6 ms·
I've encountered some hostility when I've said I've been in the Army (I don't volunteer the information out of the blue - people ask me what I did before I did
by chrisseaton 9y ago
I've encountered some hostility when I've said I've been in the Army (I don't volunteer the information out of the blue - people ask me what I did before I did my PhD so I tell them).
As the other person said, some people I've met at conferences have ended the conversation with me or told me they think it's immoral.
One person at a major Ruby conference casually literally asked me if I enjoyed killing babies.
Many people have the craziest ideas of what the military and war is like that have no connection whatsoever to reality. It's scary that civil society understands so little of the military now that it's so small and professional.
- aphextron 9y ago>It's scary that civil society understands so little of the military now that it's so small and professional. I'd say overall it's a good thing. It's a very good thing that 99% of people will never be able to remotely comprehend what we went through.
- guelo 9y agoWhen a lot of more the population served in Vietnam the country turned against the war. Nowadays nobody seems to care that America's longest war continues on.
- adventured 9y agoThat's because they're not even remotely comparable things, as you note. Afghanistan is a security operation, not a traditional war. There's no draft, thousands of US soldiers aren't dying in Afghanistan. Even the cost is a modest fraction of the total US military budget. There were 15 US casualties in Afghanistan in 2017, and 14 in 2016. That's not a war. That's a security operation.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> There were 15 US casualties in Afghanistan in 2017, and 14 in 2016. There were 15 US fatalities, not casualties. I'm sure there were many more casualties - many of them life changing injuries.
- adrianpike 9y ago> One person at a major Ruby conference casually literally asked me if I enjoyed killing babies. That's horrible man, I'm sorry somebody was that callous.
- teej 9y agoI'm sorry this happened to you.
- matte_black 9y agoI had no idea this was a thing in SV, I can’t imagine anyone having anything but utmost respect for those that have served in the military.
- refurb 9y agoI'm glad you have the perspective that these comments are coming from people who have no clue. Easier to brush off as crazy talk.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- watersb 9y ago> Many people have the craziest ideas of what the military and war is like that have no connection whatsoever to reality. It's scary that civil society understands so little of the military now that it's so small and professional. I totally believe this, and it makes me very angry. Volunteer for service, suspend your civil rights, vow to defend the Constitution, develop the technical skills, physical ability, and mental toughness to serve in combat, and lay it all on the line for fellow soldiers -- and return to a universe of people who cannot identify Khandahar on a map, and think they are morally superior... well, I would have issues. (FWIW I have never served in the military, I don't like the chain of top-level decisions that led to a decade of active military deployment.)
- Consultant32452 9y agoThe thing that bugs me is that there's no middle. People appear to either be the type of asshole OP mentioned or they idolize soldiers in an equally terrifying way. I view the military as a job. It's not a job I would want, but there's tons of jobs I don't want. In peace time it's pretty effective at helping people move up the economic ladder. In war time it provides trained killers to take out the bad guys. I don't say that flippantly, that's an important and necessary part of maintaining our civilization. Any beef I might have about things the military might be doing at any given time is better directed at political leadership than the boots on the ground.
- watersb 9y agoVery good point. I think this is objectivization -- exactly the sort of cognitive glitch when I encounter people who look very different from what I am used to. I like to think that with decades of practice, I can anticipate this reaction, or at least catch myself quickly, or Plan C: apologize. Usually all of the above. People are not mythological creatures. But getting civil society to stumble along, on a path together, has employed no small amount of storytelling and manipulation. As American as apple pie, I suppose.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoThere’s some moral hazard in treating self-sacrifice-and-killing as merely a job. Idealizing what warriors do on your behalf (imagine it was actually to defend your people not the interests of an empire) is an important way that humans deal with the act of killing. I don’t think you want cold blooded killers who do it for a meager paycheck, as opposed to the glory and heroism of defending others.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 9y agoWow. No connection whatsoever with reality indeed.