5 ms·
You're missing the point. The 'frugal culture' is selling the idea that this is the road to economic self-sufficiency while omitting or glossing over other sign
by anigbrowl 9y ago
You're missing the point. The 'frugal culture' is selling the idea that this is the road to economic self-sufficiency while omitting or glossing over other significant information, like having a very healthy income stream to begin with.
If you're poor, being frugal is very unlikely to lift you out of poverty. That doesn't mean frugality is bad, but that marketing is as the key to financial stability is deceptive.
- aschearer 9y agoSure, but are people like the ones in this article or MMM seriously advocating that their philosophy will solve poverty? It's always struck me as middle or even upper middle class people revolting against over consumption and debt. Insofar as that's the case it seems like a positive development. And I don't see why we can't do two things at once, address inequality and poverty and reform out-of-control consumerism.
- azernik 9y agoI've heard this frequently in right-wing circles; see e.g. the complaints about people on welfare having (shock!) smartphones.
- AstralStorm 9y agoPeople in Sudan have too. An older smartphone can be had for very little nowadays. As can be a budget model.
- ericd 9y agoSmartphones are an expensive luxury, not a necessity. I think the expectation is that people on the public dole should be trying to save as much as possible and try to get off of welfare.
- anigbrowl 9y agoA moderately capable smartphone can be had for $100 and up, especially if you're not aiming for the latest model. That makes it very competitive with laptops, and provides the owner with communications, mapping, and access to all kinds of services which will make it easier to get by and considerably easier to do things like job hunting. Dismissing it as an expensive luxury is absurd.
- ericd 9y agoI don't think it's absurd. The $100 purchase price is a tiny fraction of the all-in cost of the phone, and if you're touting its usefulness in lieu of a laptop, you're talking about using a large amount of data, which usually means an expensive voice+data plan ($600-800/yr). Otherwise, a laptop and using the internet at one's local library is a much better option if utility and saving money are the priorities. A prepaid flip phone is usually better for actually making calls.
- conradev 9y ago> Sure, but are people like the ones in this article or MMM seriously advocating that their philosophy will solve poverty? It sure looks like that to me: "My Courses to Help You Make More Money" - https://millennialmoneyman.com https://millennialmoneyman.com
- xboxnolifes 9y agoMMM isn't millennial money man, it's Mister Money Mustache.
- conradev 9y agoah, well that link was one of the ones referenced in the article.
- gowld 9y agoIf you're near poor, being frugal will prevent you from falling into poverty. There are many people who have good jobs, earning $50k-$100k per year, saving nothing (or negative!), and then losing those jobs, and then collapsing into the downward spiral of poverty and homelessness.
- athenot 9y agoYou're raising an an interesting point: in the US, it's possible to be near poor without really feeling it... until what you describe ends up happening.
- conradev 9y agoYeah, this is a great article covering that topic: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/my-secret-shame/476415/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/my-secr... It resonated me with a lot.
- MaybiusStrip 9y ago"Collapsing into the downward spiral of poverty and homelessness" is not an appropriate outcome for not being frugal, and a system where this is the case is probably not very good. Again, circling back to the idea that focusing on frugality as a solution to poverty ignores the larger systemic problems actually keeping poor people poor.
- jogjayr 9y agoBut the "frugal culture" doesn't call out low-income people or blame them for being poor. Most of the FIRE community and advice is targeted to middle- and upper-middle-class people - office professionals, small businesspeople, skilled tradespeople. If you're poor it's assumed that you're already a black-belt at economizing - most FIRE advice at those income levels focuses on side hustles and ways to increase income.
- mcguire 9y agoOut of curiosity, how long do you think it would take your average "office professionals, small businesspeople, skilled tradespeople" to frugal their way into a 4-bedroom house on 66 acres, free and clear? (https://www.frugalwoods.com/2016/04/06/that-time-we-bought-a-homestead/ https://www.frugalwoods.com/2016/04/06/that-time-we-bought-a...)
- jogjayr 9y agoI don't have much familiarity with the blog itself but another post says that the property cost $389k[1]. They claim they could've paid cash for it but chose to get a mortgage - so they don't own it "free and clear". Unless they've ended up paying off the mortgage early. Assuming a 25% down payment that's a $310k mortgage. You'd need annual household income of around $80k to qualify for a mortgage that size, which also seems within the reach of a dual-earning household of white-collar/skilled trades professionals. A household earning $80k annually could save up the $90k down payment for that property in about 3-4 years, assuming a 40% savings rate. I'll admit it's aggressive and ambitious by most people's standards, but not actually impossible. Now I don't think it's actually a good idea to buy property worth nearly $400k if your annual household income is $80k but it's not an entirely outlandish idea. I assume the Frugalwoods had annual income well in excess of $80k before they "retired". Their savings rate is also correspondingly huge - 71% according to the article. A brief skim of some other posts suggests they're going to be renting out their current house + putting the new property to revenue-generating uses. They clearly know how balance sheets work and the numbers make sense for their situation. Pulling back a bit I think we should acknowledge that the Frugalwoods are people who have optimized the heck out of the very good hand that they were dealt. We should be applauding that rather than trying to pick at their story and point out why it doesn't work for everyone. I might not have Michael Phelps' swimming genes but following his workout routine would probably improve my health, even if I never become an Olympian. It's obvious that having a higher income makes it easier to frugal your way into early financial independence. The vast majority of high-income households don't take that path even though there's not much stopping them. 1. https://www.frugalwoods.com/2016/04/22/the-finances-of-our-city-rental-and-country-homestead/ https://www.frugalwoods.com/2016/04/22/the-finances-of-our-c...
- djrogers 9y ago> If you're poor, being frugal is very unlikely to lift you out of poverty. It's infinitely more likely to do so than being financially irresponsible.
- bsenftner 9y agoThey can't choose to "be frugal" when their choices are which kid eats, who gets shoes, gas for work means working overtime while the kids grow up without you, and other typical situations faced by the poor.
- adrianN 9y agoWhen you're living paycheck to paycheck with literally nothing in the bank, being frugal is the difference between a broken washing machine causing debt and life without financial doom from emergencies.
- basementcat 9y agoI like to think of frugality as something akin to adding the the "-O2" argument to $CFLAGS. It isn't going to undo fundamentally bad life choices, it won't make much difference if your code is already written in inline assembly, it might help you meet requirements if you were on the edge, it might not be a terrible idea to turn it on when you're building the release binary.