8 ms·
I was mostly agreeing with the article until this part: "His medallion, once worth $1.1 million, had plummeted in value to $180,000. The dramatic drop in the v
by gambiting 9y ago
I was mostly agreeing with the article until this part:
"His medallion, once worth $1.1 million, had plummeted in value to $180,000. The dramatic drop in the value of the medallion, which he had hoped to lease for $3,000 a month or sell to finance his retirement, wiped out his economic security. He faced financial ruin and poverty. And he was not alone."
The medalions are stupid and shouldn't exist. Relying on their "value" for retirement is crazy. And like another commenter has said - if it was worth 1.1 million, why not sell it and retire, perhaps doing a less stressful job than driving a taxi for 12 hours in turns with your wife? It sounds like he gambled - that he could keep working, keep the medallion, and retire while leasing the medallion for $3000/month(!!!!!!!!!!) - and like all gambles, this one had a possibility of failing - and it did.
- LoSboccacc 9y agomedallions may have had sense but as a state regulated monopoly should never have had been transferable in the first place and should have had a (reasonably long) time limit on top of it.
- refurb 9y agoTo be honest, I actually feel bad for medallion owners, even if the medallion system is a bad one. The gov't sets ups a system, tells you the rules and says "if you buy an expensive medallion, you can drive a cab and make a living". The value of the medallion is purely based on the gov't promise to maintain the system. So you buy one (or many) and a few years later someone does a work around and the gov't says "oh well, I'm not going to try to enforce the medallion system any more." That sucks.
- adventured 9y ago> The value of the medallion is purely based on the gov't promise to maintain the system. There was never a government promise or guarantee to maintain the system as was. There was nothing more than a hope that they would. How is that any better than building your business around assuming Google was never going to change or improve their search algorithms pre Panda/Penguin? Or betting on newspaper classified ads never going away. Or a thousand other examples like that from the last century. One of the more common requirements of staying in business, is managing to adapt with change. The only alternative is for the government to try to freeze technological progress for the benefit of a few and at the expense of the many. Except that's impossible, the rest of the global economy will destroy you, leaving you in the stone age.
- huffmsa 9y agoYes, it's purely based on artificial scarcity. Which historical never lasts. PanAm went bust because they banked on price fixed airline tickets. USPS benefited from national mail logistics only being available to government level endeavors. DeBeers is about to get crushed by artificial diamonds which are both cheaper and "better diamonds" than the massive stockpile they've accumulated. The rocket industry has long labored under the delusion that massive government contracts underwriting their $100m launch prices keep them safe. But their bubble is popping one $60m Falcon 9 launch at a time. And finally, the government will support whatever brings in the most taxes and f̶r̶e̶e̶ ̶s̶p̶e̶c̶i̶a̶l̶-̶i̶n̶t̶e̶r̶e̶s̶t̶ lobbyist dinners.
- rhino369 9y agoDeBeers already got crushed by Canadian mines. Their cartel fell apart 10+ years ago.
- huffmsa 9y agoWell then said Canadian mine owners had better buckle up.
- rwc 9y agoLobbyist dinners are low on a politician's list, particularly because at the federal level ethics rules have become so ridiculous about what elected officials and staff can accept as gifts. Much more interesting to a politician is supporting the policies of well-organized trade/association groups that have the power, through their PACs or membership, to invest the resources necessary to make a difference in a campaign.
- huffmsa 9y agoDinners was a joking metaphor for organized support.
- eeZah7Ux 9y ago> it's purely based on artificial scarcity. Which historical never lasts. Never? Money are based on artificial scarcity as well.
- prepend 9y agoIt does suck. This happens quite a bit with land rezoning. Where a govt change to a long designation increases or lower value. For land rezoning, the property owner can be compensated (https://finance-commerce.com/2011/08/lost-real-estate-value-at-issue-in-zoning-cases/ https://finance-commerce.com/2011/08/lost-real-estate-value-...). With Uber it’s a bit different as rideshare is different than hailed cab, so the city didn’t actually take an action that resulted in value.
- lr4444lr 9y agoThere are reportedly about 14,000 medallions. At $1,000,000 a pop, it would not be too terrible to have a one-time buyout paid over several years as a compromise to ending the system.
- mikepurvis 9y agoMaybe, but I can think of better ways to spend $14B.
- 345655433 9y agoShould we also give $1m to everyone who used to work in coalmining, steel puddling, and manufacture? Or is there something special about taxi drivers?
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoExcept that I'm sure there's been a lot of rich people investing into these things and generating artificial scarcity. It's not been the individual taxi drivers that owned these things for a long time; they're leased out for ridiculous amounts of money.
- lr4444lr 9y agoIt's a mix. Some wealthier enterprising people consolidated many, and others were cabbies who saved up and took out loans to finance a single medallion. Another way we might handle this is just to convince these people to cut their losses and default - the banks should have better weighed the risk of deregulation - and give the cabbies themselves reimbursement up to some fixed amount (under $10K) for the inconvenience of reregistering themselves with rideshares, or any livery cab companies.
- MrFantastic 9y agoPaid by whom? We only bail out bankers.
- rch 9y agoIt's the same with mineral rights in proximity to residential housing. The system needs to adapt over time, and it is reasonable to expect people to accommodate changes as they become necessary.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- privacypoller 9y agoIn a loose sense this seems to be what's happening with fiat money and cryptocurrencies.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoYup, in this case I'd be inclined that on the one side, the government dropped the ball by not banning Uber / "black market taxis" outright; on the other, they created artificial scarcity with the medallion system, creating a trade product that only the super rich could afford to own, which they could in turn lease out to make a profit over decades. I can see why they needed the system though, to prevent a flooding of taxi drivers. And they were proven right, because now with gig economy drivers, the floodgates have been opened and the market has been flooded with drivers in a race to the bottom. Probably also because for a lot of people there's no other work. This is in part because of the local economy, and in part by the US education system, which is (from an outsider's perspective) a system that ensures highly educated / rich families stay rich, and prevents social mobility - unless someone expresses some special ability and gets a scholarship, probably from a commercial party e.g. sports.
- Bartweiss 9y ago> I can see why they needed the system though, to prevent a flooding of taxi drivers. And they were proven right, because now with gig economy drivers, the floodgates have been opened and the market has been flooded with drivers in a race to the bottom. I'm not convinced this is true, except in the short term. Plenty of service industries maintain a reasonable number of providers, and many even pay reasonable wages to a lot of those providers. Uber flooded the market as part of an attempt to break through artificial scarcity; they needed on-demand service to attract customers, and massive scale to fight regulators. And they got their flood of drivers by burning VC money to ensure that the basic "rider -> driver" transaction happens at unsustainably low prices. So what we're seeing isn't a race to the bottom - it's a race to well below the bottom. Uber rides can't stay so cheap forever; either prices go up and riders leave, or prices stay low and drivers leave. The taxi/driver market in Cleveland or Omaha isn't going to be destroyed by a lack of artificial scarcity. There is a secondary problem, where even rational markets for services don't function in expensive cities. It may be that rides normal people can afford simply aren't viable in NYC or SF. But that's not a problem with market rates, it's a problem with housing prices that make lots of totally normal jobs unlivable.
- 9y ago
- MrFantastic 9y agoRent Seeking sometimes creates losers.
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoYes - this reminds me of my state where there is a requirement that between bars and breweries there has to be a middle man that resells the booze, because its safer or something stupid. The middle man is enshrined in law. When we wanted to change the state liquor laws, the middle men said I should always be here in the middle, it's my right. That really made me angry.
- MrFantastic 9y agoThe middle man uses his free $peech to speak to the local politicians.
- Bartweiss 9y agoYep - I really don't understand the failure of sympathy towards cab drivers themselves. Was the medallion system bad? Yes. Creating good jobs by enforcing random scarcity in a handful of markets is a ridiculous system. But the people who bought these medallions didn't implement that system - they wanted to provide a service, and likely would have driven outside the medallion system if they could. Now they can, but they're broke because they happened to be in business while the government stopped screwing up their industry. They're victims of stupid regulation, not perpetrators.
- adrianN 9y agoIf you have a single asset worth a million dollars and you hope renting it out for 3% of its a value per year, you should immediately sell it and buy a well diversified investment portfolio instead. You can still sell 3% of your portfolio every year.
- MrFantastic 9y agoThey were buying medallions on leverage with hopes of appreciation.
- CaptainZapp 9y agoWhat about those thousands of Enron employees who lost their life savings because they "gambled" on the fact that their retirement savings will be invested responsibly? I don't think his idea was such a massive gamble when he paid that money for the medallion. You can argue about the system as such. But I don't think his idea was unreasonable.
- troupe 9y agoWho were they trusting to responsibly invest it other than themselves? I thought the people who lost were the ones who had it all invested in Enron. I'm not aware of any financial advisor who would consider this responsibly invested.
- CaptainZapp 9y agoLook up 401K. Which were mostly invested into Enron shares.
- troupe 9y agoI don't know of anyone who advises people to invest all of their 401k funds in a single company. Every piece of reputable financial advice on retirement seems to suggest that you should NOT do that. I'm not trying to minimize their loss or how hard that would be, but if we think people should have the freedom to make decisions on how to invest their retirement money, then we have to accept that some people will invest it all in a company where they will eventually lose it.
- Analemma_ 9y ago> I don't know of anyone who advises people to invest all of their 401k funds in a single company. That is exactly what Enron's in-house financial advisers did. They went to jail for it, but that's cold comfort to the people whose 401k's got wiped out.
- carlmr 9y agoYes, the medallions were stupid, although I think they shouldn't have allowed Uber to operate without medallions, or get rid of the system in general. >Relying on their "value" for retirement is crazy. And like another commenter has said - if it was worth 1.1 million, why not sell it and retire Because he took out a loan of 1.1 million to buy it. It's not that he bought it for next to nothing and it rose to that price, it was always a stable asset. Because regulation didn't allow non-medallion taxis in the city. Until Uber came and they just allowed it. >like all gambles, this one had a possibility of failing - and it did. We're not talking about the smartest people here. Something that had a stable (and slowly rising) value for 100 years didn't seem like a gamble until the lobbyists came in and convinced the lawmakers to allow unfair competition. I think medallions are stupid, but as long as the system exist, everybody needs to adhere by it, otherwise it's just f*ing over the working poor.
- taneq 9y agoExactly, and that's my problem with ride sharing companies like Uber (or rather, with governments letting them operate as unlicenced taxis despite strict regulation of 'real' taxis). The government created an artificial monopoly, sold tickets to operate in that monopoly, and then failed to protect it. Medallions were a stupid idea but that doesn't mean the government should be able to just write them off and screw over the people holding them.
- wooter 9y agoSo it should be able to screw people not holding them? Or those who cant get a $1 Million dollar loan or pay 3k to drive a car? Car leases are easy at $150.
- wjnc 9y agoAny government policy has winners and losers. Literally any. All that's reasonable is that governments act in.good faith and with proper accounting of, say, time horizons. They should have figured out that medallions were unsustainable, what, in the low 100k's? Once it starts working as a pyramid scheme there are only losers from then on... Except the now retired taxi drivers, who banked 1M.
- prepend 9y agoIt also seems like leasing a 1.1M asset for 36k/year is poor retirement planning. 3.2% pre tax won’t ler you live that well. Seems like an odd emotional link. That we’re supposed to support this person’s edge retirement plan by making hailing cabs suck for users. What if someone invested in Exxon. Spent $1.1M and was relying on the dividend yield (4.6% btw-http://www.dividend.com/dividend-stocks/basic-materials/major-integrated-oil-and-gas/xom-exxon-mobil/ http://www.dividend.com/dividend-stocks/basic-materials/majo...). And in twenty years renewables make Exxon tank. Would we feel sympathy? I would, a little as people losing their life’s savings is sad. But investing your whole nest egg in one thing is bad. Investing it in a thing that causes misery is even worse. Investing in a thing with artificial scarcity is further worse. Putting a million into medallions because they’ve risen in value for 80 years is dumb. The article is also disingenuous as there were lots of investment firms buying these. Why only show this one example of a single owner. This guy’s firm owned 500 in 2005, valued at $200M. https://www.nysun.com/business/new-york-citys-biggest-owner-of-taxi-medallions/18240/ https://www.nysun.com/business/new-york-citys-biggest-owner-... This was a $5B market back then if all 13,605 medallions were worth $400k each. These weren’t mostly owned by mom and pop individual owners.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> 3.2% pre tax won’t ler you live that well It also means the medallion yields a paltry 0.11 percentage points more than a 30-year Treasury [1]. Which means one is judging it to be just a tad bit riskier than the U.S. government. And safer than Apple [2]. And Stanford [3]. And MIT [4]. [1] https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/Pages/TextView.aspx?data=yield https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/i... [2] http://finra-markets.morningstar.com/BondCenter/BondDetail.jsp?ticker=C610233&symbol=AAPL4122386 http://finra-markets.morningstar.com/BondCenter/BondDetail.j... [3] http://finra-markets.morningstar.com/BondCenter/BondDetail.jsp?ticker=C14251&symbol=STAN.GG http://finra-markets.morningstar.com/BondCenter/BondDetail.j... [4] http://finra-markets.morningstar.com/BondCenter/BondDetail.jsp?ticker=C555149&symbol=MIT.GC http://finra-markets.morningstar.com/BondCenter/BondDetail.j...
- zombieprocesses 9y ago> It also seems like leasing a 1.1M asset for 36k/year is poor retirement planning. 3.2% pre tax won’t ler you live that well. Maybe he was betting on the price of taxi medallions to increase considerably. > Putting a million into medallions because they’ve risen in value for 80 years is dumb. It's the basis of investing in a lot of assets - like NYC real estate. Limit supply will protect your investment and it will always increase. This is also the basis of dollar cost averaging into an index. The assumption is that the markets/indices will always increase in value over the long term even if it may fluctuate up and down over the short term. > These weren’t mostly owned by mom and pop individual owners. Yep. Regulations and limit supply will do that. Just like most of the farm subsidies benefit the mega corporations, not the small farms.
- fergie 9y agoThere are many good reasons to licence taxi(driver)s, and cap their number. For example: - to keep traffic down - to ensure a minimum standard of vehicle - to ensure safe, well-trained and responsible taxi drivers. - to ensure a fair level of income - etc. However the main problem with the medallion system is that they can be traded, speculated on, and used to extract "rent" from workers further down the chain. This benefits nobody. Surely there could be a happy middle way between the libertarian nightmare, banned-in-half-of-Europe Uber model; and the old-skool union cartel medallion model.
- chrischen 9y agoThe city should auction off the licenses annually. Still rent-seeking, but at least the rent seeking is the city/government.
- zip1234 9y agoI agree that those are reasons for the INTENT behind regulating/licensing taxis. Certainly in the past those things may have been more important. However, with the improved access to information that people now have through their phones it seems a lot less necessary. - to keep traffic down I don't know if limiting taxis actually ends up limiting cars, but limiting cars is certainly the definition of keeping traffic down. - to ensure a minimum standard of vehicle I've actually been surprised but the people driving Uber X usually have nicer vehicles than most taxis I have taken. - to ensure safe, well-trained and responsible taxi drivers. Licensing drivers provides responsible taxi drivers? Yes, tell that to the people that have to pay cash because the credit card machine is 'broken'. - to ensure a fair level of income As far as the fair level of income, taxi companies are taking their cut. How much do the drivers actually end up with?
- MrFantastic 9y agoIn big cities, parking the cars is the major problem. Parking spaces cost $1500+/mo
- spacehome 9y agoNone of your reasons besides keeping traffic down necessitate restricting the number of licenses. And a "fair" wage will be determined by the market.
- chrischen 9y agoI agree the medallion system is stupid, however the reason for them to exist makes sense. They are used to control the supply of Taxis so streets aren't flooded, however cities should be auctioning the licenses rather than selling off one-time rights. If that were the case Taxi startups like Uber may have started their business with compliance by simply bidding for licenses (in theory if they operate more efficiently they could outbid), but instead because of the rent-seeking medallion system a 1.1 million dollar medallion per car would simply be prohibitive to new entrants.
- lr4444lr 9y agoI agree with you about the dysfunction of the medallion system, but it reveals a bigger problem with the article. The medallion is meant to artificially constrain supply. NYCTLC tried and failed to block Uber in order to protect their value, i.e., enforce a closed shop, and this was what the cabbie was upset about - losing his exclusionary license to do business. His complaint could hardly be more ANTI "gig-economy" against Uber's drivers flooding the market, which is what tanked his asset's value.
- rdlecler1 9y agoI was riding in a NY taxi in 2015. The driver owned his medallion since the 80s. He had never heard of Uber. I told him about it and suggested that this was the time to sell. I doubt he did, but the point is, is that this wasn’t an overnight event. Technology and markets change. If they didn’t the next generation would never get their chance.
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoMillions of people rely on their house and stock. If my investments lost 80% of their value, I'd be hurting. But I agree with the larger point that taxi medallions were a terrible idea, artificially limiting the supply made them really expensive and we were paying for that every time we used a taxi of course.
- erik_seaberg 9y agoAnd we have a housing shortage because millions of people bet on that housing shortage and then vote for policies that worsen it.
- emodendroket 9y agoPerhaps so, but we built up a system where that was a retirement plan that made sense and then pulled the rug out from people who were depending on it, and that happened to coincide with the wages for the work plummeting, making it very difficult to pursue an alternate plan.
- speby 9y agoI've got some news for him ... sometimes people invest in their 401Ks and GASP.... when they might want to withdraw from it in retirement, if the country is in the middle of a depression or a recession, guess what? It's worth a fraction of what it once was. Same goes people who bought ridiculously priced homes in the run-up to 2008... Guess what? Thinking that $600,000 3-bedroom home in the desert near Phoenix, AZ was a good retirement vehicle was not a good choice. And to a lesser extent, this is another example, a sad one, of people choosing to avoid diversifying their sources of wealth and income. There's simply too much risk by having ALL of your eggs in a single basket. It's on the one hand easy to sympathize with this case but on the other, I don't think there is anything due him economically.