4 ms·
It isn't a popular statement, but I'm super excited about this, and if anything, this didn't go far enough. Section 230 needs to be removed in it's entirety. As
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
It isn't a popular statement, but I'm super excited about this, and if anything, this didn't go far enough. Section 230 needs to be removed in it's entirety. As Matt Stoller from the Open Markets Institute put it last night, this is the first time that big tech has ever really lost in Congress.
One example that stuck out to me recently was Google's participation in the drug rehab scam market. The Verge called them out on it repeatedly, and Google finally stopped doing it. https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/7/16257412/rehabs-near-me-google-search-scam-florida-treatment-centers https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/7/16257412/rehabs-near-me-go...
As noted in the article, Google was making as much as $230 per click. While they knew a lot of the ads they were selling were scams, the market was extremely lucrative for them, they were bringing in hundreds of millions of dollars with it. They even had marketers specifically catering to building the rehab ad market.
Thanks to Section 230, Google can't be held responsible for scams that they knowingly continued to support and fostered the growth of... and made hundreds of millions of dollars from. Even though Google's pulled the drug rehab ads now, all that profit is still theirs to keep, even though it should really go to some sort of victim's compensation fund.
Tech companies have shown repeatedly they can't be trusted with blanket immunity from prosecution, and it's time to take it away.
- devnill 9y agoShould gun manufacturers be liable for shootings? Car manufacturers for hit and runs? What about the USPS for when people ship drugs or other illegal contraband? This seems like an awfully slippery slope where companies are are not only responsible for their own actions, but also for the actions of their customers as well.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIf gun owners are actively advertising to people they perceive to be likely mass shooters: Yes. There's just so much here. They actively encouraged the practice, they made hundreds of millions of dollars on it, and the perverse incentive of a bidding war caused by all these scammers mean that despite knowing about the problem, Google had no desire to fix it.
- adventured 9y ago> If gun owners are actively advertising to people they perceive to be likely mass shooters That's an extraordinarily absurd setup legally. How do you perceive someone to be a likely mass shooter exactly? What the hell is likely? Perceive what? Your entire concept is legally broken top to bottom, it would never stand up to a challenge. And how do you define that they're specifically advertising to that person? So: first, you have to magically perceive that someone is "likely" to be a mass shooter. Then the company has to be caught having identified someone as a likely mass shooter. Then the company has to intentionally advertise to them. Then it has to be shown that they intentionally advertised to them. Beyond being a non-functioning legal premise, in the best case scenario you just narrowed the risk for the gun maker down to zero.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThat is my point, that the parent of my comment was not making a really comparable example to the one I was giving of Google's actions and how Section 230 absolves them of responsibility they truly should share in.
- mrunkel 9y agoYour analogy is not quite right. Google in this example isn't the gun manufacturer, they are simply the building owner that somebody else is selling guns out of. The GP wants that building owner to be liable for the actions of the person that their tenant sells to.