3 ms·
I do wonder if Tesla's biggest problem around the Model 3 launch was starting by establishing very aggressive production targets. According to Bloomberg's Mode
by slg 9y ago
I do wonder if Tesla's biggest problem around the Model 3 launch was starting by establishing very aggressive production targets. According to Bloomberg's Model 3 Tracker linked in that article, the Model 3 already is the top selling electric car in the country. It outsold the Chevy Bolt by over 2x in January and February. That should be a huge accomplishment, but it is viewed as a failure because it is a small fraction of what Tesla initially predicted.
- robterrell 9y agoCherry-picking Jan and Feb obscures the fact that the Bolt seems to be extremely competitive. Bolt outsold Tesla Model 3 by 3x in Dec (3,227 versus 1,060). And it's true that January was down for the Bolt, but not by 2x (1,177 versus 1,875). Tesla's production woes are a serious problem. My i3 lease is up in a couple of months and I can't even consider replacing it with a Model 3, since the end of the reservation line is years out.
- slg 9y agoAccording to the previously mentioned Bloomberg tracker, Tesla built 5,933 in January and February. Tesla is selling and delivering the Model 3 as fast as they can built them. GM delivered 2,601 Bolts in January and February. Choosing January and February is not cherry picking because Tesla is ramping up production of the Model 3. That said, I acknowledge that the Bolt may have some seasonal effect that greatly increased sales at the end of last year when compared to the beginning of this year. Let's expand the January-February window back another month to account for that. We get 6,993 Model 3s versus 5,828 Bolts. No longer over 2x but still clearly outselling the Bolt.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Judgmentality 9y agoIt's also worth mentioning that the Bolt is a loss leader for GM, so they are actually losing money on those cars. I think it's reasonable to worry that the economics for Tesla, who have far less experience manufacturing cars at scale, could be even worse. I am bearish on Tesla, but I never thought they would get this far, so obviously I've been wrong before. My suspicion though is if Tesla isn't self-sustaining before the next economic downturn, they're fucked.
- jagger27 9y agoI think most Bolts are leases, so it probably works out in the end for GM.
- nradov 9y agoWorks out how? Bolts are compliance vehicles, sold by GM to meet fleet fuel efficiency and emissions requirements. Selling Bolts at a loss enables them to continue selling larger vehicles which actually turn a profit. Hopefully in a few more years battery costs will drop enough to make electric cars profitable in their own right.
- Nokinside 9y ago> That should be a huge accomplishment, but it is viewed as a failure because it is a small fraction of what Tesla initially predicted. It's a failure because Tesla made financial bet that they deliver high volumes of Model 3. It does not matter if Model 3 is good car and customers love it. Tesla must ramp up their production very fast or Tesla runs out of cheap money. Tesla has no problems with customers love the car with passion. It's the investors who will choke Musk to death later this year if he has to ask more money to continue with struggling production. He will get the money but it will have high interest rate and Tesla stock will come down 20-50 percent. Currently Tesla is producing 20% of it's target. Their production curve is not growing steeply enough. In fact it's slowing down. https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/
- nopriorarrests 9y agoThose production targets were established for a reason. Tesla is burning unbelievable amounts of cash [0], and they need to convince investors and bond holders that they will break this trend soon. Showing very agressive production targets for M3 is the only way to do it. [0] https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/02/tesla-loses-another-675-million-in-q4-its-biggest-quarterly-loss-yet/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/02/tesla-loses-another-675... "Tesla loses another $675 million in Q4, its biggest quarterly loss yet"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- slg 9y agoTesla's bond offerings are routinely oversubscribed. The market is clearly willing to continue to give them more and more money. I therefore find the idea dubious that Tesla needed to be super aggressive with their production targets or else they would run out of cash.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> Tesla's bond offerings are routinely oversubscribed. Historically, this does not count for much. Business history is littered with the bones of infallible stars that just needed a little cash to tide them over.
- nopriorarrests 9y agoIf I recall correctly, their last offering was more or less positioned like "according to our production estimates, this is, probably, last time we ask capital markets for cash infusion", and it was at the height of excitement about the Model 3. As of now, however, these bonds (1.8bln, issued last August) are trading underwater [0]. They will probably tap the market once again this year, and we will see what happen. [0] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/teslas-junk-bonds-are-trading-under-water-and-it-could-spell-trouble-for-elon-musk-2017-11-10 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/teslas-junk-bonds-are-trad...
- 9y ago