7 ms·
According to the creator’s Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/profileengine https://www.patreon.com/profileengine > I spent ten years on a project to build a fr
by danso 9y ago
According to the creator’s Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/profileengine https://www.patreon.com/profileengine
> I spent ten years on a project to build a free, public, highly advanced search engine for social network data. I obtained special permission from Facebook to index 420 million public profiles. When Facebook reneged on the deal and tried to destroy my business, I spent years of my life and a lot of money on legal costs and eventually obtained a settlement. I have continued to operate Profile engine for several years despite it not making money because it stands between Facebook and a monopoly over social data and because it helps educate people not to trust Facebook.
It seems like his main motive is to ruin Facebook — ostensibly by making it obvious to the world the dangers of FB data. And he’s doing this by releasing the accessible data — including photos — of every user who set their profile public.
The PR harm to Facebook is obvious. I’m not so sure the millions of people naive enough to not tighten their privacy settings will be completely understanding. Even if there is no legal danger, this doesn’t seem well thought out in terms of consequences.
Edit: A Quartz article from 2014, in which the service is described as “spammy”.
https://qz.com/279940/meet-profile-engine-the-spammy-facebook-crawler-hated-by-people-who-want-to-be-forgotten/ https://qz.com/279940/meet-profile-engine-the-spammy-faceboo...
- zeth___ 9y agoI expect him to be sued to oblivion when the GDPR comes into effect. This is all of irresponsible dangerous and illegal.
- cctt23 9y agoHow is collating public profiles dangerous, or illegal? GDPR doesn’t cover it unless the poeple in question make a specific request either.
- rhizome 9y agoDoes ProfileEngine have a local instance in the EU or something? Are you thinking the "G" in GDPR means "global?"
- greglindahl 9y agoThe GDPR purports to apply to any EU person, no matter where they are. That's one of the many problems with it. However, it is already the case that the EU casts a wide net. blekko got a demand for info from the EU regarding Google's dominance of the search space in relation to mobile apps. Most of the questions were about opinions, not facts. After consulting with our lawyers, they said that the small amount of advertising income we had from the EU was enough that the EU could demand that we answer, but we could ignore the first one and see if they asked again more firmly.
- Buge 9y agoWould it be possible for the EU to get an arrest warrant and extradite the creator to the EU? Or if an extradition isn't possible, what if the creator goes on vacation to the EU, would the creator get arrested then?
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoDoesn't this become the internet archive's problem, and not the creator. And all the internet archive would have to do is set up a way for people to remove their data from the archive.
- jakeogh 9y agoNo. Unless he goes to the EU he is not subject to the laws of another country.
- Buge 9y agoThen how was Roman Seleznev arrested and charged under US laws even though he never visited the US, or even a country with an extradition treaty with the US? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Chp12sEnWk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Chp12sEnWk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Seleznev https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Seleznev
- written 9y agoI don't. The data doesn't even contain surnames of people.
- tehlike 9y agoGDPR is not in effect, yet. Can it retroactively go behind previous events? Not sure, not a lawyer.
- chillydawg 9y agoVery very few laws become retroactive.
- erric 9y agoSOSTA/FOSTA was designed to be retroactive.
- jjeaff 9y agoThis guy most likely has no presence or assets in EU. So they will have no success in trying to enforce it.
- jonhendry18 9y ago"Edit: A Quartz article from 2014, in which the service is described as “spammy”." Yeah, seems pretty sleazy. "I didn't get as rich as I wanted, so I'm going to release all this information about people who never wanted their information to be distributed this way, and I'm going to release it in a way that is uncontrollable." Claydon writes: "I could have sold this data to some data broker for a lot of money and it would have been used by those with money for marketing or political purposes rather than freely available for the public good. Instead I donated it for free to the Internet Archive." He's either naive or stupid.
- lopmotr 9y agoHow is it any worse than what the Internet Archive does normally when it scrapes sites itself? Most sites aren't able to stop scrapers the way FB could.
- oneweekwonder 9y agoHave you seen Internet Archive try to monetize unauthorized scraped data? Only to release/leak it a DECADE later under the facade of free information.
- lopmotr 9y agoInternet Archive would be sleazy if it started out by selling data before becoming what it is now? I don't see that the history of the company matters.
- jonhendry18 9y agotbh I'm not crazy about some of the things the Internet Archive does, either. What bugs me about Profile Engine is that there are probably a lot of people who realized their mistake of leaving their profiles wide open on Facebook, and tightened up the restrictions, whose details might still be wide open in this dataset without them even realizing.