4 ms·
For many things, this is exactly what I want. Walmart has great prices for the same as their competitors and their service is ok. They aren’t Costco, but they
by prepend 9y ago
For many things, this is exactly what I want. Walmart has great prices for the same as their competitors and their service is ok.
They aren’t Costco, but they deliver exactly what they promise - minimal quality for the best price.
But I’d never buy non-consumables from them.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI agree with you. Walmart already revolutionized pharma once by offering a huge list of drugs for $4/30-day and $10/-90 day. Even if no one reading this buys those drugs from Wal-Mart, you get them cheaply because Wal-Mart forced everyone else to drop prices to compete. I wonder if it could be calculated how many lives have been saved by doing this. Anecdotally I know a lot of people whose lives have been improved by being able to take those cheap options. And I know a couple of doctors who say they point their patients in that direction to help them save money. >But I’d never buy non-consumables from them. I'm curious, would you get a Wal-Mart xray or MRI? Depending on the issue, I think I might.
- freehunter 9y agoWell, prescription drugs are one thing Walmart can't pressure the manufacturer to make worse. It has to be exactly what's printed on the label, nothing else. Many things aren't that way, including health plans.
- emmelaich 9y agoMostly agreed but be careful.. There have been incidents of generics that don't have as much active ingredient in them -- or have other quality control problems. The other factor is packaging and longevity. Generics e.g. tend to have bits of foil that are too easy to detach and swallow. And shelf life -- a quality of packaging and ingredients issue -- is less certain.
- baddox 9y agoThere are minimum requirements in the United States for health insurance plans. Pretty much every insurance provider already offers a barebones plan, and if Walmart/Humana could beat that on price, that would be a good thing.
- AFNobody 9y agoThe minimum legal standard to manufacturer is not the same thing as "safe". Cut too many corners and you ruin the medication before it arrives. For instance, I would run the fuck away from a Muro 128 generic sold by Walmart. https://www.fiercepharma.com/supply-chain/bausch-lomb-blames-weather-for-recall-of-880-000-tubes-of-eye-ointment https://www.fiercepharma.com/supply-chain/bausch-lomb-blames... > Bausch + Lomb began recalling 850,000 tubes of Muro 128 ointment--plus 35,000 tubes of an unbranded sodium chloride product sold by Major Pharmaceuticals--after users complained of a "gritty, sandlike feeling" in the eye, The Wall Street Journal reports. The Valeant Pharmaceuticals ($VRX)-owned ophthalmic specialist was unable to find the source of the problem at the manufacturing plant, leading it to conclude that the extreme cold experienced over the winter may have caused crystals to form in the product during shipping. Do you really trust the logistical capabilities of Walmart's supply chain to properly control for temperature?
- Consultant32452 9y ago>Do you really trust the logistical capabilities of Walmart's supply chain to properly control for temperature? Countless people buy temperature controlled groceries from Walmart and I'm not familiar with rampant outbreaks of food poisoning.
- AFNobody 9y agoDo you understand that is an easier problem to solve or are you just trolling?
- tzs 9y ago> Walmart already revolutionized pharma once by offering a huge list of drugs for $4/30-day and $10/-90 day I was shocked to find that some of my prescriptions that were costing me $20 out of pocket with insurance at Rite Aid where $4 cash price at Walmart. I've moved everything I can to cash at Walmart, even in some cases where the Walmart cash price is a little higher than my with-insurance price elsewhere, just on the general principle that I don't want my insurance company to know what drugs I take [1]. [1] This stems from a time once when a condition I had improved to the point that I could stop taking drugs for it. A few months later it returned, and I asked my doctor to renew my prescription. He did so...and the insurance company rejected it. They were treating it like I was a brand new patient, and they no longer allowed that drug unless you had first tried a couple other newer drugs and they were not acceptable. I'd never had those drugs, but I'd had others in their families and they were either not very effective or had annoying side effects. I was willing to try the new drugs eventually, if this relapse turned out to not be temporary, but in the short term I wanted what we already knew worked well.
- gumby 9y agoYou might look up the company IMS and the states with mandatory prescription surveillance. When I was in the “biz” we could get prescription data at least by county, in some places by pharmacy and/or prescriber and, of course, for some drugs the patient. Wait, you thought that info was confidential? Ha, this is the USA!
- itakedrugs 9y ago
- domevent 9y agoThis may be more my emotional/irrational reaction than anything, and if so please correct me. Seeing how WalMart treats it’s own poeple, and the lack of concern they’ve ever shown to the impacts of their stores on communities, I kind of doubt their commitment to my health in this scenario. I wouldn’t trust them to deliver what’s best for me, just what’s profitable for them.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI think you're missing the market effects of having a Wal-Mart. If Walmart moves in and offers MRIs at half the price of everyone else, then everyone else will have to offer better prices to compete. Someone who might not have been able to get an MRI at all will now have the Walmart option, and you'll still benefit from lower prices at your "premium" option.
- prepend 9y agoHave you ever worked retail? Retail is just kind of a bad industry that sucks to work in. It’s generally unskilled with high turnover. So while Walmart sucks compared to desk jobs, it’s pretty good for retail. I think they are great for communities. I lived in a rural community as a kid for many years without Walmart. We had no book store, no music store. Small under 1k people and one stoplight. They literally had only one science fiction book in the library (broken lands from empire of the east by saberhagen, super awesome book. Weird that that was the one) Walmart opened close-by and all of a sudden I could buy books. They had so many more options. We didn’t have to drive 40 minutes for groceries. About 1/3 of the Main Street stores closed but they really sucked. Interestingly their employees had zero benefits and zero sexual harassment protections. It was a small town where if you worked for the dime store you got no vacation, no benefits, got paid 50% if you were black. Lots of lame stuff. At least wal mart paid you some benefits. Walmart isn’t some all positive entity, there are negatives. But they aren’t horrible and are a huge positive force for the poor by lowering prices. It’s very frustrating to hear a rich person complain about Walmart when they haven’t had to need their groceries being 20% cheaper than Kroger or 50% less than Whole Foods.
- darawk 9y agoCouldn't agree more. Ultra cheap options is exactly what healthcare needs. 95% of medical issues don't require expensive equipment or highly trained practitioners to treat. Your broken bone doesn't require the very latest X-ray machine - the one from 20 years ago will do fine. The nurse practitioner can handle your UTI. You don't need someone who went through residency for that. There is so much cost to be saved all over the system if we could break some of these anti-competitive thickets. Walmart is an excellent choice for doing that sort of thing.
- freehunter 9y agoI agree, cheaper health care is what we need, and hospitals can cut back on some unneeded expenses to make that happen... but my fear is we'll just see more low-cost low-benefit healthcare plans instead. I'd work with an older x-ray machine if it meant a little cheaper price. I wouldn't, however, buy a healthcare plan than didn't include x-rays just because it was cheaper.
- darawk 9y agoWell, the hope is your plan would cover what is required to treat a given condition. I.e. if you have a simple broken bone, you get the cheap x-ray. If you have a complex fracture that requires fine resolution, they cover the brand new fancy x-ray. The problem right now is: Your doctor prescribes the fancy x-ray as a catch-all, for everything that requires an x-ray. The insurance company then gets billed for "x-ray", which the doctor said was necessary. There is no incentive pressure for you to choose the cheap one, because you're not paying. The doctor doesn't care because they're not paying. And the insurance company gets screwed - but they're a business, so what do they do? Raise rates for everyone, and pass it on down the line.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nitrogen 9y agoSomeone commented but was downvoted (apparently because they work for an insurance company?), and they deleted their comment. I think it's informative enough to quote here for history: > Actually, in many cases, we slap an authorization requirement on the fancy imagining or deny the claim for a lack of medical necessity. (Source: I work for an insurance company) You want to improve healthcare? Fix drug prices, fix the adversarial model between insurers and providers and do whatever you have to to get patients more facetime with clinicians. Connect and coordinate care - especially post discharge. Worry about things outside of medicine like food or social isolation or financial health.
- Scoundreller 9y agoWelcome to Costco. I love you.
- deelowe 9y agoUntil you buy a box of crackers and realize the price per gram is higher than equivalents at the grocery store that just come in larger boxes. The more you investigate walmart, the more you find you're not actually saving much. It's not worth the sub par customer service, deceptive product offering and questionable quality to me.