3 ms·
As long as the economy is doing well things will be OK. From the outside China looks pretty well run so I'd expect them to last for a long time. It's not like t
by maxxxxx 9y ago
As long as the economy is doing well things will be OK. From the outside China looks pretty well run so I'd expect them to last for a long time. It's not like the Soviets where it was blatantly obvious that things are mismanaged.
- emiliobumachar 9y ago> It's not like the Soviets where it was blatantly obvious that things are mismanaged. Do you mean blatantly obvious at the time and from outside? Could you please elaborate? I thought the USSR put up a good front, and fooled much of the West with regard to economic development (not freedom).
- adventured 9y agoThere were always people that left the USSR and came over to the West and told the truth about what conditions were really like there. People mostly chose to believe those stories or not, based on their own ideological bias. Hollywood put out several productions that proclaimed the USSR was a paradise. [1][2] US and European industrialists had gone over to the USSR pre-WW2 and helped them build out their industrial base. The Soviets had entirely failed at industrializing on their own. From those experiences, and people writing about them, it was fairly well known what general condition the USSR was actually in economically. Firm, reliable metrics however were largely unavailable throughout the Soviet era. The fooling of the West, regarding the Soviet's mighty materialism output, mostly fell apart by the 1960s (the facade lasted for ~30 years or so, and mostly only for people that were sympathetic to that ideology). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_North_Star_(1943_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_North_Star_(1943_film) [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Song_of_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Song_of_Russia
- maxxxxx 9y agoPeople I have met who had lived in the USSR and East Germany knew exactly that things were far different from the official reality.
- forapurpose 9y ago> It's not like the Soviets where it was blatantly obvious that things are mismanaged. It's only blatantly obvious in hindsight. My vague memory of the history of it: There were many in the West who supported the Soviets as the future of humanity (not nearly a majority, but a not just a couple of wackos either - especially at the beginning). In the 1970s / early 1980s there was a major debate in the U.S. over whether to compete with the Soviets or just accept their power. U.S. intelligence thought the Soviet economy was doing well right up until the end.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI was in East Germany, Czechoslovakia and East Berlin in the early 80s and you just had to look around to see that they were way behind the West. Long lines everywhere, empty stores, cars with two stroke engines, everything run down. You could see the decay.
- philwelch 9y agoA large part of the reason for that is because many Western academic fields were largely infested with ideological leftists. (And to a great extent they still are.) Few people expected the Communist political system to collapse the way it did, but the lowercase-communist economic system was pretty obviously on its last legs by then. And indeed, look at what's happened: Russia abandoned lowercase-communism along with uppercase-Communism but certain features of the Communist political system managed to reassert themselves, in the form of the former KGB man Putin seizing and consolidating power. By this point, Russia's sphere of influence had retracted from eastern Germany all the way back to struggling to maintain control over Ukraine, but a little bit of brute force managed to keep Ukraine in line, too. China, unlike Russia, managed to reform away from lowercase-communism while still maintaining the uppercase-Communist political structure. They are also just now attempting Great Power-style diplomacy over their neighbors, whereas Russia was overextended into that role ever since the end of WWII.
- forapurpose 9y ago> many Western academic fields were largely infested with ideological leftists. (And to a great extent they still are.) Sounds like we're edging into an old Cold War ideological fight, attributing things to characterizations rather than addressing the ideas. How does the parent post explain the CIA and Henry Kissinger's 'Detente'? EDIT: minor edit, more edit