20 ms·
Game Workers Unite
- crysin 9y agoAs someone who went to school for game design but hasn't actually been blessed yet with getting a job in games, this seems like an interesting idea. I know from my personal experience at the software companies I have worked that the culture is what drove the work to personal life ratio. My first job out of school was a start up and when the product the team I was a part of was nearing it's set-in-stone deadline, for about 3 months I was working 6 days a week and about 12ish hours a day. We weren't a game studio but we still had a taste of that crunch time that the game industry is infamous for.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- theyinwhy 9y agoGreat to see some movement here!
- andrewmcwatters 9y agoSupply and demand. Turns out a lot of people want to develop games and are willing to be underpaid compared to other developers. Either an overwhelmingly high amount of developers join a game developer union and raise salaries, or a company will simply hire someone else.
- 131012 9y agoWorkers in the game industry are not only devs. There are also artists, testers, IT techs, marketers. I'm not sure the biggest issue is about the salary, but the (unpaid) overtime, precarity, sudden lay-offs, etc.
- horsecaptin 9y agoOkay, let's call it compensation. That is a good umbrella term that includes salary, overtime and benefits. The compensation for game workers sucks compared to their counterparts in other software fields. This is probably because it is sexier to be a game dev than, say, working at Salesforce. It is a good idea for game industry workers to form a union or guild.
- checkyoursudo 9y agoSexier seems like an odd choice of word. I assume you mean, being a video game designer is sexier to the person doing the job? Low pay. Low prestige. Long hours. I mean, give me two of those and maybe I'll consider the sexiness. Don't you think it's that a lot of young future-Salesforce-developers think that making games will be a lot more like playing games than it really is? (PSA: Making games usually is not at all like playing games, unless you're really into grindfests.)
- booleandilemma 9y agoA better word might be “glamorous”.
- checkyoursudo 9y agoOk, I can accept that. I can even accept that some people think game dev is sexy. And I'm willing to say that it's all on me for not understanding, but I just don't understand how game dev (especially if you read about how it really happens) is more sexy or glamorous than Salesforce dev? My only guess is that gamers think games are way sexier than the way Salseforcers think about Salesforcing, and so maybe game devs get a little more hero status than Salesforce devs? Something like that? Do most actual game developers think, "whoa, this work I'm doing is so sexy"? I don't know that they don't. I've just never heard it. I'm sorry to all the sexy game devs I've slighted by these opinions. It is not at all my intention. Keep on with your sexiness.
- ttoinou 9y agoit is sexier to be a game dev than, say, working at Salesforce. So what should we do, besides educate people about the reality of working in this industry (which is not really the point of an union) ?
- horsecaptin 9y agoWhen the industry is highly lucrative on the backs of overworked labor, some type of a union apparatus is the most affective way to ensure fair compensation. Yes, we can educate others who want to enter the industry, but when you're graduating out of university with a fat debt, you'll accept the poor working conditions for long enough and the cycle will continue to perpetuate. The best protection against predation is for the prey to act together. Predators will always divide and conquer and go after the weak, and so the weak must be protected. The other way is increased competition - but our environment is becoming more and more anti-competitive.
- canthonytucci 9y agoWhy only game workers? Why not software workers/codewriters in general? I'd prefer something closer to SAG than the auto workers union personally.
- vvanders 9y agoGenerally software engineers have a better pay(30-50%) and work-life balance than the game industry as a whole. While the tech is similar the project cycles are usually quite different so I don't know if one-size-fits-all would get splintered by different concerns.
- walshemj 9y agoActually in the UK this is the case Prospect represents all the grades in game dev as it merged with BECTU recently
- briandear 9y agoIf the game industry is so rough, then why don’t workers quit and go work in non-game software or design? It’s because they CHOOSE to work on games and there are a lot of people that are willing to take lower pay and tougher conditions because they want to work in gaming. The implication being made that game devs are some kind of sweatshop slaves is ridiculous.
- vvanders 9y agoWow, lot to unpack there. The thing is they generally do quit, if you look at Gamasutra's yearly industry survey you'll see a huge bimodal distribution of less than 3 years and 10+ years. The average industry career ends up being about 3 years. Here's a situation that I saw a lot when I was in the industry: 1. Get a new gig in a different town(usually because the previous studio cratered). Sell your house, move your family and get settled because this studio seems like it's being run sanely. 2. 4-6mo later crunch time hits. Mandated 80hr/week with 6-7 day work weeks. Anyone who takes even half a day off catches a ton of shit. Heck, I get yelled at for leaving the office at 11pm one day. 3. No funds(remember 30-50% less pay) or time to find a new gig and you've got a mortgage/rent/family to support. 4. Game fails/sucks because of crunch or other reasons. Studio closes/layoffs. 5. Repeat step #1. I would hazard a good 80% of people in gamedev are paycheck-to-paycheck(I know we were). So while it's easy to just claim they should quit that's not as simple in practice.
- ugh123 9y agoConsider some of the negative affects of unions when working alongside low and high performers in technology: - Protection for under performers alongside high performers. Difficult or darn near impossible to terminate employment. Ability to enforce performance evaluation and plans could be killed by the union. Common in teacher unions. - Without being able to measure performance, pay may be solely based on tenure, not skill.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zaksoup 9y agoI have been working in the tech industry for 5+ years now (not too long, I know). I have yet to see a company that commonly identifies low performers and successfully terminates their employment for performance reasons only. In fact, the three times I have seen companies terminate employment after somebody was put on a PIP it was directly related to other mental health issues the employee was going through at the time. Anecdotal m, obviously, but this complaint about unions smells bogus to me, since a common complaint about the tech industry is about blood sucking low performers that stick around long past they’re due. As for measuring performance I again fail to see any company that does an adequate job of this with heuristics that aren’t at least partially, and usually fully, based on tenure. In short, what makes you think we’re good at these things now, such that unionizing would make them worse.
- humanrebar 9y agoI have seen people fired for incompetence. In fact, I appreciate companies where that happens at least every now and then. I've left jobs where incompetence wasn't corrected in some way. Though generally what happens is employees get basically cost-of-living raises indefinitely. Over a decade or two, the company ends up with a half-price employee, compared to market rates. Also we don't have to be good at evaluating employees to get worse at it. Giving raises on certification and seniority will make engineers chase promotions and titles instead of solving problems and finding managers that appreciate the work.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ttoinou 9y agoI have read the whole website and failed to see one concrete example of action that the union could take to make game-industry employees' life better Game Workers Unite is a broad-reaching organization that seeks to connect pro-union activists, exploited workers, and allies across borders and across ideologies in the name of building a unionized game industry. Even compatible with the libertarian ideology :p ?
- leadingthenet 9y agoSure, if it's of the left-wing type (ie. the original one before Americans twisted the meaning of this word, just like liberal).
- prewett 9y agoJust curious, what words would you use to describe "American-style liberal" and "American-style left-wing"?
- java_script 9y agoGP means left-libertarians, for example anarcho-syndicalists like Noam Chomsky. Versus American libertarian https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZITP93pqtdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZITP93pqtdQ
- fabianhjr 9y agoThe term "libertarian" was first used by anarchists and syndicalists in Europe. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Libertarianism#/History https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Libertarianism#/History Furthermore, modern day "libertarianism" in the USA has more to do with Objectivism/Egoism (Ayn Rand) Individualism(Individualist Anarchism). https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Libertarianism_in_the_United_States https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Libertarianism_in_the_United_Sta...
- walshemj 9y agoOff the top of my head: Lobby for improvements in labour laws to protect employees -scrapping non competes for example: Representation: In Discipline & Grievance, labour or employment triburnerals. Also as a source of pay rates etc ala BECTU, IATSE who also represent a lot of freelance workers and managers.
- jayd16 9y agoI see a lot of comments talking about employees butting heads with managers and somehow a union will protect them. I don't really see what role a union has in that particular case. I just want those poor bastards in QA to get overtime or full time benefits.
- robbomacrae 9y agoI've seen first hand how terrible dev environments such as EA are compared to startups and tech giants in SV. But that said.. in an industry where the barrier of entry for new games companies is so low, why is this even necessary? Any group of disgruntled employees with some ideas for games can say enough is enough and go start their own games company where they treat people better and subsequently attract talent (whilst raising the bar for everyone else).
- giantsloth 9y agoThe idea that it’s simple to build, design, audio engineer, graphic design, run a company, market the product, do accounting/taxes, figure out your legal stuff, etc is patently absurd
- Gabriel_Martin 9y ago"Have you ever felt exploited by the game industry? Are you in a precarious situation? No job stability and in desperate need of support? Are you losing hope that you can work in a landscape you love at all?" I'm not sure that your point actually is relevant to what they're hoping to address. Everyone having the opportunity (nevermind the intent or will) to start their own game company does not address exploitation in any way.
- ramy_d 9y agoI don't think the everyday alternative to a bad job should be a startup. That's such a different level of commitment it's not even comparable.
- 49531 9y agoCompanies are typically careful to keep employees atomized enough to prevent the disgruntled from organizing. Typically they suffer in isolation and just job hop until they find a place they enjoy working at. There are also small things companies can do to make the lives of their employees better that are sometimes impossible to negotiate as an individual. Unified teams can negotiate some of these things.
- casiotone 9y agoRead the first sentence of your post. That's why it's necessary.
- Meph504 9y agoI see a lot of people arguing about how unions protect workers, and in some cases that is true, but in my experience many have been corrupted. You only have to look at the coal workers, steel workers, and several other unions, that's leadership has been corrupted, and serve their own interest at the expense of everyone else. Additionally, things like agency fees, where even if you work somewhere with a Union, and you are denied membership, and member only benifits you can still be required to pay the union, for their "collective bargaining benifits." There are also the nightmares of union fiefdom, if a light bulb burns out in your office and you want it changed, you can wait till a union employee comes to do it, or you can pay the union the minimum call out fee (usually a couple of hours) after doing it yourself. Unions have completely failed at protecting retirement plans, and preventing age discrimination across the country. I can't understand how anyone can honestly evaluate the performance of unions in the last several decades and think that implementing one would in anyway make for a better work life situation.
- makotech222 9y agoNice propaganda, dude. We all 'hear' stories like this, but in reality, if you have any experience with people who are actually in unions, its nothing but good. And unions are the only ones pushing back against government cuts to things like education and medicaid.
- 49531 9y agoHalf of what you just said is neoliberal anti-union propaganda. A lot of people in blue collar unions get a ton of value from them. Teamsters and Boilermakers have rights protected by their unions. Yea unions have lost battles or become corrupted, but they're leaders are also elected. What you think your CEO is going to be any better? Then there are also unions for more middle to higher class groups. Writers unions, actors, professional athletes, teachers. Unions exist to fight for labor's rights.
- Meph504 9y agoIdeally, Unions exist to do that, but like many institutions, overtime they drift and are distorted away from their purpose, and mainly serve to preserve their own institution. I can't speak to how unions are all over the country, and I can't deny that unions have played a positive role in the day to day lives of workers. But what I've personally seen working in heavy industry, both the stevedoring and the steel industry. Is that unions serve themselves first, and their members secondly, and if those places that have union security agreements. The unions force non-members to basically make their lives hell. At the same time, the union agreed to a salary freeze for all its members for a 3 year period. It doesn't matter if you are the best at what you doing in the world, we couldn't compensate you more to retain that employee if we wanted it. Ask anyone who works in the Port of Los Angeles about the unions, they have locked out all technologies from automation or even telemetry unless those companies sign contracts with union vendors, etc.. etc.. My opinion isn't based on theory, or propaganda, It's from seeing everyday. Which, I highly doubt most of the people condemning my viewpoint can say.
- 49531 9y agoI am so glad to see this happening! There are a lot of reasons why game workers need to organize, but it doesn't have to stop there. Tech workers in general can make the lives of their teammates a lot better by banding together. We can also fight for the rights of others, why couldn't Amazon employees fight for the rights of Amazon's warehouse workers? Also, things like discrimination and abuse are combated by organized workforces faster than they are by HR departments, especially when such abuse comes from managers. No individual worker is going to negotiate with a company on equal footing. It requires an organization of labor to do that.
- microcolonel 9y ago> No individual worker is going to negotiate with a company on equal footing. Equal footing how? If the "worker" and the company could be on truly equal footing, then there would be no point in having companies at all. The whole point of a company is for the company to have more resources than any one person is entitled to or capable of retaining. If you mean equal footing relative other employees, why would they have equal footing if every employee is inherently different from the next?
- door3 9y agoEvery person under capitalism has to sell their labor in order to survive. This means that the employee and employer are not on equal footing - I cannot reasonably refuse to work and live a comfortable lifestyle, which means I have to make certain sacrifices (ie, working 40 hours a week in order to survive). This is all fine if I feel like I am treated well and compensated fairly, but if I feel like I am not, as an individual I have very little power. I can quit, but if I feel like most workers in my industry are not treated fairly, there's nowhere to go. However, if I organize with other workers, I have the bargaining power to make certain demands: suddenly employers realize if they want to employ people who have my skills, they have to meet certain reasonably requirements with regards to hours, compensation, etc. Things like the 40 hour workweek aren't just a result of market forces. Market forces by themselves literally worked people to death - life expectancy in Liverpool during the industrial revolution was 15. It was through organization and struggle that workers achieved the rights they have today.
- Paul_S 9y ago"We are a currently-forming anonymous and horizontal organization" - what does that mean in English?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lalaithion 9y agoThey don't publish the names of their members and they don't have a tiered structure of who does what. Everyone presumably reports to a small group of leaders.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Paul_S 9y agoA union will solve nothing other than leeching off some money from the workers (yay!). If you want to solve the problem you have to educate the credible little children who think working in gamedev is a privilege and are willing to work for free because "games!". Currently and for decades there has been an infinite supply of these, hence all the junior and mid roles pay less than half than any other industry.
- cardplayer 9y agoYou gotta love the uncaring, cynical dev with more interest in his own pocket than the effects of automation and the well-being of his technical and non-technical co-workers. Apparently, he only believes that innovation is possible everywhere else besides unions and collective bargaining. Be positive my friend, I’m sure we’re capable of creating a new type of union in 2018.
- brucephillips 9y agoI'm failing to see how your comment is any less cynical than the comment above.
- snuxoll 9y ago> You gotta love the uncaring, cynical dev with more interest in his own pocket than the effects of automation and the well-being of his technical and non-technical co-workers. As someone who eats, sleeps and breathes automation projects you (probably) won't find somebody more worried about the human costs of automation than me. 90% of our job as an internal development team is to reduce labor costs by automating various tasks, and while we continue to grow staffing because we have continued to grow our list of contracted facilities there will be a day (even if it's a decade or more away) that REDUCTION in workforce is a possibility - I fear that day, and I can only hope by that time our civilization is prepared for it. > Be positive my friend, I’m sure we’re capable of creating a new type of union in 2018. We've always been capable, unions people complain about are almost always a direct result of poor participation by members - if you want things to change make your voice heard and vote on union issues, it's no different from politics in that fashion.
- 9y ago
- cabaalis 9y agoI see no problem with game workers unionizing, but when I want to release my indie game on itch or steam and I am stopped because I have to pay dues to the union, we'll have a very real and unfriendly discussion.
- s2g 9y ago> I see no problem with game workers unionizing yet you immediately come up with a completely made up problem.
- lalaithion 9y agoFilm unions don't regulate indie films — hopefully this will be much the same.
- Stanleyc23 9y agohmm, I would have assumed the writer's guild rules would still apply even if you're doing an indie film.
- Elidrake24 9y agoYou can apply for the Low Budget Agreement on an indie film (defined as being under a particular budget amount I couldn't find), but it isn't required if you are in the guild. It was mainly created to protect individuals from larger studios - can't imagine much benefit from leveraging what are essentially personal projects.
- petee 9y agoIATSE Low Budget Theatrical Agreement sets a Tier-1 ("lowest"...their is a mythical tier-0, but its negotiated) for budgets under $6 million; Tier-2 is $6-10, and Tier-3 is $10-14 A Tier-1 has benefits such as $108/day toward healthcare, retirement. Pay rates in the range of $21-26/hr. That said, i know of plenty of super-low budget indies that are just too small to use the contract -- the union often doesn't mind, and union workers will still do these 'passion projects' because they love the work
- petee 9y agoOne of my relatives works for a large well known game developer; same employer for years. Because they decide to classify many of their devs as contract workers, they are denied rights afforded to 'full-time' employees - when she is laid off for months at a time (to prevent being called a full-time) she can't collect unemployment. No health care, no benefits whatsoever. And due to contracts, can't work for a rival either during this time. Its forced unemployment. None of the employees are happy with this situation, but job scared that they'll simply be replaced by those who won't complain, and blacklisted.
- petee 9y agoAnother example is the collapse of 38 Studios in Rhode Island - half their workers were brought in as contract workers; After 2 weeks without pay, the company finally collapsed: only 'full-time' workers were able to attend an emergency job fair the state created. The rest of the employees, many who had moved to the area specifically for the job, couldn't even collect unemployment - I met one girl working at Uno's Pizzeria so she wouldn't become homeless and stuck in a distant state.
- sangnoir 9y agoI'm amazed that this is legal in a first world country- it would be illegal to do this in a couple of third-world countries I'm personally familiar with: the laws state that if you're a on contract for more than a certain number of months, you automatically become a permanent employee. Firing and rehiring for the same position as a contractor is straight-up illegal.
- petee 9y agoThere are almost always loopholes and gray areas. I'm pretty sure its illegal, but here is one example: I hire you to rebuild my kitchen; I eventually 'run out of money' and lay you off. 3 months later I rehire you to finish the kitchen. Are you really a full-time employee? Am I responsible for your healthcare? Or are you still just a contractor? In this example, i'll bet most would say no, you're just a contractor. But that is also just at your house, not some mega-corporation...gray area, right? I believe its the use of layoff and such terminology, that gets them around laws
- kakarot 9y agoAnonymous unions... Now that's a concept I'm very interested in. Where does the negotiating power come from?
- xstartup 9y agoI think partly this has to do with "the struggle" factor. Once, I had this guy who owns a big gaming company and I asked him the same question, why do you treat these employees, unlike other software companies? He said, there was a time when he no one would apply for open job listings at his company because they had less money or they were not very hot. And that he understands, he can push the people around as he has earned it. So, it seems there is some revenge and ability to justify worse at work here. What can you do? There aren't that many successful companies and the even if there are, they aren't growing as fast as your SV startup, so they do not need increasing supply of labor.
- ManlyBread 9y agoSo what does this do exactly?
- typeformer 9y agoSolidarity!
- fouc 9y agoI thought game workers were going to be gamers that work in the game to mine or product products or similar.
- SeanBoocock 9y agoI've been working in game development as a software engineer for going on seven years and am happy to see this initiative. Unions nothwithstanding there is plenty of variation in the working conditions throughout the industry. The best empirical reflection of that is the annual IGDA surveys: https://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.igda.org/resource/resmgr/2017_DSS_/!IGDA_DSS_2017_SummaryReport.pdf https://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.igda.org/resource/resmgr/2017_.... If you find yourself at a studio with poor working conditions, know that there are plenty of studios that better respect you and your time. Hopefully unionization, or at least the threat of it, will raise the floor on the conditions and compensation for the employees most often exploited: contractors generally and QA specifically.
- Pinkertron 9y agoThis is the best news I’ve seen on this site for years.