5 ms·
I agree that dashcam/external cam footage is going to be limited and possibly misleading, and I would think/hope such footage isn't the primary factor in evalua
by danso 9y ago
I agree that dashcam/external cam footage is going to be limited and possibly misleading, and I would think/hope such footage isn't the primary factor in evaluating accident cases. But I do think there's value to it. I shouldn't have said that it is the "main" way for us to process a scene, but the most accessible/relatable way.
What you posted looks pretty cool, I don't know enough about it to understand what I should be prioritizing focus on, but we can chalk that up to ignorance. The benefit that driver-view footage has is that it is a viewpoint all of us are familiar with. If you ask me to watch dashcam footage to assess some kind of traffic thing, there's a general expectation of where I keep my eyes and what I notice.
This normal-human-view mode is probably going to be necessary in AV cases in which we determine whether the car's AI did the right thing. Presumably, as AV becomes mainstream and extremely safe, these accidents will involve edge cases and outliers which are poorly interpreted by sensors/non-human-vision. Seeing the scene as a human driver does might be a necessary starting place?
But the Uber case in AZ, IMO, proves your point. The Tempe police quickly made a judgement call based on what seems to be inadequate video. Everyone who can now view the video will also be inclined to think how impossible it would be to avoid hitting the victim, even if the actual scene in-person has much more light. And of course, we don't want to judge AV solely on whether it performs as well as normal humans.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> we don't want to judge AV solely on whether it performs as well as normal humans You don't think performing as well as normal humans should be sufficient to allow them on the road? Or are you saying they should be allowed even if their performance is worse than human? (...as long as some other criterion is met?)
- pfisch 9y agoj-walking, at night, no reflectors, in the dark. Even if the camera was brighter uber isn't at fault anyway....
- daveevad 9y agoThe bike probably had a reflector on its pedals. I would be very interested to learn whether or not the car's autonomous system identified a bicycle at any point prior to the collision.
- Scoundreller 9y agoUsually other reflectors are required when riding at night. But this was a pedestrian, not a cyclist. Personally, while riding at night, I look like a Christmas tree. $10 on EBay goes far these days in the reflective tape and bike light department:
- zip1234 9y agoIn some places (UK for example) you need to have lights on your bike as well--not just reflectors.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoIf everyone followed the law, this wouldn't have happened for a multitude of reasons. Alas, here we are.
- MertsA 9y agoWell it was a pedestrian but they were walking their bike across the road. It's not like the software should make a distinction between a cyclist in the way and a bicycle with no rider in the way.
- brokenmachine 9y agoThe car likely didn't identify an obstacle at all, let alone a bicycle, as it didn't apply the brakes.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoWhich is weird, because regardless of reflectors, it should show up on IR and lidar imaging.
- gophile 9y agoUber may not be at fault, legally speaking. That's up to the legal authorities to decide. However, as a society and civilization, and even more so, as engineers and scientists, we are going to expect that the autonomous car matches or exceeds human-level performance in critical situations like this. Therefore the time spent on investigating, understanding, and discussing the root causes of the accident is worth understanding. Accidents like these generally do not happen due to a single factor. It is necessary to understand all the necessary factors if we want to make autonomous driving systems more reliable. At the very least we need to understand whether the pedestrian appeared in the other sensors that a human could have identified by looking at the sensor data, and if yes, whether the autonomous system matched or exceeded human-level performance by detecting the pedestrian, and if the pedestrian was indeed detected, why the autonomous driving system failed to respond to the situation.
- Scoundreller 9y agoIn North America, isn’t the vehicle owner usually liable, regardless of who is driving?
- ptaipale 9y agoSurely not? Cars are routinely driven by people who are not owners, and liability for traffic offences (including that the vehicle must be insured) is with the driver.
- Scoundreller 9y agoI mean in terms of who gets sued for personal injuries. Or to repair damaged vehicles.
- MaupitiBlue 9y agoNo. The general rule is that negligence is required to be held responsible. If I let my next door neighbor borrow my car to go to the grocery store, and he hits someone, I'm not responsible. Unless, the person can prove "negligent entrustment", i.e. it was irresponsible just to let this person borrow my car, e.g. they're a habitual drunk, or blind, or 11. However, most auto liability insurance covers whoever you permit to drive the vehicle, so the owners policy does typically cover the fender bender on the way to the grocery store.
- andygates 9y agoThis car failed the moose test. Legal details aren't relevant, it's plain rubbish. This is test track pre-alpha stuff, for crying out loud.