5 ms·
The trust issue is something I can confirm. Until 2008 I believed that the market was fair overall and you gain if you do something right and lose if you do som
by maxxxxx 9y ago
The trust issue is something I can confirm. Until 2008 I believed that the market was fair overall and you gain if you do something right and lose if you do something wrong. Then I had to learn that there is a whole group of people that can't lose. We have to admire them and listen to them while they make profits and when they screw up we have to bail them out and still listen to their "wisdom". This definitely made me very cynical.
- dman 9y agoI was disappointed as well. Initially I believed that the downturn would work in the same way as a forest fire - clearing out dead wood so that new growth can occur. I hoped at the time that a new class of financial firm would emerge as a result - smaller, nimbler and more adept at its use of technology. I was incorrect and those things I hoped for did not come to pass. In fact one sad observation is that in the years following the downturn mismanaged banks outperformed the better managed ones as investments since their bounce back was much sharper.
- lend000 9y agoPretty tough to clear out dead wood when the institutions of relevance are more or less locked into their positions through heavy-handed regulation. The most glaring examples of this are the credit reporting agencies, who are defined by name in the US legal code with their special positions, rules, and privileges as involuntary private data collectors. Shouldn't come as a surprise that Equifax recovered so quickly.
- mjevans 9y agoWhat made me cynical was that the government didn't step in and handle it the same way that a private citizen having untenable obligations would be handled. I expected the failed institutions to literally be seized, and an orderly re-distribution of assets processed. I also expected, as a result, a correction in the price of housing to actually realistic levels. I was extremely naive about the housing issue; I had not realized how artificially constrained the markets were and how (at least in the US if not elsewhere) government regulations continue to distort the market towards artificial shortage. It all needs to be repaired and re-worked, but regulatory capture and conflict of voter interest by those who've made it in to the 'I have mine' status is far too systemic.
- PoachedSausage 9y agoYou are correct, it is for the time being politically untenable to allow housing (really land) to reduce in value. The situation might change when the millenials and younger generations start becoming more politically active.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAs soon as they start inheriting houses they will also be against lower housing prices.
- perfmode 9y agothis is not a reality for the majority.
- PoachedSausage 9y agoI probably just about count as a millenial, my parents could live another 20 - 30 years and that house might have to be sold to pay their hospice care should they get dementia. So the house likely isn't going to be much use to me.
- noonespecial 9y ago>that house might have to be sold to pay their hospice care I suspect this is the great Faustian bargain of the boomer generation. All the wealth that they helped themselves to in lieu of fixing the big systemic problems in economy and government will be traded away in the end for the modicum of comfort in their twilight years that a better functioning system would have provided anyway.
- dmix 9y ago> The situation might change when the millenials and younger generations start becoming more politically active. Yes, the self-serving regulatory system that was repeatedly taken advantage of to benefit a small group of property owners in previous generations will be solved by the next generation who will inherit or earn properties of their own... /s When power repeatedly corrupts those whose define the rules then maybe the solution is stop stop giving them power? Or at a minimum limit their power...instead of handing it to the next guy with no changes and expecting different results.
- rhino369 9y agoYou should also realize that people who did everything right lost. You could be a profitable employee at Bear Stearns, but a bunch of yahoos on a different floor could implode the company. You can be an autoparts manufacturer whose line of credit got stopped because of a global credit crisis. You can be a student with a job lined up who happened to graduate in 2009 and have your offer revoked. The market isn't a meritocracy.
- maxxxxx 9y agoCorrect. What bothered me was that the people who did things right and had no responsibility lost a lot whereas the responsible people stayed or walked away with a lot of money. At minimum some bank execs should have lost everything. Absolutely everything and then some more.
- skookumchuck 9y agoThe FDIC means that banks no longer need to care about solvency. It's not the market doing that, it's government interference.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThe FDIC could seize banks (don't they?) and still protect deposits up to the 250k limit. They could also require claw-back clauses for banks that want FDIC protection. Without the FDIC the first thing banks would have done in 2008 would have been to drop the savings accounts of a lot of regular people. It plays an important role for the average citizen.
- skookumchuck 9y ago> Without the FDIC the first thing banks would have done in 2008 would have been to drop the savings accounts of a lot of regular people. Banks go out of business if they get a reputation for defaulting on depositors' accounts. After all, would you deposit money in such a bank? I wouldn't, either. Depositors would still have legal recourse against the bank, too.
- LarryDarrell 9y agoCompletely anecdotal: I know more socialist leaning people now in my late 30s than I did as a college student in my early 20s. There are many people out there who once believed in the system, did what they thought they were supposed to do, and now feel like they were suckers.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWe should stop using the label "socialist" for anything that's slightly different from the current status. It makes a serious discussion almost impossible (which often is the intended outcome). There are plenty of things that can be changed before the US turns into a socialist country.