4 ms·
>was it a mistake to be so helpful to the Chinese 1970s- now? Yes Mr. Kissinger and Mr. Nixon misunderstood crucial things about China. Sino-Soviet split was
by baybal2 9y ago
>was it a mistake to be so helpful to the Chinese 1970s- now?
Yes
Mr. Kissinger and Mr. Nixon misunderstood crucial things about China.
Sino-Soviet split was not such. Rather than an imagined existential struggle, it is better to say it was a family squabble; like newlyweds trying to figure out who is a top dog in a family. Rather than splitting the Eastern Bloc, they just gave Chinese a much bigger advantage in negotiations with Soviets. A proof of that is USSR giving Chinese not something, but a NUKE, a jet engine tech, tanks, AA and ground to air missiles (!), and truckloads of resources looong into the split.
Mr. Nixon and Mr. Kissinger were tricked by Chinese.
If you doubt so, read excepts from Kissinger's biography about his thoughts at the moment of US-Mao deal. He was completely oblivious of all aforementioned.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe sino Soviet split was real, and could have easily escalated into a shooting war (and actually was one in Vietnam by proxy) beyond a few border scruffles. China making overtures to the USA was a matter of survival to them as they thought at the time.
- baybal2 9y agoI will parry this argument by saying that to Mao and Deng, just as to Soviets, "expending" few battalions worth of loyal soldiers is nothing more serious than just a play. When Mao sent his troops to Zhenbao, he forbade them from both advancing into Soviet territory, and falling back. He ordered to execute any soldier who disobeyed. That was his idea from the beginning to make it a show tantrum. Relations and trade in between Soviets and Mao continued well after Zhenbao, and there are living witnesses to that on both sides.
- classicsnoot 9y agoFWIW they totally duked it out in the Northern/Mongolian region. But they kept it quiet so we all forget. China also pushed heavily into India during the Cuban Missile Crisis.
- opportune 9y agoTrue but the China of today is different from China of the cold war. You're right in that USSR and China were definitely closer together then than China and the US are now, no doubt about it. But you have to consider that, as far as we can tell, there's no threat of looming war between China and the US, so in the short term we're ok. In the long term, I think the Chinese are becoming more Western/liberal in terms of attitudes. They like capitalism, they like international brands, and as more and more people travel between China and the US for immigration/business/education they'll be more exposed to Western liberalism too. And consider this too: in 20-30 years, the business and political leadership of China will probably only barely remember the Communist days. Perhaps we were "tricked" in the sense that we were overly trusting or congenial, but if you look at US-Chinese relations over a longer timespan, I think it looks like our attitudes will pay off. I see things improving between our two countries, despite China's current attempts at backyard imperialism.
- fspeech 9y agoYour time line is off. USSR assistance to China on nuclear weapons happened before the split. The rest happened after USSR fell and Russia sold the weapons because they were economically needy.
- baybal2 9y agoNo, please check the precise timing. Even with first relations over the nuke were happening before the split, last pieces were delivered to China well after that. Jet engine tech was given to China at the very peak of the "split" and ground to air missile tech just a year after Nixon's visit, which means they got it almost as soon as Soviet did themselves. Why would Soviets ship a supersecret, vital, wunderwaffe defence tech to an enemy? And as for living witnesses of trains full of coal going into China. There are thousands of people in cities of Manzhouli and Zabaikalsk saw that with their own eyes, and being very puzzled by that. China never had any issue with coal supply whatsoever, it has world's biggest coal reserves. The presumption is that those wagons with coal were just a cover for Soviets to deliver China the defence tech covertly.
- fspeech 9y agoUSSR exported their SAMs to China starting in 1950s. They had a mutual defense treaty before the split. The treaty did not end the moment fissures started to appear. I can't find any report on the defense tech exports to China well after the split. If you have references please share. Keep in mind that even now Russia sells rocket engines to the US.