3 ms·
Shocking how incomplete this article is. One of the prominent sites was caused by Fairchild, and it's specifically described in Gordon Moore's autobiography.
by dekhn 9y ago
Shocking how incomplete this article is. One of the prominent sites was caused by Fairchild, and it's specifically described in Gordon Moore's autobiography. he said they just dumped strong acids down the drain, unaware that it ate a hole in the drainpipe, and so all the other solvents they dumped down the same drain ended up hitting the water table and pluming (https://www.amazon.com/Moores-Law-Silicon-Valleys-Revolutionary/dp/0465055648 https://www.amazon.com/Moores-Law-Silicon-Valleys-Revolution...).
he claims he didn't know that would happen, but every trained chemist learns to neutralize their acids before dumping them down the drain.
AFAICT, Moore and his buddies never had to pay anything for this- the companies settled with the government.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoThe statement about the acids doesn't make any sense. Every building engineer in charge of an industrial site knows that the pH of wastewater has to be within range, or the city will come after you for messing with operation of the sewage plant. My undergraduate university had a neutralization plant at its science site. And what's with the solvents dumped down the drain? Only water-soluble material is disposed of through sewage, with constraints on biological oxygen demand. Solvents don't go into sewage, they are burned, and some halogenated solvents are exquisitely toxic to the biological stage in the treatment plant, but that is known. Also, the sewage engineers would notice. With semiconductor plants it's usually halogenated solvent plumes. No leaky sewage lines involved.
- dekhn 9y agoThis all happened in the 60s and 70s when Fairchild was getting started. AFAICT, they just ignored all the rules. Note that this was before "semiconductor plants" as a thing existed: Moore invented a lot of the technology underlying semi plants at Fairchild.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoThey really shouldn't have skipped the rules, a common source of solvent plumes in groundwater is drycleaners. When did they start using halogenated solvents, in the 1930s?
- Gibbon1 9y ago[When did they start using halogenated solvents] Post war I think. I saw an old educational movie from the 30/40s. 'How a dry cleaners works' they were using ether or some such for dry cleaning. Film went over how the fire alarm/suppression system worked. I think the issue with halogenated solvents wasn't really understood at first. Businesses would just dump the stuff in the drain or on the ground. I remember a news report in Santa Cruz country, some business was getting harassed because they were supposedly illegally dumping perch. Turned out there was dry cleaners there in the 1950's and they were dumping perch in the septic system. 50 years later it was seeping into the San Lorinzo river.
- Aloha 9y agoMid-Late 30's, before that it used gasoline or naphtha to do the cleaning.
- dekhn 9y agoI agree they shouldn't have skipped the rules. But, at the time, I guess they kind of knew they were onto something (semiconductors) and the decided to cut a few corners?
- kbenson 9y agoAt this point it should be obvious that those starting out an industry, or those disrupting it so much as to make it in their image, have all the incentive in the world to break rules in small to medium ways consistently and pay for it later (if at all) from a position of dominance. Not only can they afford it later, but enough elites usually get in on the deal to make money on the way up help shield it from any major blowback. Just look at Uber for a recent example. I'd bet you could pick any decade of the last 150 years and it wouldn't be that hard to find obvious, well known examples.
- Aloha 9y agoLargely they followed the rules as existed at the time, consider that before the late 60's most states had no rules on dumping chemicals into the environment - and the EPA didnt even exist before 1972 - the regulatory scheme as it exists now was developed largely between 72 and 92.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe consequences were not very bad, at least for the 60s guys. In my hometown, GE did stuff like dump PCBs into the Hudson River and “donated” contaminated oils to towns for oiled gravel roads. The company had to do some remediation, long after the folks who did it were gone.
- Aloha 9y agoWhy would the individuals pay? - when you do work for hire, you're presumed to be doing the companies bidding, and they hold the liability bag. As the article states, it was not known how polluting some of these solvents were (sometimes) until decades after the disposal happened. Also, this is largely how superfund stuff works, GE has paid out many hundreds of millions to clean up the millions of tons of PCB's they dumped into the hudson river in NY over a couple decades.
- dekhn 9y agoThis wasn't work for hire. Gordon Moore was a cofounder of Fairchild. As a founder who was doing primary research work, he should in fact be held directly accountable.
- Aloha 9y agoThat would fly in the face of a couple hundred years of law. That aside - in most cases no laws that existed at the time were violated, so its not as if he knowingly violated the law - TCE for example was not known to be harmful until the mid-70's, was not known to be environmentally persistent until even later, and was not declared a carcinogen until 2005. Imagine that you're a cofounder of a company that made billions - but you personally didnt benefit much from it - beyond a paycheck - is it fair for you to be personally responsible for that environmental damage, or should the government go after the company you worked for? Superfund is set up to follow the money, the money that Intel, and the successors of Fairchild has, wildly exceed the money the founders made.
- dekhn 9y agoI'm not sure what laws you're talking about, the Superfund law: applies liability to corporate owners who commit gross negligence, and in this case, Moore was a corporate owner. Corporate officers are specifically the people who are on the legal hook.
- refurb 9y agoWhen I worked in an academic lab about 7 years ago, we never neutralized acids or bases before dumping them in the sink. The logic is that they'll be diluted almost as soon as they go own the drain. Of course, this was using small quantities of acid, not liters.
- dekhn 9y agowe're talking about liters of HF (nearly pure).
- IAmEveryone 9y agoThis is actually an article in the NYT’s photography section. It does not claim to be a complete survey of these sites.