4 ms·
Back in about 1988, Bruce Porter, one of my AI professors, described the problem statement of the Fifth Generation project as, "a list of important research top
by mcguire 9y ago
Back in about 1988, Bruce Porter, one of my AI professors, described the problem statement of the Fifth Generation project as, "a list of important research topics like natural language understanding, speech recognition, and so forth, and the statement, 'Therefore we will build a parallel Prolog machine.'" He wasn't a fan.
On the other hand, according to the tech press at the time, the Japanese were going to eat our lunch. Put us all out of work. Rule the world with an iron fist.
- segmondy 9y agoA Parallel prolog machine is a great idea. Just because it failed to take off doesn't mean the idea shouldn't be explored again. The difference in CPU design in 88 and today is amazing. Prolog is one of those languages that just automatically lends itself well to AND/OR conditions without having to change any code. I personally still see a future there, Von Neumaan has only taken us so far. We need alternate CPU designs.
- tlb 9y agoI agree, along with a huge range of parallel machines. Parallel machines weren't a great idea in the early 90s, because you could barely get one decent CPU on a chip and adding memory turned it into a large board per core. Now you can have satisfying numbers of CPUs plus memory on a single chip, and even a useful prototype on an FPGA.
- PaulHoule 9y agoThe 5th generation project found that Prolog isn't very parallelizable and thus they created a language called KL1 which was more parallelizable than Prolog but not as good in other ways.
- wrp 9y agoThere were a few nearly identical parallelizations of Prolog. Besides KL1, there were Concurrent Prolog, GHC, Paralog, Strand, and Aldwych. The structure of Prolog-like concurrent systems is like the Actor model, based on message passing, and shares the problem of indeterminacy in the ordering of messages. These systems had to drop backtracking, because that requires access to a global stack. In the end, it proved difficult to implement clause invocation in these languages as efficiently as procedure invocation in object-oriented programming languages. The combination of efficient inheritance-based procedure invocation together with class libraries and browsers was better than the slower pattern-directed clause invocation of the FGCS programming languages, so concurrent object-oriented message-passing languages like Java and C# became the mainstream. I would suggest that the relational database approach is simpler and about as powerful as the rule-based approach to knowledge processing. From a practical point of view, any row of a Relatonal DataBase System table can be considered as a rule, provided that at least one attribute has been selected as an output.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> On the other hand, according to the tech press at the time, the Japanese were going to eat our lunch. Put us all out of work. Rule the world with an iron fist. Sound familiar? Thankfully history doesn’t repeat itself with another Asian country going all in on AI with a scary huge real estate bubble.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jonathanyc 9y agoDrawing trite parallels is very ha-ha, but we have to remember that while Japan only has half the population of the US, China’s population is much more. It’s a little suspicious arguing that one Japanese person is somehow destined to be more productive and inventive than two American people; it is even more suspicious arguing the same for one American and five Chinese.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe parallels are downright freaky. Think about it: * Sense that they will rule the world * Incredibly bubbly real estate market * Exporting this bubble to North America west coast * Huge bets on AI * Zombie companies (SOEs) * Rapidly aging worforce Yes, there are some difference, China is much larger than Japan but it is also much poorer than Japan (on a per capita basis). The country as a whole isn't that well educated (compulsory education only goes to 9th grade, extremely uneven resources applied to rural areas and different cities). Who knows how this will play off, I'm guessing a China crash will be much worse in scale than Japan coming down in the late 80s/early 90s, but China will also be able to recover much more quickly after it happens given there is still room for development.
- mieseratte 9y ago> one American and five Chinese How many Chinese are meaningfully in the present? As I understood it, there was still a non-trivial population living in a less-than-modern way.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> He wasn't a fan. Given the historical circumstances, I'll be he would prefer they were trying to build a parallel Lisp machine.
- mcguire 9y agoIf I remember correctly, we did have a lab full of TI Lisp machines at the time. Never used them myself, though. The interesting point, though, was that the specific goals were not clearly related to the fundamental reasons for doing it. And as it turned out, most of the research topics (but not all, IIRC) were really boosted by work in graphics co-processors.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoMy understanding was that, at the time, Lisp and Prolog were the two "languages of AI", with Lisp favoured in the US and Prolog in Europe and Japan. Knowing how language arguments go, I assume that an AI professor who didn't like the idea the Japanese were going for Prolog would be naturally preferring Lisp. I might be wrong :) As to the 5th generation computer project, what little I've read so far has more or less convinced me that special-purpose processors will never be better than general-purpose ones, at least not for general-purpose computing (which, ultimately, was the aim of the project). I'm saying that as a dyed-in-the-wool symbolist btw (and a long-time Prolog user). Special-purpose processors to make my Prolog go faster is something I'd love to get my hands on- but, for most people? I think it's not even number 1000 in their list of priorities ot improve computing performance.
- lispm 9y agoBasically most AI/Lisp vendors also offered a Prolog in Lisp. As a Prolog implementation the standalone Prolog compilers were faster and had more Prolog features, but since the Lisp tools were a bit more mature, even in Japan some projects used Prolog in Lisp. There was a lot of research for AI hardware in the 80s and also for Prolog hardware. I once saw a Japanese Prolog Machine (a special purpose workstation with a Prolog environment), but I didn't have the chance to actually use it. With faster/cheaper Intel or RISC processors and a lack of research funding, the topic of specialized hardware was mostly ending in the early 90s.
- 2sk21 9y agoI confess that I too fell for the 5th gen hype and spent a couple years diving deep into Prolog in the mid 80s. It wasn't a total waste however, I still find my knowledge of Prolog coming in handy. Logic programming is an interesting concept, but not in the way they envisaged it in the 80s. In particular, I am fascinated by answer set programming. There is no need to shoe-hard Turing completeness into logic programming.