3 ms·
That's true, but if you type and distribute a book that happens to match the latest Harry Potter, nobody - including the courts - will believe you independently
by icebraining 9y ago
That's true, but if you type and distribute a book that happens to match the latest Harry Potter, nobody - including the courts - will believe you independently came up with that exact sequence of words.
Similarly, if you copy the definitions of all functions/methods/classes/etc from one API, nobody will believe you independently came up with it.
- chii 9y agoEven if the methods and functions are so basic as to not have variations?
- icebraining 9y agoIt's hard to tell about APIs, since there's no caselaw, but the rule for texts is that the smaller they are, the more original they have to be to qualify for copyright protection - so conversely, the sheer length of a work makes it more likely to be protected even if it's not that original. So "add(a, b) returning the sum of the two" is probably not copyrightable by itself, but a whole namespace full of functions might be.
- lmm 9y agoNo. But the court explicitly looked at that and said that there was enough creativity in the choice of what names to give methods and how to group methods that the Java API qualifies as a creative work (and I don't think anyone would really dispute that).