6 ms·
Relativity Space raises $35M for a new process to build and fly rockets
- baybal2 9y agoWell, they do that 3D printing thing. I do not believe this delivering much of economic gain.
- nugi 9y agoIt would seem that way from a casual glance, but rocket piping is quite complex, and currently assembled from hundreds or thousands of segments. Being able to print such assemblies will permit faster, lighter production, and production of shapes currently infeasible to cast/assemble. It could be dramatic, or slight. The key will likely be implementing a scaling strategy and qc.
- baybal2 9y agoSee, an R7 family launch vehicles - complete dinosaurs. Both complex, and lengthy to assemble, in addition to having monstrously complex launch sequence. What you say about that is totally true. But there is a big BUT - being complex does not preclude them being produced like sausages with big enough manufacturing complex, big and competent labour force, and very good rigid procedures perfected over 60 years. In comparison to the cost of the whole space program, launch vehicle costs are almost microscopic. Every rocket is a project, not a product. Every rocket launch is not a service, it is also effectively a project. And it was an achievement of the crippled post-Soviet space industry in making launch vehicles and launches more close to being a product and a service. Prior to that, a commercial satellite launch was hard to do without spending an eternity doing talkshops with likes of Boeing, Lockheed or French government. When ex-Soviet rockets popped up on the market, procuring a satellite launch service turned, figuratively, into a grocery shopping.
- ricardobeat 9y agoCosts are far from “microscopic” for commercial entities.
- gnode 9y ago> produced like sausages I think the trend may well go in the other direction, and become more like shipbuilding. Due to reusability, we can afford to make costlier rockets, as they're useful for many launches. This may for instance mean the use of relatively expensive composite materials, such as in the BFR, which prioritises fuel cost above unit cost. Also, the efficiency of rockets generally increases with size.
- Robotbeat 9y agoHonestly, large-scale composites are actually cheaper per unit dry mass than metal 3D printed parts. Composites may be more finicky, but they're not necessarily more expensive in aerospace! Carbon fiber composites are more expensive than stamped metal parts like automobile bodies, but if you're talking CNC machined or 3D printed metal parts, then carbon fiber can indeed be cheaper.
- cryptoz 9y agoInteresting news. All this newspace startup competition in the rocket launch industry is huge. One concern: > The Terran booster will hit what the company believes is a sweet spot between smaller rockets under development by Rocket Lab (and others) and the much larger Falcon 9 built by SpaceX. The market is moving very quickly right now. I'm not sure the Falcon 9 will even be flying by the time this launches. Maybe that will mean more opportunity for them, it is hard to say. But it seems to me that all these small-rocket companies are banking on one specific idea: that the convenience or dedicated customer service they provide will exceed the pros of going with a more established low-cost provider like SpaceX. With BFR flying regularly in the same timeframe as this rocket gets its first launch, their only hope is that customers will not want to ride along as a 90th payload in a BFR but will want a dedicated ride themselves. Or perhaps I am being close minded, perhaps the market will grow sufficiently such that SpaceX will not even be able to suck up all the new launches and new demand, and the small-rocket companies will thrive. I just don't want to see them left in the dust. A $10M price tag is incredible (I mean, wow, that's low! for a dedicated launch!). But will that be the expensive option by the time their rocket is ready for use? Two concerns, it turns out. Will these rockets be reusable? I'm guessing not, since the article didn't mention it and these days in the rocket world, if you're not reusable, then who cares? You will be left in the dust. Edit: Wait a minute. I just went to their website. It says nothing about reusability either. But it exclaims how great it would be to build and fly rockets in days instead of years. Are they very specifically making a disposable rocket? If so, fuck this company and fuck everything about it. It's not the way of the future to build large objects and throw them away. It's evil in fact, to research something like this in the modern era with an attitude of 'fuck you' to the materials' sources where they are mined from the Earth. I'll hold off on an actual opinion until I know more. But I sure hope Y Combinator didn't invest in a fake-new-space-actually-oldspace company. I hope this is better than it looks because it looks awful. Edit 2: What does the success case of this startup look like? Will they ever research reusability? Or are they aiming to make 1,000 new rockets per year? That's the success case based on the financials (=$10B revenue/year) and it sounds gross. Without reusable rockets that whole thing is extremely wasteful. The efficiencies of 3D printing things quickly are not correctly accounted for in the loss that the planet takes due to increased mining and wasteful dumping that would have to occur (and which the investors and company do not pay for).
- njarboe 9y agoI thought at first the fact that reuseablity is not mentioned as one of their goals was a big problem with their business plan. If the Falcon 9 Block 5 really becomes highly reusable, according to Elon Musk's criteria, SpaceX will be able to scale up launch rates and scale down prices that, by the time this rocket is available (2021 stated, delays likely), it won't be able to compete on price. I was thinking, "The more people working on different rockets the better. Hope it works out for them in that niche." But going to their website[1] this launch market does not seem to be the company's main focus. They want to develop the technology to build currently very complicated objects with two orders of magnitude lower parts count. This is desired so that the products can be more easily built on Mars. I can see that as a long term profitable outcome with applications on Earth along the way. From their mission statement[2]: In the early days of settlement, there will be few people living on Mars. Intelligent automation and lightweight, compact 3D printing are fundamental technologies needed to quickly build a new society with scarce resources - and the most scalable means to get back home. An ambitious goal (with an incongruous phrase tacked on the end??). [1]https://www.relativityspace.com/home https://www.relativityspace.com/home [2]https://www.relativityspace.com/mission/ https://www.relativityspace.com/mission/
- gnode 9y agoWith relatively cheap transport to Mars (due to reusable launch), I don't see why building rockets there would make more sense than bringing them from Earth, i.e. returning them to Earth. Furthermore, to develop rockets on Mars you'd also need a substantial supporting industry (metallurgy, testing, etc.).
- njarboe 9y agoI would guess the goal is a self-sustaining civilization on Mars, a la Musk. People there will want to build as many things locally as they can. Ground transportation, energy sources, habitats, rockets, etc. Most of the parameters of Mars can be simulated on Earth but there is a big one that can't be simulated: 1/3 gravity. Iterating development on Mars for Mars will have large advantages over building things on Earth for Mars, long shipment to Mars, testing on Mars, build next version on Earth, ship to Mars, etc. Plus simulated Mars environments will not be perfect. With this tech they are hoping to drop the need for supporting industry for making stuff substantially.
- madengr 9y agoEngine parts I can see, but is there some inherent advantage to 3D printing the vehicle parts? Seems more hype.
- ricardobeat 9y agoComplete printing of our rocket, Terran 1, reduces vehicle part count from nearly 100,000 to under 1,000 components - and is the first step toward an entirely autonomous factory They also mention a turnaround of _days_ for a full rocket, and being able to manufacture in Mars. More info at their website: http://www.relativityspace.com http://www.relativityspace.com
- Gravityloss 9y agoAFAIK one can't get something that competes with high strength carbon fiber tanks made in a 3D printer. You need continuous long fiber placement, the opposite of "a little material here and there" 3D printing. Now, printing might work for some other materials than carbon with similar or even higher strength to weight ratio. But AFAIK unproven so far. Would be a whole separate science project with lots of other applications than rockets. Also, looks like the engine had some machining work done, maybe after the laser sintering aka 3D printing part, since the surface was smooth and shiny.
- gnode 9y agoLarge carbon fibre tanks are arguably 3D printed. They're made with a CNC machine that winds carbon fibre tow onto the tank. A larger challenge would probably be to cheaply produce the raw carbon fibre on Mars.
- Gravityloss 9y agoThat's a winding machine, not a 3D printer. But yes, if that's what's meant, it's completely a no brainer. Nobody's hand winding tanks or airliner fuselages.
- erdle 9y agoAre there any environmental impacts re rocket launches?
- fudged71 9y agoYou mean besides atmosphere and ionosphere?
- monochromatic 9y agoThey perturb earth’s orbit in a way that will become evident in a million or so years.
- marcosdumay 9y agoThe Earth has 5e24 kg. A 1e4kg rocket going at 7e3m/s is going to cause something around 1e-17m/s change in velocity. And that's considering that Earth receive all the momentum from the rocket's exhaust, what isn't true. You'll need way too many rockets to cause an even measurable change on Earth's orbit in a million years. Try changing it to a few billions.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoFrom a purely pedestrian point of view the hype video[0] on their site got me really excited. Challenges aside it blows my mind that humanity is doing research and prototypes like this today. I'm excited about the future again. 0: https://vimeo.com/260505466 https://vimeo.com/260505466