5 ms·
> The gap between street lights (and hence the person) was in the field of view of the camera the entire time But the gap between street lights is going to be
by pdonis 9y ago
> The gap between street lights (and hence the person) was in the field of view of the camera the entire time
But the gap between street lights is going to be very hard to see into.
> I'm confident my eyes are good enough that I would have been able to see this person at night in these lighting conditions.
I think you're overconfident. Human low light vision is very good if there is low light everywhere. But it is not good at seeing into low light regions when brightly lit regions are nearby.
That said, I agree that a visible light video camera is likely to be even worse that human vision under the given circumstances. But as others have commented elsewhere in this thread, the car is not just supposed to be using a visible light video camera. It has LIDAR and IR sensors, which should have clearly shown the pedestrian well before visible light did.
- hcknwscommenter 9y ago> But the gap between street lights is going to be very hard to see into. This wholly contradicts my experience driving at night on a street with street lights. I can't recall a time in my entire life I have had significant difficulty seeing into the gap between street lights. Keep in mind that the gap is not arbitrarily chosen. Edited to note that I have experienced difficulties in low-vis conditions such as snow storms, sand storms, VERY strong rain storms, etc. None of which apply to this situation.
- eanzenberg 9y agoAlso in those stormy conditions you slow down enough where the stopping power should roughly equal your visibility.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoKeep in mind a lot of folks in this thread might be suddenly realizing they have reduced ocular ability at night, a likely common condition that pretty much nobody is aware of when it’s minor (because it’s not obvious something is amiss; maybe it’s just that dark). I agree with you that streetlights and headlights are almost universally sufficient in my experience. If they’re not, it’s worth getting your eyes checked out for light sensitivity at night. You never know. I’m not sure a typical eye exam checks for it, either, because none of the tests I can think of seem like they’d be useful. (As usual, an even keeled comment based on family experience is -2 and rapidly being silenced with zero feedback inside 5 minutes, which makes me wonder why I contribute to this community at all, probably time to stop)
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoI suspect it's too late to chnage now but have a "throwaway" account is an indicator you might not be committed to the community. one has to dig a little deeper to find out a multi year history with 4000 karma. so first impressions of your comments might be getting biased (it might just the "red car effect" but i am seeing a lot more throwaway accounts these days) I would also not judge the community based on reactions to this very contentious thread - i am wary of jumping in on this one, but thought it worth noting your comment was not wildly out of place. stay, we have cookies :-)
- nugi 9y agoJudging a comment, or commenter, based on karma is asinine. Respond to comment, not commenter; ideas not people. You are not well representing HN, and this is my 'unpopular opinion' account talking. There are plenty of better ways to engage, and I do appreciate your enthusiasm for HN. Perhaps this is an apt introduction to the heated discussion that is HN.
- acdha 9y agoThis may be how you believe you see the world but most people take reputation into consideration and on sites which expose that information account age and karma are very popular cues for that.
- buvanshak 9y agoKarma does not mean shit. It just means you are complaisant. I think the proper way to use things like HN/reddit is to always use a throwaway account and always speak your mind without the fear of negative karma...So I also agree 100% with the parent. Reply the comment, not the commenters, their karma or their entire history.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoWell, in my view I was responding both to the comment ("i am leaving") and the commentor (making the years of participation and 4000 points relevant). If someone has been a contributor for many years then we should consider why they chose to leave. it might be them, it might be us. I actually believe i am representing HN as a place where different opinions can be voiced, hopefully in a manner to generate light not heat. Heated discussions are rarely the useful or interesting ones to read. Thank you for appreciating my enthusiasm. PS Are you using two accounts - one ("my 'unpopular opinion' account) for saying things you fear people might not like? That seems odd. May I ask why?
- pdonis 9y ago> Keep in mind that the gap is not arbitrarily chosen. It's not supposed to be, no. But the gaps are not always optimal. The spacing of the street lights in the video (to the extent I can tell) seems to be quite wide, wider than I would think is optimal.
- throwaway2048 9y agoThe edges of the "lightpool" that the lamps normally cast is probly being clipped by the cameras crappy dynamic contrast, it is almost certainly a much larger lightpool in real life.
- pdonis 9y ago> it is almost certainly a much larger lightpool in real life. Not according to the post by niftich upthread.
- thomasz 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XOVxSCG8u0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XOVxSCG8u0
- Natsu 9y agoNot usually, and I say this as someone who has spent a lot of time driving nearby roads at night.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf Tempe is like Tuscon, they are using different kinds of street lighting from the rest of the country to minimize light pollution for star gazing reasons.
- jcranmer 9y ago> But the gap between street lights is going to be very hard to see into. Looking, right now, at a parking lot between two lights from a well-lit room. I can make out most of the outline of the black car in the middle of the "darkness" without any trouble. This isn't even the low light vision kicking in (which I agree isn't going to kick in if you're driving). Human vision should be able to make out the pedestrian earlier than the video footage.
- pdonis 9y agoHow long does it take you to make out the black car and determine that it's a car? What if the car were coming straight at you out of darkness and you were standing in the light of a street lamp? Also, are you looking straight at the car? Or are you looking elsewhere so that the car is in your peripheral vision, the way it would be if it were on the side of a road you were driving on?
- pishpash 9y agoA moving object would be more visible than usual. Human vision is better at picking up scene change.
- Retric 9y agoNot when you transition from high to low light conditions. The problem is night vision has more noise which makes movement detection far more difficult. This is made worse because the pupil can't fully dilate making the gaps seem much darker.
- stormthebeach 9y agoThis street in particular is weird at night because the street downstream rises up, and the light from those lamps is cast at a higher point. The place she was hit is extremely dangerous because there are no lights on her, and no lights behind her.
- niftich 9y agoFWIW the spot where the crash happened is in fact badly lit. I know this anecdotally from having been at the location for events -- it's right next to a concert venue -- but it can also be seen on other dashcam videos. In this video [1] driving northbound, same as the vehicle in the crash, the car first goes under AZ-202, emerges under a streetlight, goes through a darker spot, then another streetlight (as you see the rocky outcrop), and then a very dark spot: and suddenly, you see a right-turn lane that wasn't there before. The latter dark spot is where the crash happened. Another video by the same author, driving southbound [2], provides another useful reference. And these videos are three years old, yet the illumination of the roadway has not improved. Cameras exaggerate the contrast a bit, but not unreasonably so. The streetlights in question essentially aim directly downwards, illuminating the roadway immediately underneath, but much less of the surrounding air than other designs. This is responsible for the dark gaps, albeit it does significantly reduce light pollution. [1] https://youtu.be/zEaTdYJExq8?t=8m50s https://youtu.be/zEaTdYJExq8?t=8m50s [2] https://youtu.be/yfR7krN7z00?t=23m26s https://youtu.be/yfR7krN7z00?t=23m26s EDIT: Found more. The car in this video is going southbound, camera facing backwards [3]. This view faces the same way as the Uber did, but of course this video is moving away from the scene, and offset by a few dozen meters to the west. The drastic change in roadway illumination can still be seen. In a fourth video [4], the car is going northbound, like the Uber, in the proper lanes, but the camera is pointing obliquely front-right. The illumination seems better, but you can still see the intensity of the shadows, including environmental shadows and the car's own shadow, as it moves between the lights. [3] https://youtu.be/0Dum8Fj71JU?t=13s https://youtu.be/0Dum8Fj71JU?t=13s [4] https://youtu.be/6qHcuW_LCIU?t=16m45s https://youtu.be/6qHcuW_LCIU?t=16m45s
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIs Tempe like Tucson in explicitly aiming for low light pollution? It does make for some nice star gazing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Natsu 9y ago