19 ms·
TV advertising has hit a wall thanks to streaming options like Netflix
- msoad 9y agoOnly if there was an HBO for sports too. I hate watching those stupid ads when I watch live sports!
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI might pay for that if the arena and equipment wasn't also covered in ads. That's never going to change.
- antimatter 9y agoExactly. I think NBA League Pass cuts out the advertising from the local tv networks during timeouts and half time to show the in arena feed (kiss cam, etc). But those are often times ads now as well.
- majormajor 9y agoI'm meh on those sponsorships, but would definitely pay for a commercial-removed sports experience. People don't realize how much dead time is introduced to professional games solely for commercial breaks. You can ignore a sponsor logo, you can't get that time back.
- tenken 9y agoits called PPV, a showing of an ad-free event. :)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Only if there was an HBO for sports too. There are several. HBO itself is one of them. The sports on them are fairly limited, most notably boxing, however.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> Only if there was an HBO for sports too. I hate watching those stupid ads when I watch live sports! Funny, I came here to comment on my distaste for services, such as hbonow, that throw ads in front of paid content. They place ads for their other shows in front of the thing I’m trying to watch (at least, the web service does). I hate it and I am considering dropping my subscription as a result.
- crysin 9y agoI don't really get this sentiment. I get not wanting to see ads that have nothing to do with the service you're using, but I personally have never been upset or revolted at HBO running their trailers for other shows before the show I want to watch. Everyone has their own tastes and to each their own I just wish I could understand the absolute revolt some people feel at even content relevant ads.
- alsetmusic 9y agoCompare with a service like Netflix. Netflix has no ads and let’s me skip past the opening titles with a single click of a button. It’s highly optimized to give me what I want. HBO not only shows me ads for unrelated content (it’s really never something I’m interested in seeing), but I have to blindly click the timeline when I skip it. If I overshoot, I have to backtrack in search of the first scene. Overshooting again puts me back in the ad. It’s more about what HBO wants me to see than it is about what I want to see.
- _asummers 9y agoIf you get the individual league streaming services, they often show "Commercial Break In Progress" across a semi-static image with no audio during ad breaks.
- diggernet 9y agoYeah, that's one thing I really liked about MLB.tv. It's gone. :(
- kevincennis 9y agoWhat would a service like that do during television timeouts? I’ve found silent “we’ll be right back” screens to almost be worse than ads in some ways. It’s just a weird feeling.
- losteric 9y agoIt does depend on the sport, but for basketball they could replay interesting plays, talk about players, theorize strategy, broadcast in-stadium fillers, or just show the team talking.
- scottwernervt 9y agoScroll tweets from fans.
- diggernet 9y agoI've always enjoyed those quiet ad-free breaks on MLB.tv. This year they've started filling them with loud , annoying, repetitive ads. Starting to wonder why bother paying for the service.
- Spivak 9y agoJust treat it like any other timeout that's shown: show the fans, cut to the coaches, cut to the commentators -- call it exclusive content any you're pretty much golden.
- flying_kangaroo 9y agoYou could even have the commentators take a break during tv timeouts, and just have some chill crowd shots. Maybe get some teams on board to show what they'd do on jumbotrons during the breaks in action.
- js2 9y agoI rarely watch sports events live. Each sport has a fairly predictable timeline. For example, an NFL game is about 3.5 hours of clock time for what's an hour long game (skipping clock stoppage and half-time). So just start watching 2.5 hours after kickoff and you catch up with real time by the end of the game.
- js2 9y agoDuring the Winter Olympics, I tried to figure out what I would have paid NBC for an ad-free experience (I watched as much as I could via CBC, but sometimes I just wanted to watch on TV without the VPN rigeramorale). I came up with $300. I would've paid NBC $300 for two weeks of ad-free Olympics coverage.
- maxerickson 9y agoYou think there are 3 or 4 million other households that would set the same price? (they had $900 million+ in ad revenue) It'd be a fun gimmick if they could figure out a way to auction ad free broadcasts to their viewers.
- js2 9y agoInteresting, probably not. The streaming app was almost rage inducing though. Seeing periodic commercials in and of itself wouldn't be that bad. But NBC seemed to have more ad slots than ads, because I kept seeing the same dumb 3 or 4 ads over and over, and many weren't even relevant. There was a Comcast ad that made no sense to show me. I'm not in a Comcast market. Worse, you basically couldn't forward through an event since it would stop you at an "ad point" and make you watch that ad. You could then forward to the next "ad point" and have to sit through that one. And if you skipped backwards to re-watch something to earlier than the "ad point", it would show the ads again. By contrast, CBC basically shows you 90 seconds of ads up front, then lets you watch the rest of the event including skipping around ad free. The NBC app could have used logic like, for every X minutes of program time you watch, you have to watch Y minutes of ads. That would have been okay. But no, the NBC app was basically "we're going to force you to watch these ads" like that episode of Black Mirror. And BTW, this was for the paid NBC networks as I had to pickup a Sony Vue account to watch anything not on the main network. For the main network, I recorded everything on my Tablo from OTA where I could skip around as much as I wanted.
- maxerickson 9y agoComcast owns NBC so will be a common filler ad on NBC whether it makes sense or not.
- ChrisLTD 9y agoAdvertising has invaded nearly every waking hour of our lives. I'm glad there are services like Netflix that can give us some respite.
- marnett 9y agothey have product placement out the wazoo, don't think otherwise.
- thewarrior 9y agoExamples ?
- ceejayoz 9y agoWe've cut the cord, and it's really remarkable when visiting relatives just how frustrating TV ads are to encounter now.
- trentnix 9y agoAnd that constant bombardment has reduced the effectiveness of advertising as well. So it makes sense that advertising dollars would be distributed differently than they once were.
- Kenji 9y agoThat's weird. There's almost no advertising at all in my life. It all depends on how you structure you life.
- 0xfeba 9y agoEveryone and their mother will soon have a streaming service. I predict eventually there will be some streaming conglomerate to allow you to pick and choose streaming providers (Netflix, Hulu, NBC, etc.) with a single sign-on. Right before they package them up as bundles, and we have Cable Company 2.0.
- ams6110 9y agoI don't see the value-add there. We already have the common viewer (the browser) and oauth single-sign-on is already widespread -- we don't need a Comcast or any other conglomerate to do that.
- time0ut 9y agoA single monthly bill and maybe a small bulk discount could entice me.
- majormajor 9y agoNot having to switch between apps for different shows would be very nice. And yes, I'm literally reinventing the cable "guide" experience with silo'd channels. Apple and others are trying to do this their own way, but nobody has something exhaustive that I know of.
- jasonlotito 9y agoVRV.co does this for a number of online streaming services that have their own apps and content. The cost is much lower than subscribing to each service on its own. The value-add is convenience in having a single app to deal with on multiple devices, a single login to deal with, a single payment that is fairly cheap when compared to everything individually.
- time0ut 9y agoThank you. This is really great. I think my wife will be very interested in the content they have.
- googletron 9y agostart advertising through https://brave.com https://brave.com
- doubt_me 9y agoCan't install umatrix or uorigin. Nope.
- ams6110 9y agoIncidentally I'm pretty annoyed that Amazon has started running promos for other content in front of the content I selected. I pay for Prime, I don't want to see ads. Even Amazon's.
- firloop 9y agoHBO has done this for a long time on their streaming service as well, which is maybe why Amazon thinks they can get away with it. Super annoying.
- ibdf 9y agoI agree. I think they can get away with it because Prime is more than just Amazon Videos.
- blktiger 9y agoAt least you can skip these ads.
- munk-a 9y agoWhy do I need to intervene to avoid the crap you're throwing at me? More precisely, if you threw a water balloon at someone's computer in the office, does the fact that they could have moved their computer make it so that the water balloon throwing never happened?
- behrlich 9y agoI've never encountered one of these that wasn't immediately skippable.
- lordnacho 9y agoIf you have kids they often don't understand that, or they don't quite have the motor skills to click the tiny little "skip" area.
- stephengillie 9y agoDo you not wander around your apartment, performing other tasks, while watching shows? It's difficult to skip an ad when your hands are full of pancake batter - or when you're standing across the room, to have a smoke out the window.
- freeGuerrilla 9y agoNow advertising will inevitably saturate online content, I am looking at you YouTube
- lowmagnet 9y agoThis is really the only reason I have a play/red subscription. Of course, this doesn't stop YouTubers from placing sponsored messages everywhere.
- crysin 9y agoYouTubers get a lot more money for their product placements than they do for their views. Hell, almost universally all the Tech tubers did promos for Dyson's new battery powered vacuum. YouTubers don't get a direct benefit for you being a Red member, they're not salaried, and I'd hazard a guess that there are a signifigant fewer amount of Red subscribers than there are subscribers who just use adblocks. Personally no matter the amount of content YouTubers put out I could never justify myself paying YouTube directly for the privilege of not having to use an adblocker on their site.
- 2474 9y agoI don't watch much TV or streaming services but I do appreciate a funny advertisement[1] when I see it. Granted it never makes me want to purchase the product. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TaldfjkrHy4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TaldfjkrHy4 Yes, I have childish humor.
- sharkweek 9y agoPlenty of data shows people will pay more to avoid ads (https://exstreamist.com/poll-79-of-netflix-subscribers-would-rather-pay-more-than-see-ads/ https://exstreamist.com/poll-79-of-netflix-subscribers-would...) Anecdotally, the $4 more a month I pay Hulu for an ad-free version of their streaming service is the easiest money I spend on any entertainment.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoI wonder if Netflix or Amazon prime will try to introduce advertising. I notice that they are sometimes inserting ads in the beginning of a movie/episode, but so far only to promote their new show offerings.
- lambda_lover 9y agoIt's only a matter of time before it's needed to maintain revenue growth...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- otakucode 9y agoThank goodness. We have the Internet. Distribution of content is no longer a task worth a kings ransom. A clever 12 year old can do it in their spare time. These 'professionals' who fall on their face time and time again trying to resurrect their antiquated system which is based solely on the difficulty of getting content from A to B should have been eliminated a decade or two ago. Let us see how well they like capitalism now.
- chomp 9y ago>Even marquee cable TV shows like The Walking Dead are having trouble holding onto viewers. You can't cite that, The Walking Dead has story and writing problems outside of general TV viewership declines. I really hate advertising. There's a lot of investment in human psychology, and I sometimes find myself being seduced by a piece of advertising. They really know how to push my buttons. It's insidious. Even news articles have paid content. Paid placement for TV and movies (Netflix is not immune to this). It's everywhere, and impossible to escape.
- munk-a 9y agoFor me the most revolting evolution of advertisement was when paid content made it's way into the content of articles, i.e. "The Circular investigates which brand of laundry detergent is best for getting out that wine stain" But I think down the road a bit we'll find out how much advertising has cost us as a society in terms of lost efficiency, it's an externality just like dumping waste into a public water source except the water source is our brain's attention span.
- mohaba 9y agoGood. I was long tired of paying to be advertised to.
- knightofmars 9y agoThis is all my opinion, I've never understood cable television. You are paying for someone to provide you with advertisements. Sure, you get a lot of channels and content but how many channels does the average person watch and how often are you just turning on "something" to have on? I've never paid for cable but as soon as Netflix DVD delivery came along I was on board and haven't looked back. Going back to watching television with advertisements is akin to nails on a chalkboard now. Which is odd because I still use free Pandora and have no problems whatsoever with their advertising.
- wvenable 9y agoIf you're paying for Internet, you're paying for someone to provide with you advertisements in exactly the same way. Cable is merely the delivery method -- the networks and stations themselves are providing the content separately and using advertising to fund it. If you pay for premium cable channels like HBO then you're actually contributing your money to the production of advertisement-free content.
- staplers 9y agoExcept Cable is purely an entertainment-consumption medium. Whereas the internet provides tools and services vastly beyond entertainment including creation of content, goods, and services. The value-cost ratio is absurdly better on the internet.
- wvenable 9y agoThat's just progress. At the time cable was deployed, the value-cost ratio was quite a bit better. For many people the Internet is deployed to them on the very same cables that were originally laid just for television. A lot of people have cable because they've always had cable and now there's a generation of people coming up who've never had it.
- munk-a 9y agoIt is (or was, I haven't checked recently) very difficult to actually just pay for HBO. I had wanted to get a subscription for a few different shows they offer and every way to get access to them involved paying for cable channel bundles. I assume cable companies are shoveling money at HBO as fast as they can manage as otherwise it'd be a wise idea for HBO to just begin offering ala carte access to their content and get oodles of free money.
- upofadown 9y agoThe lack of a change is the surprising thing here. The article could as easily spun it as "TV advertising holding steady in the face of streaming".
- milofeynman 9y agoThis is only going to increase the cable companies attempts to add more Netflix-taxes to your internet bill. Comcast started it with their bandwidth soft-caps, with $10 per 100gb over 1TB (it was originally 300gb). I'm lucky to be on an isp that doesn't have a cap right now, but I'm sure it's in the pipeline as cable subscriptions fall and advertising dollars decline.
- farresito 9y agoThanks god. Fuck those guys, seriously.
- oflannabhra 9y agoOnce the Great Unbundling Event of the 2010s completes, I look forward to the Great Rebundling Event of the 2020s to begin. But seriously, cable actually did solve a lot of problems. I've never paid for a cable TV subscription, but having to manage multiple services individually is not an ideal solution, either.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAt some point Netflix will realize that there is money in selling ads and soon Netflix will look like cable TV. It's just a matter of time.
- Freak_NL 9y agoOnly if its competitors all do this too, and no new competition can fill the gap. Their current business model is profitable, so why resort to something that can only cost you users and risks your current market leader position?
- oflannabhra 9y agoExcept Netflix isn't a bundle.
- munk-a 9y agoThis will happen when all the smart people have moved on and only the less intelligent sales people and accountants are left. It definitely will happen eventually but then a great ship-jumping will commence again. I am paying Netflix to provide a service for me, I will stop paying Netflix if that service includes shoving an advertising pipe directly into my brain.
- johnmarcus 9y agoNetflix content has gotten so f&ing boring I'm likely going to cancel my account soon. I'm tired of 500 shows season 1&2. Would much rather prefer 100 shows with season 1-4+. At this point, it's clear they have recruited Hollywoods most seasoned producers, and with it, all the garbage that was already being produced.
- wetpaws 9y agoBased on their revenue I'm pretty sure they know what are they doing
- pkulak 9y agoI recently switched my family's main TV over from using the OS on the TV (WebOS, pretty good actually, which is why we used it this long) back to good ol' Roku. My youngest heard about this and burst into tears for a good 20 minutes. Turns out, he thought "Roku" was DirectTV, which his grandparents have. He was sobbing about how on "Roku" shows keep stopping in the middle (ads, I assume), if you turn off the TV the show doesn't stop, and that if you don't watch a show in time, you have to wait weeks to watch it again. Once I got everything powered up and he saw Netflix, Amazon, et all, he was just fine again.
- soared 9y agoThe "downside" to this is that advertising will switch from the old tv model (buying ads based on which show they'll air during) to buying ads in the internet-way (all the creepy facebook targeting, etc). I'm already managing three of these campaigns, using third party data to buy tv commercials on devices like roku and smart tv apps. So it doesn't matter what show the ad airs on because its targeted to the user (household) who is watching the show. Its around 5-10x more expensive than normal online video ads right now, but 50x cheaper than normal tv ads. Plus you can actually prove someone made a purchase after seeing an ad. This is called advanced tv or connected ctv (atv, ctv) if you're looking for more info. Streaming on a pc/mobile is called full episode player (fep) and is similar.
- thrillgore 9y agoRight now, a third of the TV ads I will see on broadcast are political ads for a candidate that praises the leadership of President Trump. On YouTube, I get ads for the "non-profit" Prager University, which is just full of bullshit. I personally love that Netflix doesn't have any advertisments, especially polarizing ones.
- jasonlotito 9y agoFor YouTube, YouTube Red has been wonderful. No ads at all. At least they have the option.