9 ms·
On one hand, while harsh, laying off older workers (even the ones who have kept up to date on technology) makes good economic sense. On the other hand, not all
by mistermann 9y ago
On one hand, while harsh, laying off older workers (even the ones who have kept up to date on technology) makes good economic sense. On the other hand, not all global companies are limited by the type of worker's rights legislation noted in the article.
While this survival of the fittest, hyper-capitalism approach will optimize return on investment and technological innovation, I suspect it is also ~destroying the careers of many high achievers who would likely have outperformed in other fields without having their careers derailed.
Does anyone see a way to reconcile this?
- tyingq 9y ago"laying off older workers...makes good economic sense" Perhaps you're just quoting bad, but real, existing policy, but this is pure bullshit. Experience has value. I'm surprised also, that younger developers aren't concerned about this. Do they think they are going to retire in their 30's, or that they are somehow more innovative or more smart than those that preceded them?
- TACIXAT 9y ago>Do they think they are going to retire in their 30's That is the plan, yes.
- tyingq 9y agoHeh, appreciate the honesty. I guess there is a temporary market condition where that might seem realistic to some.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoAh, shame. 30's here. Hint: no retiring yet. In fact, not sure why you'd want to, but for escaping the daily grind for someone else. The well is endless. Drink deep. Also not sure why its worth selling some of the best, most energetic years of one's life to something one cares so little about that one wants to enter into it on an escape trajectory.
- badpun 9y ago> In fact, not sure why you'd want to, but for escaping the daily grind for someone else. ... isn't this exactly the point of retirement?
- 52-6F-62 9y agoNo. Retirement implies the intent to no longer participate in an activity professionally, competitively, or as a contributor. It means ceasing one's work. Working for oneself or for something one believes in to any extent might not be the same grind, but also wouldn't be retirement.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI think it's a good plan but I hope you know that most people won't achieve this.
- TACIXAT 9y agoI do realize that. I recognize I'm in a very fortunate position and am taking advantage of it.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI don't understand the need to take a stand either way. If the experience has value, as you say, then IBM is shooting themselves in the foot and will suffer in the market. Meanwhile some other company will scoop up all this great economically efficient talent and get a market advantage. I tend to think you're right, but I don't feel the need to make IBM save itself.
- tyingq 9y ago"I don't feel the need to make IBM save itself" Yeah, I'm not specifically trying to make some plea to IBM. Just that the general practice of laying off experienced people, or only hiring young people, is dumb and not productive. I've personally seen that a mix of young/innovative and older/experienced is better than a homogenous extreme of either.
- Consultant32452 9y agoMy point is that you don't need to plea with IBM or the general marketplace. If what you said is true then companies with that mix of young/innovative and older/experienced will outcompete everyone else. Let IBM's massive public failure be the message to others.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoDude, you keep making these fallacious arguments that base themselves around the markets being perfectly rational. Stop it. Spend some time in the real world, and see that there is no truth to those appeals.
- Consultant32452 9y agoWhether or not markets are perfectly rational is irrelevant. I haven't seen an economic argument, an argument that suggests it's better for the employer if they keep the older workers, that justifies forcing them to against their will. There are arguments to be made that outlawing age discrimination is the moral thing to do. But it being the moral thing to do has nothing to do with whether or not it's the best business decision for every company.
- gcb0 9y agoact on data instead of baseless silly preconceptions, like the one you opened your comment with ;)
- protomyth 9y agoWell, first, I really want an explanation of how "laying off older workers (even the ones who have kept up to date on technology) makes good economic sense". All I see is poor engineering and technology churn for stuff that was a solved issue years ago. If we are actually to become an engineering discipline we really need to start valuing experience. I really don't think the throw-away culture we have is going to work when so much of our lives start requiring software to work or someone gets killed.
- ams6110 9y agoIt makes sense in a bean-counter type of way, where you look at employees as warm bodies that can perform a task. You can generally pay young people less than older people. That is pretty much the same point of view that drives outsourcing also. Whether it is good for a company in the long run, is very dependent on the skills and experience required to perform those tasks well and provide value for customers.
- protomyth 9y agoBean-counters also buy crappy toilet paper[1] and don't mind removing benefits. That isn't really an explanation of why it makes "good economic sense", its an explanation on why people who don't do a specific job just don't value that job. 1) had an old manager that pointed out when the company starts buying the scratchy toilet paper, its probably time to move on sense they are going to make a lot of crappy decisions from now on.
- vinceguidry 9y agoSadly not a good metric anymore because most companies outsource their building maintenance and janitorial services. Still a great point.
- protomyth 9y agoEven with outsourcing there is some quality control by the company. Does my garbage can get emptied nightly, are the bathrooms clean, is the lighting replaced when burned out, etc. Companies that blame the facility are pretty much playing the numbers game.
- ams6110 9y agoIn my early 50s, I am now squarely in the "older tech worker" community but I have always viewed employment as an agreement between two parties. I provide work, they provide compensation. Every two weeks they pay me, fund my other benefits as per the employment agreement, and we're even. I have never looked at an employer as somebody who owed me anything beyond that, nor do I owe them any particular loyalty beyond what we agreed to.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoSo you're saying youre ok with employers discriminating based on your age because employers can do what they want?
- vinceguidry 9y agoAs a professional, hopefully he's been planning for retirement for some number of years. And not all employers discriminate. So just find one who doesn't, finish off your retirement checklist, and leave the world of work to the kids. There are worse worlds to live in than one in which everyone can do what they want.
- Cthulhu_ 9y ago> So just find one who doesn't IBM didn't, until they did.
- vinceguidry 9y agoI really don't understand the mentality here sometimes. HNers want ultimate choice for themselves, but the choices of the companies they work for are to be constrained such that the only choices they make are choices that benefit them. They want both ultimate security and benefit of market forces on their salaries. Libertarianism only when it suits them.
- s73v3r_ 9y ago
- maxxxxx 9y agoBy the same logic it would make economic sense to euthanize old or sick people too... I think we need to start looking at building systems where most people have a reasonable path to get education, health care, affordable housing and retirement without having to win the lottery or get lucky in some other way. We can't just look at short term profits and throw away people once they are a little older. It just won't work in the long run.
- schrototo 9y agoWhy is there a need to reconcile? Worker’s rights trump ROI. If you can’t run a profitable company without discriminating against and exploiting your workers, you shouldn’t run a company at all. Also, look towards more socialist countries (e.g. Germany), for practical strategies to keep making money while at the same time ensuring people don’t get exploited. Hint: empowering workers, letting them unionize and collectively bargain, treating them as humans rather than “Human Resources”, will not actually significantly decrease your ROI.
- berbec 9y ago> Worker’s rights trump ROI <s>Where? Do they accept skilled immigrants? What Rosetta Stone do I need to buy. </s> At least in the America I see around me, this is very untrue in the vast majority of cases.
- rpiguy 9y agoThe effect of unionization had the opposite effect in Germany, Denmark, etc. It caused a huge shift to contract work. Contractors have more protections in those countries than they do here, but do not enjoy nearly the same protections as full time employees. http://ec.europa.eu/epsc/publications/strategic-notes/future-work_en http://ec.europa.eu/epsc/publications/strategic-notes/future... https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/11/business/europe-labor-rights.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/11/business/europe-labor-rig... I admit that the social protections in those countries generally means that the shift to contractor work is less likely to affect things like cost of healthcare, retirement, etc. Some big US tech companies might be zombies (IBM, HP), but with our less restrictive labor laws and emphasis on entrepreneurship they have been replaced with new giants (Google, Facebook, etc.) This did not happen in the tech sector in Europe, the giants fell, Bull, Nokia, etc. and nothing rose up to their size outside of the banking sector. Part of the reason may have been that the overall environment was not flexible enough to allow new entrants, among many other factors. SAP remains strong, but I can't think of another pure software/IT company in Europe of that size or market position.
- schrototo 9y agoNeither of the articles you link to say that unionisation is the reason for the ongoing shift to contract work, or even mention unions at all... If anything, (stronger) unions are exactly what contract workers need. What caused the shift to contract work? Greed. Greedy employers who don't want to give up the tiniest bit of profit to pay for living wages, health benefits, retirement plans or workplace safety, and then have the gall to re-brand deregulation as freedom.
- cornholio 9y ago> On one hand, while harsh, laying off older workers (even the ones who have kept up to date on technology) makes good economic sense It's actually a completely irrational thing to do, you would not get rid of an experienced, productive, loyal employee, unless you are forced into a compensation plan that no longer makes sense and there is no way to diminish that paycheck. In light of the large increase for IT compensation in the last decades, this seems the exception. In my 20s I worked with 60 year olds that were better than all of my young/senior peers, with deep, multidisciplinary understanding of our product, technology and market. This is why I have serious reservations about the way the issue is presented in the article, as purely a prejudice against old age. That would make sense say in the airline industry, driven by the customer's prejudices, but in tech it is simply self-defeating, you are not gaining anything, there is no motive, quite the opposite. That is if, and only if, the employees keep up to date, productive and motivated. A large part of the article is bemoaning how IBM failed their expectations for a job for life where they can retire from. That is a huge warning sign of an employee who no longer competes in the market and sees his paycheck as an earned right.
- cimmanom 9y agoYup. It's pretty common for a 60-year-old to be 10 times as productive as a 25-year-old in the long run (counting bugs, rewrites, "oops, we built the wrong thing", "oops, this doesn't scale", "oops, this incredibly fragile when we try to extend it") even working 80% of the hours (40 hours to the youngster's 50). And even the highest salaries for the most senior engineers are less than 10x an entry-level programming salary these days. Experienced developers are a bargain.
- Balero 9y agoThis seems to me to be why people are pushed into management roles. Many of the above savings (especially the big ones) can be more quickly decided at the management level. Also worth noting that you can have been in the industry for a long time, and to not have benefitted. Good experienced developers are a bargain. Bad experienced are still just bad.