10 ms·
It's about time people realize that platforms like YouTube are private publishers. They have full discretion to remove or editorialize content, and there's no e
by pavlov 9y ago
It's about time people realize that platforms like YouTube are private publishers. They have full discretion to remove or editorialize content, and there's no expectation of free speech.
Expecting YouTube to keep hosting something because of First Amendment rights is as absurd as expecting a printing press to print your pamphlets for free.
- DennisP 9y agoYes, and we have full discretion to decide we don't like them anymore if they do that. I don't think many people believe YouTube could be sued for First Amendment violation.
- pavlov 9y agoYou'd be surprised by how many people think their First Amendment rights are trampled on by Twitter/Facebook/Google...
- chillwaves 9y agoPeople calling it censorship yesterday (on this forum) don't seem to understand the meaning of the word.
- girvo 9y agoI think that’s kind of ignoring the outsized impact these huge companies have on our lives.
- che_shirecat 9y agoYoutube holds a pretty dominating market share of video sharing but there are 10+ other relatively large sites that you could host the content in question on. There's a difference between access and an audience - youtube shouldn't be obligated to give an audience to content they don't like. People are free to migrate to other platforms (case in point - phub) if they so choose.
- chillwaves 9y agopeople are basically complaining about market share through the lens of oppression and it is sickening.
- Laaas 9y agoHow is it not censorship? It is legal, and they're not violating anything, but it is still censorship, because they are censoring something. It doesn't have to be illegal for it to be censorship.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoBecause Google is a private company is why it is NOT censorship.
- waterphone 9y agoIt's censorship, it's just legal censorship because it's not the government doing it.
- chillwaves 9y agoThat's not what censorship means.
- wlesieutre 9y agoHere's what Merriam Webster says censorship means: >1 a : the institution, system, or practice of censoring >"They oppose government censorship." The example use calls out government censorship as a specific type of censorship. If "censorship" meant "the government censoring things" you would not need to specify "government censorship" in that sentence. Yes, I know that dictionary definitions are not necessarily the final word on what something means, but they're absolutely correct here. It is a broad word and it is widely used in other contexts. People other than the government can censor things. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_censorship
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- optimuspaul 9y ago
- hungerstrike 9y agoActually, I think what you meant to say is that the definition of the word censor has nothing to do with the first amendment or even government. Censorship is the "official" capacity of someone to prevent someone else from publishing. The official person could be an official of government or a private company as far as the definition is concerned. define censor - https://www.google.com/search?q=define+censor https://www.google.com/search?q=define+censor 1. an official who examines material that is about to be released, such as books, movies, news, and art, and suppresses any parts that are considered obscene, politically unacceptable, or a threat to security. 2. (in ancient Rome) either of two magistrates who held censuses and supervised public morals. 3. examine (a book, movie, etc.) officially and suppress unacceptable parts of it. So, Youtube and others are indeed censoring you when they do not allow you to publish certain videos.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chillwaves 9y agoGreat, but every content platform has rules and censorship. The term doesn't mean much in that context. A private platform saying "You cannot say whatever you want on my microphone" is not censorship in any meaningful sense when you are free to pick up your own microphone. No one says you have a right to the users on a specific platform. I can't go on CNN and start ranting, so why should I be able to say anything I want with Youtube not able to moderate the content? It doesn't make sense. You cannot force private platforms to accept views against their economic interests and call that freedom. If someone says you will go to jail for saying something, that is censorship.
- tzs 9y ago> So, Youtube and others are indeed censoring you when they do not allow you to publish certain videos. Except YouTube does not prevent you from publishing your videos. They only prevent you from publishing them on YouTube. You can publish them on another platform, or self-publish them. Censorship is usually taken to mean suppressing or attempting to suppress a work from being published at all across some reasonably large population, which is generally something only governments have the power to do. One might make a case that a private organization that has acquired a monopoly or near monopoly could do so, but YouTube is not yet there.
- adventured 9y agoCensorship becomes an interesting tag, plausibly accurate, if the US Government regulates platforms further to such a degree that they make competing with them a lot more difficult, due to compliance cost & risk. That is, if the government effectively protects & entreches the existing giant platforms through regulatory action. Then these entities become something a lot closer to regulated broadcast platforms akin to radio or TV with ABC, NBC, etc. before the advent of expanded media thanks to the Internet.
- chillwaves 9y agoHasn't happened so why speculate?
- vortico 9y agoCensorship is the correct term for any organization restricting content. E.g. a parent restricting a child's TV is censorship. The First Ammendment only deals with censorship by the US Government.
- chillwaves 9y agoOK then the word has no meaning because every community has rules and the right to organize and self moderate. That is what is happening. You do not get to force your voice on another person's platform. How is that justice?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoIs that more than the people who think that without Net Neutrality, Comcast, Cox, ATT will trample their First Amendment rights?
- pavlov 9y agoIs that common? My impression is that most people are basically worried that lack of net neutrality regulation means they might eventually get charged more for Netflix.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agohttps://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/06/attack-net-neutrality-attack-free-speech https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/06/attack-net-neutrality-...
- _jal 9y agoThis. Non-nerds don't, as a rule, understand the distinction. I have had to explain why it is a category error so many times that I have it down to a quick patter now, in a couple of forms - one for quick explanation, one as a socratic QA. The latter seems to work better for people who shout loudly about their Constitutional rights.
- bcoates 9y agoThe non-nerds are right and the nerds are being weird pedants. Going all well-actually and giving people the verbal equivalent of xkcd 1357 lets everyone know you're one of those people.
- _jal 9y agoLaw is a pedantic field. If I'm bullshitting over a beer, no I don't do that. If I'm having a serious conversation about real things, yes; I prefer to talk about reality. I take it you don't?
- DennisP 9y agoIf so they're wrong, but that doesn't change the fact that as users of Youtube, we have an absolute right to exercise our actual First Amendment rights of free speech and assembly, by complaining about Youtube's unsatisfactory service and moving to other platforms. The fact that Youtube has a legal right to do what they're doing is completely beside the point.
- Slansitartop 9y agoThere are two relevant concepts here, and it's not surprising people get them a little confused. One is the natural right of free expression, the other is the First Amendment. The latter is a law meant to protect the former against a particularly powerful organization, the US Government. It wasn't even originally part of the constitution because founders thought free expression was an inalienable right retained by the people, so explicitly guaranteeing it was redundant. So, I think it's a forgivable offense when someone complains that their "First Amendment" rights are being violated when their free expression rights are being violated by a particularly powerful organization that's not the US government.
- deevolution 9y agoThere are plenty of other platforms out there for the people who believe their first amendments are being violated. Youtube is going to do whatever it must to protect itself from losing money and consumers. If it turns out the majority of the population is disgusted by gun rights propaganda, and that content starts littering youtube, people are going to start moving away from the platform. Logically, they are going to remove the content that reduces their revenue. This is just a hunch though.
- aje403 9y agoNever underestimate the ability of an idiot on the internet spouting a first amendment argument getting upvoted to the moon and beyond
- Buldak 9y agoIt does strike me that the free speech and capitalistic impulses of opponents of censorship are in tension with each other. If YouTube could show that hosting certain gun videos would cost them $X in advertising revenue or litigation, and that their decision to ban them was only designed to avoid that loss, would that appease their critics? Or is the suggestion here that large content platforms have some obligation to uphold free speech norms at their own expense?
- ballenf 9y agoIf they held all content to the same rule, probably yes critics would be mollified. The problem here is that Google's critics feel like the exact opposite is happening. edited to add: From the article > It then posted links to YouTube videos on synthesizing meth and other illicit acts. Kind of hard to imagine that meth instructional videos are good for YT advertising revenue.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoGoing to repost my canned response: >The government supports free speech because it's important and a Good Thing. Just because private companies aren't required to do the same doesn't make it any less important and a Good Thing.
- leot 9y ago"Censorship" is a Bad Word because of Nazi book burnings, Soviet political censorship, Fahrenheit 451, and other notions of "government censorship". Its "Bad Word" status means that we don't want it to apply to the kinds of blocking that we think are legitimate. But the reality is that censorship is not all, or even mostly, bad. YouTube censors snuff videos. And porn. Is that bad? How about videos showing how to make bombs? What about nuclear bombs? What about anthrax? What about biological weapons? Clearly, YouTube and other platforms must and will draw lines on what does and doesn't constitute acceptable content. The question isn't about censorship. It's about where the line should be drawn. For whatever reason, there's a lot of people who think that instructional videos on guns should be in-bounds rather than out-of-bounds. To the extent people are talking about "censorship" writ-large it is a distraction from having to justify making specific kinds of content widely available.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoAn argument can be made on what is and is not appropriate to censor, and we would probably disagree. But that's not important - what's important is who should decide what is and is not censored. Should YouTube (and Google) be making that decision, or should the government? At least in theory, the government is an extension of the people, and a private corporation is not. We should decide as a society what topics should and should not be censored. Then we can defend minority viewpoints and make moral judgements, rather than financial ones.
- leot 9y agoI think content providers and platforms should be free to make whatever choice they want regarding content on their platform, provided they don't discriminate illegally (i.e., based on membership in a protected group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group) If you fully ramify your position, you're advocating that the government tell me that if I host videos, I can't prevent people from posting videos that I don't like. E.g., if I make a cat video hosting platform, and someone uploads a dog video, I can't stop them. Again, this is a debate about where to draw the line. It just happens to be the case that there are some people who are fierce advocates for maximizing the amount of gun stuff that is readily available online.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoExactly. But it is ridiculous, IMO, Google does not boot the content like Alex Jones but instead is paying the infrastructure cost as not possible to monetize. It is a great comparison to printing pamphlets. Google is basically paying the bills to print alt-right pamphlets and to me that is wrong.
- SmallDeadGuy 9y agoThat's not very absurd if you let the printing press stick ads all over your pamphlets, getting them revenue. A better comparison is expecting a printing press to want to associate themselves and their ads with controversial content.
- ad_hominem 9y agoThat line starts to get blurred when you have leviathan banks in an oligopolistic industry like Citi, who only exist because they were bailed out by the gov't, making decisions like this: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/22/business/citigroup-gun-control-policy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/22/business/citigroup-gun-co... There's also a conversation to be had about free speech as a cultural norm. I'm within my rights to shout down everything you try to say in a public forum but I think we've seen that society suffers when that's commonplace.
- js8 9y ago> It's about time people realize that platforms like YouTube are private publishers. They have full discretion to remove or editorialize content, and there's no expectation of free speech. I don't know. Can you explain, why should private companies be not allowed to discriminate, but allowed not to have free speech? In both cases you can say, well, if you're discriminated by a private company, you can always go to a different one. I my view, the problem is that we don't want to force people (individuals) to non-discriminate or allow free speech. But institutions, it's another matter. If the institution has enough power, it can impede the rights of people. So people asking for YT and such to respect freedom of speech are asking for them to be treated as institutions, something that is potentially more powerful than individuals. And they understand that freedom of speech (just like non-discrimination) is beneficial (for society) in any institution, not just government. After all, you can select a government too, by emigrating into a different country.
- leot 9y agoThey, and you, and all of us, are allowed to discriminate, and we do so all the time. However, we have made laws that prohibit certain kinds of discrimination against "protected classes", e.g. based on sex and race. Being an advocate of gun rights is not a protected class.
- js8 9y agoI don't think you understand my argument. I am talking precisely about discrimination against what you call "protected classes" (actually, I don't think the legislation is class oriented, but let's put that aside). Companies are not allowed to do that, but individuals are allowed to discriminate even "protected classes". I can freely choose not to associate with black people, for instance. And that is a good thing. So even today there is a legal distinction between individuals and institutions. And in a certain sense, "advocate of gun rights" is a protected class, because you have also non-discrimination (I would assume, like most civilized countries) on the basis of political opinion.
- leot 9y ago
- cm2187 9y agoDon't think it's a first amendment issue, but the printing press in question is offering to print everyone else's pamphlets for free, but turns down pamphlets that are not compliant with its liberal agenda. I think it is certainly entitled to do so, but I have seen many, even on HN, denying that the Silicon Valley is progressively becoming hostile to non liberal opinions. This seems to be a good illustration. And this liberal agenda is not a monopoly of the Silicon Valley either. Citi recently did something similar, announcing that it will cease to make loans or provide payment services to businesses who do not comply with its views on gun control. Which I find more problematic than youtube given the regulatory monopoly and lack of competition in the banking industry.
- jbigelow76 9y agolack of competition in the banking industry I can think of 11 banks off the top of my head, some are big banks, a couple credit unions, a brokerage with banking services like Schwab. If I googled for "local banks" I would get a lot more. What is the lack of competition you are referring to?
- leot 9y ago"Liberal agenda" <= really? I don't know what you mean by that. Please explain. (EDIT: Legitimately don't understand the downvotes here.)
- reitanqild 9y agoThat the big tech companiea are liberal seems to be one of the things most "conservatives" and "liberals" on HN agree on :-) As for why it was downvoted I guess a number of people on both sides found it to be plain false and maybe also someone though it was a deliberate misrepresentation of the situation.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> That the big tech companiea are liberal seems to be one of the things most "conservatives" and "liberals" on HN agree on The big tech companies (in terms of direction from the top) are mostly center-right neoliberal in orientation, straddling the US partisan divide (Microsoft has historically been attached to the Republican Party, which paid off big when the Bush Administration took over from the Clinton Administration at the end of their antitrust trial, most of the rest of the big firms have been closer to the neoliberal wing of the Democratic Party.)
- dbg3386 9y agoTotally agree with this.
- naaaaak 9y agoIf YouTube is a private company that can act how it wants, how is a Christian bakery forced to bake a cake for a person who violates their religious beliefs? Were they not a private company who could act how they want? Gun control is the religion of leftists, so I guess that’s okay, right?