6 ms·
Based on what came out of the last few days I don’t think it’s clear at all, I think a human would not have hit the woman. The footage we saw was from a terrib
by MBCook 9y ago
Based on what came out of the last few days I don’t think it’s clear at all, I think a human would not have hit the woman.
The footage we saw was from a terrible dashcam and did not represent how dark the street actually was. Other people who have driven down the street with cameras show it to be perfectly reasonably lit, with streetlights and everything.
Second, the woman was crossing across two lanes, so any driver watching would have already seen her cross the left-hand lane. It’s not like she popped out from behind a tree suddenly. She wasn’t even going that fast.
This seems to be a massive failure of Uber’s system as well as a complete failure of the ‘safety’ driver.
I don’t think anyone’s overreacting. I think they’re under reacting. I think it’s pretty clear over was heavily negligent. There’s no way they don’t get sued. What comes out at trial is going to be up amazing, I think.
I think if this had been a “real” accident that would’ve been almost impossible to avoid, around it WAS impossible to avoid, or one where the human stepped in and it wasn’t good enough… We would be having a discussion we’re like what you’re saying. Maybe if this was what emai I think if this had been a “real“ accident that would’ve been almost impossible to avoid, around it WAS impossible to avoid, or one where the human stepped in and it wasn’t good enough… We would be having a discussion we’re like what you’re saying. Maybe if this was Waymo or one of the other comapnies.
But it looks like the dubious honor of first death by a autonomous car was totally unnecessary and preventable.
- sokoloff 9y agoThe pedestrian also has a significant contribution of negligence to this collision, IMO.
- mjmahone17 9y agoWhy? They crossed a 35 mph (so in Tempe this is a “slow” road) at a corner (unmarked corners are also crosswalks, legally) on a well lit road. Where the car was many seconds away when she started crossing. Would a human driver be deemed at fault in a court of law? Usually not (though in this case, maybe) unless they kept going after the collision, or were under the influence. But that’s because we give human drivers a lot of leeway to kill people. Not because it isn’t their fault.
- bendauphinee 9y agoAs a pedestrian, it's still our responsibility to make sure approaching vehicles are actually stopped before we start crossing. She did not, or she would be alive.
- lutorm 9y agoIt's certainly prudent to do so, and any amount of self-preservation says you should, but is not checking if you're about to be run over actually negligent? Edit: Also, if you as a pedestrian, stand at a 35mph road, at night, and wait for all approaching cars to stop before you start crossing, you will be standing there a very long time indeed.
- sokoloff 9y agoOne legal definition of negligence is A failure to behave with the level of care that someone of ordinary prudence would have exercised under the same circumstances. If you've established that doing so is "certainly prudent", then I think it's reasonable that not doing so is negligent.
- stevesimmons 9y agoAccidents in complex systems usually happen because multiple safeguards have failed. We can agree the pedestrian had some degree of negligence by walking across the road in a less than perfectly safe manner. But the same assessment also applies for Uber, for not reacting to an obstacle that probably should have been detected. The question right now is what degree of negligence does Uber bear...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 9y agoI don't live there, but this article suggests that there is signage for "no pedestrians" at the location where she was struck: https://www.curbed.com/transportation/2018/3/20/17142090/uber-fatal-crash-driverless-pedestrian-safety https://www.curbed.com/transportation/2018/3/20/17142090/ube... This twitter stream suggests the same with more details: https://twitter.com/EricPaulDennis/status/975889922413551616/photo/1 https://twitter.com/EricPaulDennis/status/975889922413551616... It appears to me that they did not cross at a corner, and the corners "nearby" in the references above all have marked crosswalks. If that's the case, I don't see how one could assign 0% negligence to the pedestrian.
- jcranmer 9y agoThis is an example of the strong tendency to blame pedestrians for most to all pedestrian-vehicle collisions. In reality, pedestrians are generally at the bottom of the list for blame, behind even the engineers who designed the roads in the first place. In this situation, there is no evidence that the pedestrian did anything dangerous. She was crossing in what amounts to an unmarked crosswalk. When struck, she was well advanced in her crossing motion, and there's no sign that she stopped or otherwise dallied in the middle of traffic. The dashcam footage indicates a car some distance ahead: it is not unreasonable that she waited for the car to pass, checked that the traffic was clear, and started crossing. If you object to the idea that it's an unmarked crosswalk: the median has a paved surface that has no other apparent purpose than as pedestrian walkways, and is otherwise inaccessible to pedestrians except by crossing the street at that point. I would not be surprised to find out that the crossing time at the light is insufficient for anyone other than a fit adult walking briskly. For someone walking at a much slower gait, it is actually safer to cross at a place with a very ample pedestrian refuge. Indeed, the presence of the no pedestrian signs actually suggests that the crossing point is more useful than the "legal" route, and quite possibly safer too (given the tendency of many DOTs to consider road improvements only on the basis of vehicle efficiency, even to the point of active hostility against pedestrians). If that crossing point is fundamentally dangerous for a pedestrian, it's not the pedestrian that is to be blamed, it's the traffic engineer who built a deathtrap.
- sokoloff 9y ago> If you object to the idea that it's an unmarked crosswalk I do. I've never seen another crosswalk with a "no pedestrians" sign.
- galdosdi 9y agoThat's one point of view, if you're a goodie two shoes who automatically follows and agrees with every law and rule you ever heard of, even if it violates your own basic ethical values. Another point of view is that the state of arizona intentionally hates pedestrians and gratuitously creates roads that put their lives at risk when all they're trying to do is get home from the grocery store or whatever, a perfectly reasonable thing we oughtta all have the right to do without having to walk an extra mile out of our way or whatever. In NYC, which is actually a reasonable jurisdiction in the USA, that dumb fuck Giuliani tried to enforce anti jay walking laws one time in the '90s. You know what happened? NYPD cops went on the record telling the NY Times they planned to intentionally leave their ticket books in their precinct lockers so they had no way of writing such idiotic tickets. Police nullification, you could call it. Guliani immediately backed down and no one in recent memory has tried to do that again in downstate NYS.
- BurningFrog 9y agoI think both these things are true: Something was very wrong with how the Uber car handled this. A human driver might well have avoided hitting the pedestrian, but would not have had any legal trouble if they did.