouldn't be how the world works. I'm biased, because I'm pretty intimately familiar with other crimes that technology makes harder to enforce.
- sprout 16y agoThe task is no more complicated than it was before. I've seen no evidence that conclusively shows Craigslist had a positive or negative effect here (most seem to take it for granted that Craigslist is a positive or negative force.) Generally it looks like Craigslist was making enforcement easier by providing a centralized repository of everyone's actions.
- tptacek 16y agoI don't think it's as simple as all that. If craigslist itself was under a serious legal assault, or its managers facing criminal charges, I'd be right there with you. It seems to me, however, that craigslist's opponents would be happy to leave it at "don't run ads for the sex trade". I simply don't believe that's an unreasonable position.
- joe_the_user 16y agoThe Internet in general does make it much easier to engage in "victimless crimes". That is not going to change unless a truly massive level of repression is imposed. I would oppose such an effort. The situation is a signal that society needs to find a different means to deal with the problems like child-trafficking than making prostitution in general illegal. And I certainly do expect law enforcement to accommodate - law enforcement works for me, meaning society in general, last I hear.
- tptacek 16y agoIf you think prostitution is victimless, you and I will just have to agree to disagree, just as I agree to disagree with people who think abortion is murder. Law enforcement should accomodate the will of the people. It should not blindly accomodate the will of the market and the progress of technology. Markets are good, technology is good, but neither are great drivers of public policy. If you're right about prostitution, change the law. Unlike newspaper classifieds, the legislative process did not become irrelevant when craigslist caught on.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI'm actually not injecting any of my values into the conversation - I used quotations. Acts that could be called "victimless crimes" are acts which both sides are eager to engage in. You can consider one or another of those who engage in drug trades or prostitution transactions to be victims if you'd like, I don't think that really changes the conversation here. Regardless of the values involved, actions which both sides are eager to engage in are inherently difficult to stop - both sides happy to use subterfuge, etc. So the cost to society for stopping such things is only going to increase as communication technology advances. And enforcement always involves a cost-benefit equation regardless of whether one might think of laws as absolute. However bad it might be, prostitution is not going away and enforcement acts in the end are ways of dealing with it rather than something that is going to stop it. The enforcement equation for drugs and prostitution have always been "perverse" - since police can't stop prostitution, their actions have often involved both self-aggrandizing media-events ("moral panics") and kick-back schemes. The perversity only increases with communications technology.