5 ms·
I would love to see Tesla demonstrate that their Superchargers are anywhere near super enough. A couple days ago, I supercharged at the “120 kW” Tesla factory i
by amluto 9y ago
I would love to see Tesla demonstrate that their Superchargers are anywhere near super enough. A couple days ago, I supercharged at the “120 kW” Tesla factory in Fremont. For quite a few minutes, I got 23kW. After a while, it went up to 50kW or so. I checked the other car sharing my charger, and the total was well under 120kW. I suspect the station has an overall power limit. Also, there was a line.
For trucks, you need something like a megawatt to recharge on a lunch break, and a line blows the whole thing up.
- beisner 9y agoSolar. Freakin. Roadways.
- freehunter 9y agoHave you seen the roads through most of the country? We can't keep tar and stone in decent condition, no way we'd keep those solar panels running.
- beisner 9y agoOf course, it was a reference to a viral video a few years back with the same title. A joke, if you will.
- matte_black 9y agoWould have been a hit on Reddit.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThese are like two different problems, though probably compounding. Allowing vehicle charging while moving is an interesting problem, regardless of where the power comes from (well, it’s way easier if it’s attsched to the truck).
- notatoad 9y agoI don't think the solar road is meant to charge the cars while driving, it's just a place to install solar panels.
- ams6110 9y agoElectric semis for true long haul will never be viable unless there is a major breakthrough in battery tech. 300 gallons of diesel fuel has so much more energy than even the best batteries could pack into a reasonable size and weight.
- KillerRabbitt 9y agoMajor breakthroughs in autonomous driving may change that. If drivers are eliminated, the costs of waiting 30-60 minutes while charging becomes almost 0.
- hughes 9y agoEspecially if the truck can hand off its payload to a fully charged & waiting replacement cab. If you have access to a fleet or don't need the same truck back, it becomes more of a baton relay than a marathon.
- TillE 9y agoWith the kind of infrastructure required for that, I can't help but think it would just be a lousy version of an electric railway. At least for long hauls with high throughput.
- colordrops 9y agoThat's like saying that circuit switched networks are better than packet switched.
- amluto 9y agoThey would be if packets had enormous per-packet overhead.
- Gibbon1 9y agoAt some point you start wondering about improving intermodal transportation. Using rail for longer distances with trucks handling the last 50-100 miles.
- JshWright 9y agoI believe the superchargers use on-site batteries to buffer demand to the grid. Perhaps the local battery was depleted, so they backed off charge rates to avoid hitting the grid too hard.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoSome do, some don’t. Usually only where Tesla is charged demand charges for peaks by the utility.
- amluto 9y agoAs far as I know, none do. The big one in Gilroy has a big battery pack that seems to sell storage and VARs to the grid. In CA, basically every commercial rate structure includes peak demand charges.
- paranoidrobot 9y agoCharge rate is variable based on a huge number of factors, not all of which you can see. It also doesn't charge at the full 120kW the whole time. Some of the factors that can affect it: - Whether someone is sharing your charger (iirc every two bays share the same backend infrastructure) - If you are sharing the charger, then who was plugged in first (the second person to plug in will receive lower priority) - The State of Charge of the battery pack (the closer to the high/low extremes of charge the slower it will charge) - Temperature of the battery pack - Condition of the pack - Whether there are any restrictions on the pack (some packs if they are supercharged a lot will have caps placed on the charge rate) I imagine with the 'Megacharger' infrastructure given the sheer amount of power needed, they'll have dedicated infrastructure for the entire bay.
- vvanders 9y agoYup, you're also dealing with companies that may have fixed routes and the capital to develop the infrastructure if it makes financial sense. Your average consumer isn't going to drop $X0,000 to put in a super/mega-charger but a business might.
- amluto 9y agoTry telling a trucker that their truck didn't finish charging because of complicated reasons.
- Jesus_Jones 9y ago1. tesla superchargers share a the 'bank of chargers' at 2 spots. look for 2a, 2b, those two spots are shared. pick one that doesn't have a paired spot in use 2. they charger at a higher rate when your car has a lower charge. 3. they cool the battery when charging to prevent harm, if its really hot this can lower charge ability. there's a similar thing with cold temps They are reliable and predictable with those factors. There is already extensive discussion of how to charge higher power systems like trucks, tesla has a plan, google for details. the easiest thing is just several superchargers together. by the way, a supercharger spot is just a bank of regular chargers working together, feeding dc directly to your car's battery. its not magic, it's all pretty easy to understand once you get some basic info.
- greglindahl 9y agoThe Fremont factory supercharger has always been the worst one in the network. Be social with some owners, you'll be surprised what you might find out.