6 ms·
My bullish position on Tesla goes like this: They had the same production problems on the roadster, the Model S, and the Model X. Each time, the new vehicle wa
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
My bullish position on Tesla goes like this:
They had the same production problems on the roadster, the Model S, and the Model X. Each time, the new vehicle was a “make or break” for the company. Each time, there were reports of how these production problems would sink the company. The company never sank. Tesla is now apparently “good” at making the Model S and Model X. I always assumed they would have similar nightmarish production problems with the Model 3, so all of these reports are sort of expected for me. But I also know that Teslas are extremely popular in Silicon Valley, where I live. That to me indicates that those with the means really like the cars. So it stands to reason that once they are good at making an affordable car, they’ll sell like hot cakes.
Musk mentioned recently that two things really stress him out: Artifical Intelligence and what to do about the risks is poses for humanity, and the Model 3 launch. I still have a lot of faith that Elon can make it happen.
And personally I really want Tesla to succeed. I think a lot of other people do too.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> The company never sank. The company refreshed its financing. This is always possible, until it isn't. > That to me indicates that those with the means really like the cars. Cashflow is no respecter of brand power.
- skybrian 9y agoBrand power can result in more sales, though, which usually does increase cash flow? We don't know yet at what point they'll transition from being supply-limited to demand-limited. Tesla owners seem to be pretty forgiving of quality issues so far. We'll see how well that holds up.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> Brand power can result in more sales, though, which usually does increase cash flow? Yes, when you can get to the point where cash changes hand (this may be a very different moment from the "sale"). If cash shows up too late, then it doesn't matter how much demand there is, the game is over. Endings from cashflow crunch can be very abrupt. A very dangerous time for many companies is under conditions of growth, because very often your outgoing cash happens now and your incoming cash comes later. Tesla has to pay its employees each month, has to pay its suppliers on time (or lose them), pay its utility bills etc etc. The outgoing cash does not stop going out. But the bulk of the cash comes in only when they can hand a car over. And that's not happening very fast right now. The monthly outgoings per-car appear to be negative.
- agumonkey 9y agoTesla is the bitcoin of EVs :) or maybe it's the other way around. I think Musk persona and SpaceX makes many want to bet on high risk but high gains project. I wonder how Tesla stock did after the dual rocket landing.
- kakarot 9y agoPlease explain the relationship between Bitcoin and Tesla, other than "high risk but high gains".
- sabujp 9y agoafter looking at the monroe video on the 3, i'm waiting for the all EV camry that goes 400 mi on a charge
- dave1619 9y agoYou might be waiting 10 years?
- slg 9y agoI do wonder if Tesla's biggest problem around the Model 3 launch was starting by establishing very aggressive production targets. According to Bloomberg's Model 3 Tracker linked in that article, the Model 3 already is the top selling electric car in the country. It outsold the Chevy Bolt by over 2x in January and February. That should be a huge accomplishment, but it is viewed as a failure because it is a small fraction of what Tesla initially predicted.
- robterrell 9y agoCherry-picking Jan and Feb obscures the fact that the Bolt seems to be extremely competitive. Bolt outsold Tesla Model 3 by 3x in Dec (3,227 versus 1,060). And it's true that January was down for the Bolt, but not by 2x (1,177 versus 1,875). Tesla's production woes are a serious problem. My i3 lease is up in a couple of months and I can't even consider replacing it with a Model 3, since the end of the reservation line is years out.
- slg 9y agoAccording to the previously mentioned Bloomberg tracker, Tesla built 5,933 in January and February. Tesla is selling and delivering the Model 3 as fast as they can built them. GM delivered 2,601 Bolts in January and February. Choosing January and February is not cherry picking because Tesla is ramping up production of the Model 3. That said, I acknowledge that the Bolt may have some seasonal effect that greatly increased sales at the end of last year when compared to the beginning of this year. Let's expand the January-February window back another month to account for that. We get 6,993 Model 3s versus 5,828 Bolts. No longer over 2x but still clearly outselling the Bolt.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Judgmentality 9y agoIt's also worth mentioning that the Bolt is a loss leader for GM, so they are actually losing money on those cars. I think it's reasonable to worry that the economics for Tesla, who have far less experience manufacturing cars at scale, could be even worse. I am bearish on Tesla, but I never thought they would get this far, so obviously I've been wrong before. My suspicion though is if Tesla isn't self-sustaining before the next economic downturn, they're fucked.
- ams6110 9y agoI'm indifferent on whether Tesla succeeds. I do appreciate that they sparked a modern revival of EV technology, and I'd be happy if some day an EV made sense for me. At this time, it does not. Range is still too short and charge times too long.
- mjamesaustin 9y agoDo you travel more than 200 miles in a day frequently? For me, an EV is so much better because I can charge every night and I won't have to go anywhere to fill up my tank ever again.
- ams6110 9y agoDepends. At least a couple of times a month. And arranging rentals or owning another car for those trips is not really appealing. Another big reason is that I don't buy new cars. So for an EV to make sense for me it would need to be a used one, at least 5 years old, and still have useful range and battery life.
- nickbauman 9y agoMany EV owners who moved back to gas or hybrid cars find the hunt for gas stations and time spent on fill ups infuriating. You can charge an EV from any mains, very quickly on the special mains installed in your own garage. If you're commuting hundreds of miles per day, my heart goes out to you regardless.
- jcadam 9y agoI also see more Teslas than I would expect here in Florida. It's apparently catching on with the retirees-with-money demographic. Along with all the old boomers buying sports cars - porsches, corvettes, etc., it's getting harder to identify and avoid all of the older, dangerous drivers anymore. They used to have the courtesy to identify themselves by driving giant full-size Cadillacs and Buicks :(
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI'm in Tampa, and I can't tell you how many times people ask me about my Model S when I'm parked somewhere. I made a flyer, ran off 500 copies, and just hand those to people when they ask instead of spending 15-30 minutes explaining everything. I can tell its moving the needle based on my referral code stats.
- nopriorarrests 9y agoI think you are applying the software startup metric to industrial company. For typical SV startup lack of demand is the single most critical issue (hence the "make something people want" YC motto), nothing comes close. Tesla has plenty of demand. But being industrial company, Tesla is not solely about making something people want. It's about making it on scale, and showing profit. So far, each model Tesla made meant more debt on balance sheet, and bigger quarterly losses. Once they break this trend, they are golden. But this moment is not yet, and not even on the horizon, meaning another capital rise this year.
- Jdam 9y ago> And personally I really want Tesla to succeed. That, instead of a sound financial analysis, seems to be the cause of your bullish position. I hope you’re not calling what you’re doing with your money “investing”.
- aerovistae 9y agoHow many times have you predicted Tesla's demise over the past 10 years? Just like those people on radio shows believing they've identified the impending end of the world.
- Jdam 9y agoI’m not in the finance industry, hence I’m not predicting anything. I rather read analyses some pros do.
- aerovistae 9y agoAnd how many times have these 'pros' predicted Tesla's demise in the last 10 years? How many times does someone have to be wrong before you stop standing behind their opinions?
- Jdam 9y agoIf you listen to Graham&Dodd types, I can’t recall a case where they’ve been totally wrong. Btw Tesla is a public company for less than 10 years.
- dang 9y agoWould you please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and abide by the rules when commenting here? We don't want snark—it's both a poison and a fertilizer. I'm dismayed to see that you've posted uncivil comments in the past as well.
- Nokinside 9y agoAll the previous models and problems with them happened in small production volume luxury car segment. Luxury car customers tolerate more defects and it's economical to repair them quickly with good service. Model 3 is completely different animal. Learning from history does not help here. Model 3 is 'entry level luxury' similar to Audi A4 and BMW 3 Series. Tesla is very creative and innovative in every level, not just in their technology. Their financial innovation has finally reached it's limit with Model 3 and it's the breaking point. They can't afford large setbacks or partial delivery and gradual development over the years. They are running out of cheap money. Tesla is leveraged to the gills and there can't be another year or two until delivery or Musk loses the company and some other car maker or PE firm buys them cheap and finishes the product. I wouldn't be surprised if Tesla is GM or Toyota brand within next five years. https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/
- wpietri 9y ago> So it stands to reason that once they are good at making an affordable car, they’ll sell like hot cakes. For me, this puts the cart very much before the horse. Once they're good? Making an expensive car is much, much easier than making an affordable one. The fact that they previously struggled with making an expensive one could just as well be a sign that their process improvement and cost reduction skills just aren't good enough to play in the big leagues. Their being at 15% of projected output sure doesn't conflict with that; if they learned a lot from S and X, I'd think they'd be doing much better.
- simonsarris 9y agoYeah, my bull case is similar. People forget just how bad the Model X launch was. It was a complete disaster. They had I think literally three of them ready for launch and then total silence for weeks. Then took months to get any sort of small run volume off the ground. And because people have totally forgotten about that, people will probably totally forget about just how (comparatively mildly!) bad the Model 3 launch is going. It will stutter for a year, and in three years everyone will want one. I lived through my dad owning 4 Jaguars, totally inexplicably. One of them he carried around a box of brake fluid because he had to add a little each day. If a car is that special to you, you just mentally set aside production issues. Electric cars are even more special. Enzo Ferrari probably never said the apocryphal quote: "I don't care if the door gaps are straight. When the driver steps on the gas I want him to shit his pants." But for a big demographic its essentially true. So Tesla will make it out of this year, and then everyone will forget that the Model 3 ever had problems in the first place, just like with the X.
- brian-armstrong 9y agoI find it amusing that in a forum that gets angry about cults of personality, this comment is on top