4 ms·
I think this seems like exactly the scenario that autonomous driving vehicles are intended to prevent. may be optimistic. Lots of people are hoping they will p
by maxerickson 9y ago
I think this seems like exactly the scenario that autonomous driving vehicles are intended to prevent. may be optimistic.
Lots of people are hoping they will prevent such scenarios, the motivation for fielding them is more related to making lots of money.
- adamweld 9y agoI disagree, if you look at any of the Waymo videos you can see they have great recognition of every car, pedestrian, and obstacle within 100 meters of the car, and most of that data (point cloud lidar/radar at the very least) would work in pitch black without even headlights. Thus it's extremely reasonable to expect that autonomous vehicles will easily prevent scenarios like this. Inclement conditions, defensive driving, etc. are much harder to work with but this should have been cake.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf you turn your headlights off on a dark country road, your sight capabilities actually go up, not down. The problem is: most roads are lit or you st least have to compete with other headlights, and it would make you harder to see.
- _up 9y agoThere was also a recent lawsuit where Uber pledged to not use any lidar tech and software from Waymo anymore. Maybe they had to deactivate Lidar.
- asteli 9y agoLIDAR in question on this vehicle is an HDL-64, a commercial unit from Velodyne. Lawsuit is entirely unrelated.
- user5994461 9y agoIf you look at any demo video from the manufacturer, the product is always perfect and amazing.
- chrsstrm 9y agoGo to [0] and [1] and count how many times they use the word "safe." We're not hoping autonomous vehicles are safer, we're being sold on them as the safer alternative. So yes, this type of close call situation is exactly where these vehicles are supposed to be superior. [0] https://waymo.com/ https://waymo.com/ [1] https://www.uber.com/info/atg/ https://www.uber.com/info/atg/
- maxerickson 9y agoWhy should I take their marketing at face value? Of course they are selling them as safe. I still think the funding to work on them is chasing big piles of money.
- jachee 9y agoHuman-driven car fatalities per day: 120+ Automated-car fatalities total: 1 Seems safer, so far. Also, nothing's going to make walking out in front of a ton of steel going 30+mph 100% safe.
- dictum 9y agoThat's a very misleading comparison, even as an informal, rough comparison for the sake of argument. Such a comparison would have to take into account the amount of human-driven cars and automated cars - not just taking a picture of a single day, but the variance over time (e.g. if today there are a thousand automated cars in operation, and yesterday there were 50, that can distort the average stats); automated cars aren't driving in certain areas/times/weather conditions whereas human-driven cars are, etc. Automated cars may be safer, but, open snark – I hope it's not calculating its sensor data in this way — close snark.
- thousandautumns 9y agoThis isn't the first automated car fatality though right? Hasn't Tesla had some?
- adrianmonk 9y agoMaybe a better word than "intended" would be "expected". As in, most normal, rational, reasonable people basically familiar with the technology involved expect this to be preventable.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoBeing buried in lawsuits isn't a great way to make money, generally speaking. The people hoping to make lots of money at this should have a pretty high level of motivation to make it safe.