10 ms·
Sources: Google is buying Lytro for about $40M
- nradov 9y agoWell that was the logical outcome. Their technology was interesting but it clearly wasn't viable as a stand-alone compact camera. Everyone expected it would eventually be integrated into smartphones.
- greglindahl 9y agoOr, as is often said in the Valley: "Is it a product, or a feature?"
- guardian5x 9y agoIt could be smartphones, i also think the technology would be interesting for streetview.
- Gibbon1 9y agoI thought they had switched from consumer camera's to large 3D light field camera's for shooting movies.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoThey tried to build the whole ecosystem around light field photography themselves. To do that, they would need to raise Magic Leap levels of capital, which they decided not to do.
- cmac2992 9y agoAwesome. After playing with Google's go pro light field images, it's really hard to go back and enjoy regular 360 photos. The quality and 6dof sense of presence. was amazing. Hopefully the addition of lytros tech makes it even better.
- modeless 9y agoThese are the mentioned light field images: https://www.blog.google/products/google-vr/experimenting-light-fields/ https://www.blog.google/products/google-vr/experimenting-lig... They can only be experienced properly with a positionally tracked VR headset, but they are extremely cool if you have one.
- owenversteeg 9y agoHTC Vive, Oculus Rift, and Windows Mixed Reality headsets... and it seems like Windows Mixed Reality headsets are available for around $200 on Amazon. Wow, we live in the future. I guess the main cost here is the PC attached to them... probably costs about $500 minimum if I'd have to guess for something with the specs required. [edit] wow, you can get an Asus pre-built desktop for $440, damn! i5-7400, 12gb DDR4, 2TB HDD, graphics good enough for VR... wow. Anyone know if it's possible to build your own for a competitive price, or if that'd drive up the cost? I remember the days when it was cheaper to build your own...
- cmac2992 9y agoWhat GPU is in that prebuilt? I think you'd probably want a 1070 especially for windows MR headsets. Right now with gpu and memory prices inflated due to cryto mining, prebuilts are very competitively priced. If you want to build your own, definitely go with a motherboard gpu bundle otherwise you'll be paying $$$ for a gpu.
- watersb 9y agoWhen I saw Google's spherical-photo capture bot -- basically an array of Lytro cameras -- I figured this would happen soon.
- ipsum2 9y agoCan you link me to this? I only know that Google is using GoPros to do light field capture: https://petapixel.com/2018/03/15/google-built-arc-16-gopros-light-field-photography/ https://petapixel.com/2018/03/15/google-built-arc-16-gopros-...
- Robotbeat 9y agoNo, they were regular GoPros frame-synced and spun around to act as even more cameras. You can, in fact, do this with a single regular camera (with a wide-field lense) if you're patient enough and have a multi-axis motorized (and encodered) mount.
- chirau 9y agoI remember Ben Horowitz singing praises for this company. Must be a good pay day for A16Z.
- nigelcleland 9y agoFrom the article, the sale price is estimated at $40 million, whilst the company had raised $200 million, most recently at a $360 million valuation. Most likely not a good pay day, definitely a significant haircut for some of the investors to say the least.
- vadimberman 9y agoAgree, and given the standard "liquidity preference", the founders are likely to net $0, except for the Google bonuses for the engineering (Jack Barker-like Rosenthal is not likely to stick there). It's sad, really. It's one of the really innovative companies, but it's not easy to sell tech ahead of its time. Yet another incident that will encourage to pick copycats over real innovation. I guess Google is no longer as generous with the acquisitions.
- dpandya 9y ago> It's sad, really. It's one of the really innovative companies, but it's not easy to sell tech ahead of its time. This glorifies failure quite a bit. One major objective of tech companies is to produce products that customers value and like. Lytro failed to do this. Just because the underlying science is complicated doesn't make the tech "ahead of its time" due to the fact that maybe the tech, as implemented, just isn't what people want, now or in the future! Having complicated science underlying a product certainly doesn't excuse a company from producing products that people want.
- coldtea 9y ago>Lytro failed to do this. Just because the underlying science is complicated doesn't make the tech "ahead of its time" due to the fact that maybe the tech, as implemented, just isn't what people want, now or in the future! As we speaking abstractly? What theoretically could be if we didn't know anything about the tech? Because otherwise this specific tech is very much an "ahead of its time" technology, whether consumers adopted it or not. Besides, consumer adoption is a BS test for a technology being ahead of its time. Failure in the market can simply be because the implementation was not good, or the marketing wasn't, or the support was lacking, or the price too high, or 200 other reasons, that don't depend on the technology not being ahead of its time.
- bwang29 9y agoLytro has really cool technology but never really found a good use case for consumers. I owned both the 1st generation and 2nd generation camera, as much as I hated the UI of the software and usability of the hardware, I can clearly see the team has tried really hard to make it usable. They tried building an editing app, a community, a community 2.0, multiple hardware batch revisions. I wonder why they didn’t stop sooner or up to which point they feel like this direction is done. I felt they never really listened to the photographer community during the process, or answer support sufficiently, they have done pretty much the exact opposite of user first or user driven product development in my opinion, and this still left me confused today. Burning a few million dollars a month, I feel it really took a series of very bad decisions to lead to this financial outcome.
- samstave 9y agoThey are buying them to make dash cams for self driving cars is my guess... That tech in dash-cam video is priceless
- akhatri_aus 9y agoIt's likely for VR, the 'reverse' of the Lytro allows projection to the eye at multiple focal points.
- Kyragem 9y agoValued at 360M in the last funding round and Google buys it for 40M. Pennies on the $ ROI for the VCs :-)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Deimorz 9y agoIf you have a VR headset, I highly suggest trying out the "Welcome to Light Fields" demo that Google released on Steam last week (it's free): http://store.steampowered.com/app/771310/Welcome_to_Light_Fields/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/771310/Welcome_to_Light_Fi... It's absolutely incredible and seems like really promising technology. Even with the relatively low resolution of current headsets, the image quality is amazing and you can see some slight lighting changes as you move your head, which makes it feel far more immersive than a static photo. There should be a lot of potential to use this for extremely realistic virtual tours. Note: I had some slight issues with it "hitching" at the start of each scene in the guided tour (which made me feel a bit of motion-sickness), but that was probably because I didn't install it on an SSD (or my PC is just not quite fast enough overall). There weren't any issues when viewing the scenes individually afterwards.
- rjth 9y agoAs someone who has been working with stereo 180 videos in VR for the past few months, this technology makes such a huge difference. While stereo photography looks broken from most angles, Google's lightfields demo just felt natural. Honestly, one of the best VR experiences I've tried in a while.
- owenversteeg 9y agoHuh, that'd certainly explain why Google wanted to pay $40MM for it. Thanks!
- bb88 9y agoI thought the future of light field cameras would be to replace the bulky DSLR's and their lenses. If you can do that, then autofocus systems go away completely. What you're left with is the shutter and zoom, and the computer's ability to make beautiful bokeh from any image.
- fudged71 9y agoThe problem is the sensor cost. You are sacrificing pixels for information/depth, meaning you need more pixels for the same result. Most people aren't willing to go back to a 2MP camera when much better image quality cameras are on the market.
- bb88 9y agoMaybe not the home user, but people are willing to pay lots of money for photography gear if it gets the results they want. Broncolor, Hasselblad, Leica and Zeiss, all come to mind as specialty companies that make money from selling expensive gear.
- micheljansen 9y agoFor AR & VR this makes perfect sense. In VR space you do not want to be stuck with a single predetermined focus point, but have the freedom to move around the light field. Lytro's patents alone are probably a steal at $40M.
- evilset 9y agoI'll be waiting for you OASIS, but not so soon.
- neves 9y agoCan someone explain to me reasoning of the deal? It looks to me more some kind of Silicon Valley brotherhood deal. Sure 40m to Google is change money, but it is a failed company and they could duplicate the tech with far less.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- neves 9y agoMaybe it is the 59 patents...
- kypro 9y agoThe fact many of the employees seem to have been given severance would imply that to me.
- jmalicki 9y agoAre they not even keeping the computational photography engineers? I can see jettisoning the rest, but I presumed this might be an acquihire of some great minds in computational photography to beef up the Pixel Camera team?
- m3kw9 9y agoThis tells me the tech isn’t too useful from the price and from the buyer and the amount of time it took to get a sale on that price. That’s beside the fact that it does this selective focus thing which should be automatic anyways or selected during the shot.
- Jtsummers 9y agoAlong with selective focus (which struck me as gimmicky) you do get 3d images from a single sensor with better detail than a stereoscopic setup (2x standard cameras). This is useful for computational work as you can get better spatial data from one source or if you add multiple sensors you can get even more improvement. I always figured this would be used in a fashion similar to synthetic aperture radar, but using image data, and applied to autonomous vehicles and similar applications. It's better than edge detection from a standard single sensor. And you have more to train your algorithms on since they can recognize what is an actual object more easily versus what is an image of an object.
- mseebach 9y agoI tried to click around on Lytro's website, but it left me pretty baffled. What the f... is it?
- w0m 9y agoA camera that allows you to 'focus after the fact'. Actually pretty sweet tech; though it never really caught on.
- Jtsummers 9y agoLytro makes light field cameras. A single sensor can be used to capture enough information to do a lot of computational imagery work like the somewhat gimmicky example of changing focus. But you also have enough data to do things like accurately apply filters to parts of an image based on depth information. A good simulation of viewing the image through caustics or other distortion effects. And, to me the most interesting, reconstruct 3d information from a single sensor. Downsides, a 16 megapixel sensor only got something like 4 megapixel of image resolution because of how much data has to be captured for the light field. So consumer grade sensors resulted in (by contemporary standards) very low resolution images. And all those neat effects weren't really available, except maybe to their commercial partners (later products and services). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-field_camera https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-field_camera
- mseebach 9y agoThanks!
- jonbarker 9y agoLight field cameras always fascinated me because they are the example of the literal opposite of evolutionary biological inspiration (this is not an insult by the way). The first biological 'eyes' were probably light sensitive spots on skin with no lenses or shape, which then became cavities for directional sensing and then lenses and retinas developed to enable image recognition.
- electrograv 9y agoThe compound eyes of some insects are very similar to how a lightfield camera is optically structured.
- Dirlewanger 9y agoHasn't Photoshop had this tech for a couple years now? I remember seeing on HN a video of Adobe demonstrating it at a conference.
- vernie 9y agoWhich tech are you referring to?
- John_KZ 9y agoLytro captures true depth information. Sure, you can blur things in Photoshop, but it simply doesn't look like the real, depth-of-field based blur on real lenses, or the calculated one of light-field cameras. Re-focusing on photoshop is just a gimmic to fake the real thing (and if you're experienced in photography you can always tell)
- rweba 9y agoThis should not be viewed as a failure. This is the nature of startups, even if you do every single thing right, work hard, manage the cash flow, innovate, etc., there is a more than 90% chance you won't get that billion dollar plus exit. The only unique thing here is that Lytro got a lot of hype and raised a lot of money, so people naturally expected a unicorn. What I am saying is these guys don't necessarily have anything to be ashamed of. In the worst case they gained a lot of experience that they can apply to their next idea. That said, I am curious: Will the founders get ANY money out of it? A comment claimed that they raised $200 million at $360 million valuation, so theoretically they may end up with nothing.
- inuhj 9y agoMy estimate is that the founders took money off the table during those rounds. It's doubtful they'll see anything from the sale. I wouldn't worry too much about them I'm sure they're sitting fine.