4 ms·
Arizona did something reckless and stupid. Unfortunately, somebody other than the decision maker paid the price. Arizona stupidly allowed Uber to operate after
by lern_too_spel 9y ago
Arizona did something reckless and stupid. Unfortunately, somebody other than the decision maker paid the price. Arizona stupidly allowed Uber to operate after California kicked Uber out and after seeing the videos of Uber cars running red lights in SF.
For what? For a few temporary (the plan is to be fully autonomous quickly) low paying test driver jobs? The engineers making the big salaries stayed in California (or Pittsburgh in Uber's case).
https://www.google.com/amp/amp.fox10phoenix.com/news/arizona-news/arizona-governor-to-welcome-uber-selfdriving-cars_ https://www.google.com/amp/amp.fox10phoenix.com/news/arizona...
- galdosdi 9y agoThis is what's always confused me. The usual play is to suck up to a corporation in the hopes that a bunch of jobs or other investment will show up, but self-driving testing is kinda a perfect example of something that will not give any economic benefit to the testbed state at all. It takes very little local investment, and it's a temporary thing that will only yield benefit for the corporation doing the testing, and as soon as they have as much data as they want they can leave and use that data anywhere else. And if what Arizona hoped for is to get self driving taxis early, well, other states can simply let the sucker states like Arizona do the testing, then wait to legalize self driving till the day after it proves itself, thus reaping close to 100% of the benefits with close to 0% of the disadvantages. I honestly think Arizona politicians just blundered because they were following the typical playbook out of pure habit. I hope the explanation is not less innocent than that, but that's also very possible. Petty corruption is very common in USA state governments.
- rkuykendall-com 9y agoA very common play is to remove all regulatory requirements for an industry that you know will provide next-to-no jobs at a cost to public safety, because it looks good to Republican voters. See: Coal.
- owenversteeg 9y agoNow, I totally agree with your comment that other states can let Arizona do the testing then reap the rewards. But at the same time, I think there can be other indirect benefits: Arizona getting known for being innovative, for example. Arizona was getting in the news a lot for positive self-driving tech things, and that's great. It's bad that they didn't vet Uber carefully enough and thus a woman died, but the general attitude of encouraging innovation even without direct, immediate benefits is a great thing.
- hueving 9y ago>For what? To advance technology and make AZ attractive to other R&D. Not everything has to be tied to a direct economic boom.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoCalifornia remains the center of autonomous car research and industry with carefully thought out regulation designed with public input. Laissez-faire regulation and rolling out the red carpet for bad actors in Arizona didn't change that. It just led to the predictable result.
- hueving 9y agoCalifornia remains the center because the companies are already headquartered there due to decisions made 50 years ago by the military for radar technology: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo That's despite it's often idiotic regulations driven by populist ignorance. A governance policy in favor of developments of new technology most certainly can have an impact over time. > Laissez-faire regulation and rolling out the red carpet for bad actors in Arizona didn't change that. Oh, red carpet for bad actors? Where is it that Uber is headquartered again? And doesn't Waymo also test in Arizona?
- lern_too_spel 9y ago> California remains the center because the companies are already headquartered there due to decisions made 50 years ago by the military for radar technology: Poor argument. It doesn't explain why the auto industry didn't hire all the self driving car engineers to work in the Midwest or why the communications companies didn't hire them all to work on the East Coast. Google itself has offices all over the world, but it put the Chauffeur team in Mountain View. If you really think that the military industrial complex that started Silicon Valley gives it an insurmountable advantage for building a self driving car company, Arizona's decision to even try to pull them away looks even more stupid. > Oh, red carpet for bad actors? Where is it that Uber is headquartered again? In California, which reaps all the benefits from taxing its highly paid employees without incurring any of the costs of its out-of-control self driving car program, which Arizona's governor welcomed with much fanfare. > And doesn't Waymo also test in Arizona? It does. It also tests extensively in California and has engineered its vehicles to comply with the new California regulations that allow cars on public roads that have no human driver inside. Notably, all the highly paid engineers remain in California, and the advanced testing facility with highly paid testers (unlike the temp workers hired for the public road tests) was built in California too because advanced testing on private facilities is correctly less regulated. Arizona's problem is that it underregulated testing on public roads.
- humanrebar 9y ago> Arizona did something reckless and stupid. Unfortunately, somebody other than the decision maker paid the price. Well, crossing the street in that manner wasn't the smartest thing to do either. The person shouldn't have been run over, but we accept some risks while walking bicycles across multi-lane highways at night without watching for oncoming traffic.
- lemonghost 9y ago> we accept some risks while walking bicycles across multi-lane highways at night without watching for oncoming traffic. The accident occurred on a surface street in a fairly busy area right down the street from ASU's main campus where there tend to be a lot of pedestrians and bikers
- humanrebar 9y agoSure, but every time you cross the street, you assume some risk. That's why little kids hold an adult's hand when they cross. And the risk is even higher if you're crossing the street at night. And it's even higher if you don't have a light, crosswalk, or stop sign to protect you.
- csbrooks 9y agoI used to live in Arizona. The traffic lights and crosswalks are an insane distance apart. There are bright streetlights basically everywhere. All the roads are straight. It's all designed for cars, and not for pedestrians. And it's really tempting to j-walk if you're ever stuck walking somewhere.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoI thought the same thing. Why was she so nonchalant about a car about to hit her? And then I remembered: Pedestrians are simply not afraid enough of cars. They blithely assume the driver can see them, that the driver is a human (!), that the driver wants to avoid hitting them, that the driver has quick reactions, and that the car's brakes are in good working order. Those are a lot of assumptions to bet your life on. It's much safer to cross streets assuming every car is trying to kill you.
- xvf22 9y agoThe police department was also quick to defend Uber by saying that the crash was 'unavoidable'. From the reports it seems like Uber were heavily focused on putting in miles trying to make up ground. The NTSB report will hopefully expose the failures (if any) of the Uber self driving system or the organization. They've said that self driving cars are critical to their survival and if it turns out they cut corners / mis-represented things then it'll be hard for them to get out of that hole.
- stormthebeach 9y agoI find it peculiar that you would quote the police department saying the crash was "unavoidable" when I'm unable to find such distinct phrasing used in any news articles. The most damning phrasing is: "it’s very clear it would have been difficult to avoid this collision in any kind of mode (autonomous or human-driven) based on how she came from the shadows right into the roadway".
- ameister14 9y agohttps://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/tempe/2018/03/20/tempe-police-chief-fatal-uber-crash-pedestrian-likely-unavoidable/442829002/ https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/tempe/2018/03/20/...
- stormthebeach 9y agoSo I've read the article and watched the videos - I haven't seen any actual quotes where any spokesperson had said it was unavoidable outside of the headline and first paraphrased sentence. I only mentioned this initially because it seems like a sensationalized headline of a statement.
- mehrdadn 9y ago"Unavoidable"... I assume for a human. I'm not sure it was unavoidable for an automated car.
- test6554 9y agoThe decision to allow self-driving cars in Arizona is going to save far more lives than it will take. I firmly believe it was a massively good decision. but time will tell.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoYou've misunderstood my statement. California allows self-driving cars and has licensed 50 companies to test them in the state. California didn't allow Uber to operate on public roads because Uber didn't agree to the required oversight. Arizona allowed Uber to operate without reasonable oversight even after seeing videos of Uber autonomous cars running red lights. The result is that it took more lives than it saved, and that outcome was obvious to anybody paying attention.
- bowlich 9y agoI heard Phoenix took quite a big hits in the tech sector in 2008. I live out in the boonies in Arizona, I would say at least if I go off of for recruiter spam, there's been an uptick in engineering positions related to the self driving car companies. Whether those positions are actually real I don't know, never actually replied to them.